Skip to content
CONTACT

Ig Nobel Prizes 2014

On 18 September 2014, at Harvard's Sanders Theatre, the 24th First Annual Ig Nobel Prize Ceremony is held and broadcast live. For Italy it's a medal-table year: two prizes, one for Art and one for Economics. The Spanish Nutrition winners can't attend and give their thanks by video, because even at the Ig Nobels everyone works remotely now.

PHYSICS2014 · #1
Winners
Kiyoshi Mabuchi, Kensei Tanaka, Daichi Uchijima and Rina Sakai (Japan)
Citation
For measuring the amount of friction between a shoe and a banana skin, and between a banana skin and the floor, when a person steps on a banana skin that's on the floor.
Reference
K. Mabuchi, K. Tanaka, D. Uchijima and R. Sakai, “Frictional Coefficient under Banana Skin”, Tribology Online, vol. 7, no. 3, 2012, pp. 147-151.

The oldest gag in silent cinema finally has a number. The Japanese researchers put banana skins on the floor, put a shoe on top and measured how much it slipped. Result: the skin cuts friction about sixfold compared with the bare floor, because when squashed it releases a slippery gel.

Here's scientific proof that comedy is grounded in physics. Their real interest was joint lubrication, so there's a medical application too. Meanwhile I've added “banana” to the server room risk assessment. The safety officer asked for an explanation. I sent him the PDF.

NEUROSCIENCE2014 · #2
Winners
Jiangang Liu, Jun Li, Lu Feng, Ling Li, Jie Tian (China) and Kang Lee (Canada)
Citation
For trying to understand what happens in the brains of people who see the face of Jesus in a piece of toast.
Reference
J. Liu, J. Li, L. Feng, L. Li, J. Tian and K. Lee, “Seeing Jesus in toast: Neural and behavioral correlates of face pareidolia”, Cortex, vol. 53, 2014, pp. 60-77.

The phenomenon is called pareidolia: seeing faces where there are none, in clouds, in plug sockets, in bread. Volunteers were shown images of pure noise and told that half contained a hidden face or letter. Many “saw” them, and their brains lit up in the areas used to recognise real faces.

Our brain is facial-recognition software tuned never to miss a face, even at the cost of finding too many. Early neural networks did the same, seeing dogs everywhere. I see an angry face on the front panel of the old server. But there, I believe, it really is angry.

PSYCHOLOGY2014 · #3
Winners
Peter K. Jonason, Amy Jones and Minna Lyons (UK, Finland, Australia, USA)
Citation
For amassing evidence that people who habitually stay up late are, on average, more self-admiring, more manipulative and more psychopathic than people who habitually rise early in the morning.
Reference
P.K. Jonason, A. Jones and M. Lyons, “Creatures of the night: Chronotypes and the Dark Triad traits”, Personality and Individual Differences, vol. 55, no. 5, 2013, pp. 538-541.

The study cross-referenced the sleep habits of a few hundred people with questionnaires on the darkest personality traits. Night owls, on average, score slightly higher. On average, I stress, because here I feel personally targeted.

I'm a sysadmin. Updates are done at night, when nobody's using the servers. So my psychopathy is a contractual requirement. I don't manipulate anyone: I persuade users to change their passwords, and that's a public service. Vanity? Only about my uptime. I signed a petition to have the study redone at three in the morning. Nobody else signed: they were asleep.

PUBLIC HEALTH2014 · #4
Winners
Jaroslav Flegr, Jan Havlíček and Jitka Hanušova-Lindova; and David Hanauer, Naren Ramakrishnan and Lisa Seyfried (Czech Republic, Japan, USA, India)
Citation
For investigating whether it is mentally hazardous for a human being to own a cat.
Reference
J. Flegr and J. Havlíček, “Changes in the personality profile of young women with latent toxoplasmosis”, Folia Parasitologica, vol. 46, 1999, pp. 22-28; D. Hanauer, N. Ramakrishnan and L. Seyfried, “Describing the Relationship between Cat Bites and Human Depression Using Data from an Electronic Health Record”, PLoS ONE, vol. 8, no. 8, 2013, e70585.

Two lines of research. The Czech team studied a parasite that cats can transmit and its possible effects on the personality of its host. The American team trawled through millions of medical records and found an association between cat bites and diagnoses of depression. Association, not cause: perhaps sad people simply get bitten more.

Anyone who owns a cat knows the animal has full admin rights over the house. It sits on the keyboard, walks on the mouse, switches the computer off with its tail. I don't know whether it harms the mind. I do know mine has stopped arguing.

BIOLOGY2014 · #5
Winners
Vlastimil Hart, Petra Nováková, Erich Pascal Malkemper, Sabine Begall, Hynek Burda and colleagues (Czech Republic, Germany, Zambia)
Citation
For carefully documenting that when dogs defecate and urinate, they prefer to align their body axis with Earth's north-south geomagnetic field lines.
Reference
V. Hart et al., “Dogs are sensitive to small variations of the Earth's magnetic field”, Frontiers in Zoology, vol. 10, 2013, article 80.

Seventy dogs, two years of walks, thousands of observations recorded compass in hand. Result: when the magnetic field is calm, dogs prefer to line up north-south before doing their business. When the field is disturbed, the preference vanishes.

So the dog's circling before it stops isn't indecision, it's compass calibration. The same dance I do with my phone to find a signal in the cellar. Whoever collected this data spent two years watching dogs in their most private moments, with scientific seriousness. I find it heroic. And a little embarrassing for the dog.

ART2014 · #6
Winners
Marina de Tommaso, Michele Sardaro and Paolo Livrea (Italy)
Citation
For measuring the relative pain people suffer while looking at an ugly painting rather than a pretty one, while being shot in the hand by a powerful laser beam.
Reference
M. de Tommaso, M. Sardaro and P. Livrea, “Aesthetic value of paintings affects pain thresholds”, Consciousness and Cognition, vol. 17, no. 4, 2008, pp. 1152-1162.

Volunteers, paintings chosen as beautiful, neutral or ugly, and a laser delivering a small painful pulse to the hand. Looking at masterpieces, the perceived pain was lower than in front of works judged ugly. Beauty, quite literally, acts as an anaesthetic.

An Italian prize for Art: how proud. And an immediate application: I demand that every tech-support waiting room have a beautiful painting on the wall, not the usual toner supplier's calendar. Being told your warranty has expired still hurts. But in front of a lovely landscape, perhaps it hurts a little less.

ECONOMICS2014 · #7
Winners
ISTAT, the Italian National Institute of Statistics (Italy)
Citation
For proudly taking the lead in fulfilling the European Union mandate for each country to increase the official size of its national economy by including revenues from prostitution, illegal drugs, smuggling and all other unlawful financial transactions between willing participants.
Reference
ISTAT, “Cambia il Sistema europeo dei conti nazionali e regionali - Sec2010”, 2014; “European System of National and Regional Accounts (ESA 2010)”, Publications Office of the European Union, 2013.

The fact is technical: the new European national accounting rules require some illegal activities, such as drugs, prostitution and smuggling, to be estimated in gross domestic product, so as to measure the economy completely. ISTAT was among the first institutes to announce it was applying the new rules, and the prize followed.

It's an accounting problem every sysadmin knows: if you measure network traffic, you also have to count what shouldn't be there. Otherwise the chart is beautiful and completely false. I've applied it to my office: the productivity count now includes unauthorised coffee breaks. The result has gone up forty per cent.

MEDICINE2014 · #8
Winners
Ian Humphreys, Sonal Saraiya, Walter Belenky and James Dworkin (USA, India)
Citation
For treating “uncontrollable” nosebleeds, using the method of packing the nostrils with strips of cured pork.
Reference
I. Humphreys, S. Saraiya, W. Belenky and J. Dworkin, “Nasal Packing With Strips of Cured Pork as Treatment for Uncontrollable Epistaxis in a Patient with Glanzmann Thrombasthenia”, Annals of Otology, Rhinology and Laryngology, vol. 120, no. 11, 2011, pp. 732-736.

A little girl with a rare clotting disorder had nosebleeds that wouldn't stop with the usual methods. The doctors dug out an old remedy: strips of cured pork pushed into the nose, which seem to contain factors that help stop bleeding. It worked.

A true technician's solution: when the official procedure fails, you open the drawer of old things and try the one that used to work. Like my grandfather's screwdriver that opens every modern computer. Coming from the land of salami, I feel only a mild unease at the waste of good charcuterie. But health comes first.

ARCTIC SCIENCE2014 · #9
Winners
Eigil Reimers and Sindre Eftestøl (Norway, Germany, USA, Canada)
Citation
For testing how reindeer react to seeing humans disguised as polar bears.
Reference
E. Reimers and S. Eftestøl, “Response Behaviors of Svalbard Reindeer towards Humans and Humans Disguised as Polar Bears on Edgeøya”, Arctic, Antarctic, and Alpine Research, vol. 44, no. 4, 2012, pp. 483-489.

On Svalbard, polar bears are increasingly showing up near reindeer. Question: do the reindeer recognise the predator? Experimental answer: a researcher dresses up as a polar bear and approaches. The reindeer fled sooner and further than when a normally dressed human approached.

It's a full-blown penetration test: you disguise yourself as a threat and see whether the system notices. In companies we do it with fake phishing emails. The reindeer, apparently, passed the test better than the accounts department. Not one of them clicked on the bear's link.

NUTRITION2014 · #10
Winners
Raquel Rubio, Anna Jofré, Belén Martín, Teresa Aymerich and Margarita Garriga (Spain)
Citation
For their study entitled “Characterization of Lactic Acid Bacteria Isolated from Infant Faeces as Potential Probiotic Starter Cultures for Fermented Sausages”.
Reference
R. Rubio, A. Jofré, B. Martín, T. Aymerich and M. Garriga, “Characterization of lactic acid bacteria isolated from infant faeces as potential probiotic starter cultures for fermented sausages”, Food Microbiology, vol. 38, 2014, pp. 303-311.

The good bacteria used to ferment cured sausages must be safe and able to withstand the human gut. Where do you find bacteria already selected for that? In babies' guts, of course, collected from nappies. The Spanish team isolated them and tried using them as a “starter” for probiotic sausages.

The study's title is impeccable and at the same time impossible to read out at dinner. Same problem as corporate file names: all true, all precise, and nobody wants to open them. At the deli counter I shall continue not to ask questions. Sometimes complete documentation is a risk.