Ig Nobel Prizes 2020
On 17 September 2020, because of the pandemic, the 30th First Annual Ig Nobel Prize Ceremony takes place online only for the first time, pre-recorded and streamed. The theme was insects, with the mini-opera “Dream, Little Cockroach”. At last, a ceremony where the problem was everyone else's connection.
- Winners
- Stephan Reber, Takeshi Nishimura, Judith Janisch, Mark Robertson and Tecumseh Fitch (Austria, Sweden, Japan, USA, Switzerland)
- Citation
- For inducing a female Chinese alligator to bellow in an airtight chamber filled with helium-enriched air.
- Reference
- “A Chinese Alligator in Heliox: Formant Frequencies in a Crocodilian”, Journal of Experimental Biology, 2015
- Winners
- Miranda Giacomin and Nicholas Rule (Canada, USA)
- Citation
- For devising a method to identify narcissists by examining their eyebrows.
- Reference
- “Eyebrows Cue Grandiose Narcissism”, Journal of Personality, 2019
In the study, participants could estimate a person's narcissism from a photo of their face, and the strongest clue was the eyebrows: thick, well defined, groomed. Narcissists, it seems, care a great deal about their own frame.
I'm applying the method to my work at once. The IT narcissist can be recognised by his desktop: wallpaper with his own photo, icons aligned to the millimetre, PC name the same as his own name. I have a messy desktop and unkempt eyebrows. So I'm humble. Or just lazy.
- Winners
- The governments of India and Pakistan
- Citation
- For having their diplomats surreptitiously ring each other's doorbells in the middle of the night, and then run away before anyone had a chance to answer the door.
- Reference
- Numerous press articles
According to the reports cited by the committee, for a time diplomats of the two countries were the victims of night-time doorbell ringing, with the culprit fleeing immediately. The oldest prank in the world, at the level of international relations.
The Peace prize has its own logic: it's the lowest-intensity conflict ever documented. No damage, just doorbells. In IT we call it a ping: you knock, you run, and you measure how long it takes to answer. Proposal for the next international conference: all disagreements settled by ping.
- Winners
- Ivan Maksymov and Andrey Pototsky (Australia, Ukraine and others)
- Citation
- For determining, experimentally, what happens to the shape of a living earthworm when one vibrates the earthworm at high frequency.
- Reference
- “Excitation of Faraday-like Body Waves in Vibrated Living Earthworms”, bioRxiv, 2019
The two physicists placed earthworms on a loudspeaker and made them vibrate. Ripples formed on their surface, similar to the waves that appear on a vibrating liquid, the so-called Faraday waves. The earthworm, for science, became a little acoustics lab.
It's one of those rare cases where a living being behaves like my old hard drive: it vibrates, it wobbles and it seems to be thinking. The earthworm, it should be said, was treated kindly and apparently lost no data.
- Winners
- Christopher Watkins, Juan David Leongómez, Jeanne Bovet, Agnieszka Żelaźniewicz and colleagues (United Kingdom, Poland, France, Brazil, Chile, Colombia, Australia, Italy, Norway)
- Citation
- For trying to quantify the relationship between different countries' national income inequality and the average amount of mouth-to-mouth kissing.
- Reference
- “National Income Inequality Predicts Cultural Variation in Mouth to Mouth Kissing”, Scientific Reports, 2019
With a questionnaire in thirteen countries, the researchers found that where economic inequality is greater, couples report kissing more. One hypothesis: in more uncertain settings, kissing helps strengthen the bond and keep the relationship steady.
Correlation, of course, is not causation. You cannot hope to reduce the national debt by kissing less. But as an economic indicator it strikes me as friendlier than bond spreads. I can picture a financial news bulletin: “Kisses down, markets uncertain, hug rate stable”.
- Winners
- Xi Guang-An, Mo Tian-Xiang, Yang Kang-Sheng, Yang Guang-Sheng and Ling Xian Si (China)
- Citation
- Five professional hitmen from the Guangxi region: one accepts a contract for a murder, then subcontracts it to the second, who subcontracts it to the third, and so on down to the fifth, each keeping a share of the fee. In the end none of them carries out the murder.
- Reference
- Press articles and court records
The story is true and ended up in court: the target was not killed, the last man in the chain suggested he stage his own death, and the whole affair ended up with the police. Nobody was hurt, except the reputation of subcontracting.
It's the perfect portrait of every big IT project. The client commissions, the agency passes it on, the supplier delegates, the freelancer subcontracts, and the last one, with a budget of two euros, does nothing. The site never goes live. But the invoicing system works beautifully.
- Winners
- Richard Vetter (USA)
- Citation
- For collecting evidence that many entomologists (scientists who study insects) are afraid of spiders, which are not insects.
- Reference
- “Arachnophobic Entomologists: When Two More Legs Makes a Big Difference”, American Entomologist, 2013
Richard Vetter, a spider expert, surveyed his fellow entomologists. Many of them handle cockroaches, wasps and larvae without a problem, but recoil at the sight of a spider. Two extra legs are enough to change everything.
It happens in IT too. I know sysadmins capable of fixing any server who won't touch a printer. It's a peripheral, so technically outside their remit. But the real reason is different: the printer has eight legs. We all know it. At night, it moves.
- Winners
- Nienke Vulink, Damiaan Denys and Arnoud van Loon (Netherlands, Belgium)
- Citation
- For diagnosing a long-unrecognized medical condition: misophonia, the distress at hearing other people make chewing sounds.
- Reference
- “Misophonia: Diagnostic Criteria for a New Psychiatric Disorder”, PLoS ONE, 2013; “Cognitive Behavioral Therapy is Effective in Misophonia: An Open Trial”, Journal of Affective Disorders, 2017
The Amsterdam psychiatrists proposed precise criteria for recognising misophonia: intense anger or distress at sounds such as chewing, noisy breathing or ticking. And they showed that cognitive behavioural therapy can help. Real relief for many people.
As a technician I know a professional variant: irritation at the compulsive clicking of a pen during meetings. Or the colleague who eats crisps in front of the keyboard. And the crumbs between the keys are a problem for the hardware too.
- Winners
- Jair Bolsonaro (Brazil), Boris Johnson (United Kingdom), Narendra Modi (India), Andrés Manuel López Obrador (Mexico), Alexander Lukashenko (Belarus), Donald Trump (USA), Recep Tayyip Erdoğan (Turkey), Vladimir Putin (Russia) and Gurbanguly Berdimuhamedow (Turkmenistan)
- Citation
- For using the Covid-19 viral pandemic to teach the world that politicians can have a more immediate effect on life and death than scientists and doctors can.
- Reference
- Numerous press articles
The committee awarded the prize collectively to nine heads of state and government of the time, as a general reflection on the weight of political decisions during the pandemic. It's a satirical prize, with an unusually long and unusually famous list of winners.
Here the IT commentator does the only sensible thing: he notes the general lesson and adds nothing more. The moral, valid for every machine room, is simple: decisions taken at the top reach the bottom faster than any update.
- Winners
- Metin Eren, Michelle Bebber, James Norris, Alyssa Perrone, Ashley Rutkoski, Michael Wilson and Mary Ann Raghanti (USA, United Kingdom)
- Citation
- For showing that knives manufactured from frozen human feces do not work well.
- Reference
- “Experimental Replication Shows Knives Manufactured from Frozen Human Feces Do Not Work”, Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports, 2019
An ethnographic tale was doing the rounds about a man in the Arctic who supposedly made himself a knife from his own frozen excrement. The archaeologists decided to check: one of them followed a suitable diet for days, then they shaped the blade and chilled it to extremely low temperatures. On meat, the blade melted. Myth busted.
This is the true scientific spirit: don't trust the legend, redo the experiment. Even when nobody, really nobody, wanted anyone to redo it. Like when a user says “a video said so”. You check. Wearing gloves.
Helium changes the resonances of the vocal tract: it's the cartoon-voice trick. The researchers used it on an alligator to find out whether reptiles also use these resonances to communicate their size. The answer is yes, and the alligator's voice changed.
The detail to appreciate: someone had the nerve to shut an alligator in a gas chamber and wait for it to sing. That takes more courage than updating the accounting software on a Friday afternoon. But only just.