Ig Nobel Prizes 2002
The ceremony of 3 October 2002 at Harvard's Sanders Theatre handed out ten prizes to research that looks like a joke and jokes that look like research. There were ostriches in love, elephants to be measured and a device that translates dog into Japanese. I took notes on a 1.44 MB floppy: more than enough.
- Winners
- Norma Bubier, Charles G. M. Paxton, Phil Bowers and D. Charles Deeming (United Kingdom)
- Citation
- For their report on the courtship behaviour of ostriches towards humans on British farms.
- Reference
- “Courtship Behaviour of Ostriches Towards Humans Under Farming Conditions in Britain”, British Poultry Science, vol. 39, no. 4, 1998
- Winners
- Arnd Leike (Germany)
- Citation
- For demonstrating that beer froth obeys the mathematical law of exponential decay.
- Reference
- “Demonstration of the Exponential Decay Law Using Beer Froth”, European Journal of Physics, vol. 23, no. 1, 2002
Professor Leike, in Munich, was looking for a way to explain exponential decay, the kind radioactive nuclei do, to his students. Instead of uranium he used beer: pour, measure the height of the froth over time, plot the curve. It works brilliantly, and disposing of the lab materials is a pleasure.
Perfect teaching: an abstract concept made concrete and even drinkable. I once tried to explain disk fragmentation with a cake. The disk is still fragmented; the cake is not.
- Winners
- Karl Kruszelnicki (Australia)
- Citation
- For performing a comprehensive survey of human belly button lint: who gets it, when, what colour and how much.
Dr Karl, an Australian science communicator, collected thousands of answers to a questionnaire on navel fluff. Out came a profile: it is more common in slightly hairy, middle-aged men, and the abdominal hairs funnel it towards the centre like a conveyor belt.
A fine piece of statistics on data nobody had ever collected. Just like the first person who decided to log how many times users hit F5 out of despair. Useless data? No: data waiting for someone curious enough to look at it.
- Winners
- Theodore Gray (USA and Switzerland)
- Citation
- For gathering many elements of the periodic table and assembling them into the form of a four-legged periodic table table.
Theodore Gray, co-founder of a mathematical software company, took the expression “periodic table” literally. He built a wooden table with a compartment for each element and filled it with real samples, where possible without putting the office at risk.
It is every nerd's dream: a piece of furniture that is also a database. I have a drawer with every cable from the last century, sorted by connector type. It is not the same thing, but I'd like to point out that it too contains some rare elements.
- Winners
- K. P. Sreekumar and the late G. Nirmalan (India)
- Citation
- For analytically estimating the total surface area of Indian elephants.
- Reference
- “Estimation of the Total Surface Area in Indian Elephants”, Veterinary Research Communications, vol. 14, no. 1, 1990
How much skin does an elephant have? To dose drugs and understand how it loses heat, someone needed to know. The two researchers from Kerala developed a formula based on measurements taken from the animal, avoiding the impractical alternative of wrapping it in brown paper.
It is a serious problem disguised as a riddle, like working out how much cable you need to wire a warehouse. On paper it's simple. Then you get there and find that the elephant, like the warehouse, has lots of folds nobody put on the floor plan.
- Winners
- Vicki Silvers Gier and David S. Kreiner (USA)
- Citation
- For their report on the effects of pre-existing inappropriate highlighting on reading comprehension.
- Reference
- “The Effects of Pre-Existing Inappropriate Highlighting on Reading Comprehension”, Reading Research and Instruction, vol. 36, no. 3, 1997
Anyone who has bought a second-hand textbook knows the drama: someone before you has highlighted the wrong sentences in yellow. The two psychologists tested whether this hurts comprehension, and yes, misplaced highlighting can distract and confuse the reader.
It is the same effect as code comments left by the previous colleague: “IMPORTANT!!!” on a line that does nothing, and total silence on the function holding up the whole website. The highlighter, like the comment, is a weapon. It should require a licence.
- Winners
- Keita Sato, Matsumi Suzuki and Norio Kogure (Japan)
- Citation
- For promoting peace and harmony between the species by inventing Bow-Lingual, a computer-based dog-to-human language translation device.
Bow-Lingual was a small gadget to clip onto the collar: it analysed barking and showed the dog's mood on a display, happy, sad, frustrated, on guard. A real commercial product, born from a meeting between a toy company, an acoustics lab and a vet.
At last a human-dog interface with simultaneous translation. Now I need the printer version: I'd like to know what it really means when it says “paper jam” and there isn't a single sheet in the tray. I suspect that, like the dog, it just wants attention.
- Winners
- Eduardo Segura (Spain)
- Citation
- For inventing a washing machine for cats and dogs.
Eduardo Segura, in Tarragona, designed a machine for washing pets: a cabin in which the animal is wetted, soaped, rinsed and dried, with different programmes depending on size. No spin cycle, let's make that clear at once, for everyone's peace of mind.
Pure automation applied to a task every cat owner regards as a suicide mission. I admire the courage: anyone who has tried to bath a cat knows the real problem isn't the water. It's the testing phase.
- Winners
- Executives, directors and auditors of Enron, WorldCom, Adelphia, Arthur Andersen, Xerox and some twenty-five other companies (various countries)
- Citation
- For adapting the mathematical concept of imaginary numbers for use in the business world.
A satirical prize dedicated to the accounting and corporate scandals of those years, many of which ended in investigations, restructurings or bankruptcies. The citation plays on imaginary numbers, the mathematical kind, which exist only in calculations.
As a technician I'll stick to a lesson in method: a set of accounts, like a backup, is only worth something if someone actually tries to restore it. As long as it is just a green icon saying “all fine”, it is an imaginary number too. Checking is not distrust: it's maintenance.
- Winners
- Chris McManus (United Kingdom)
- Citation
- For his study of scrotal asymmetry in man and in ancient sculpture.
- Reference
- “Scrotal Asymmetry in Man and in Ancient Sculpture”, Nature, vol. 259, 1976
Professor McManus, who has always studied left and right in the human body, noticed something: in men the right testicle tends to sit higher. Then he went to check ancient statues and found that Greek sculptors often depicted the opposite, with the left one higher.
It is quality control on historical data: the artists had the model right in front of them, and still got the detail wrong. Like software manuals describing buttons that no longer exist. Even marble, it seems, has documentation bugs.
On English farms the ostriches were courting. Not each other: the farmers. Dances, outspread wings, bows. The researchers observed and documented the phenomenon, noting that human presence could confuse the birds at the most romantic moment of their lives.
It is a configuration problem: the ostrich has the right mating protocol but the wrong destination address. Like the network printer that keeps sending documents to the boss's office. So much love to give, and no subnet mask.