Skip to content
CONTACT

Ig Nobel Prizes 2003

On 2 October 2003 at Harvard the prizes went, among other things, to Murphy's Law: if something can go wrong, it will. The same evening saw London taxi drivers, an entire country for rent and a man legally dead but very much active. Ten prizes, no system crash. Suspicious.

ENGINEERING2003 · #1
Winners
John Paul Stapp, Edward A. Murphy Jr. (both posthumously) and George Nichols (USA)
Citation
For giving birth in 1949 to Murphy's Law, the engineering principle that if something can be done the wrong way, someone will do it.
Reference
“The Fastest Man on Earth”, Annals of Improbable Research, vol. 9, no. 5, 2003

In 1949, during experiments on extreme deceleration with rocket sleds, some sensors were fitted the wrong way round. From that incident, and from the people involved in the project, came the most quoted sentence in server rooms across the planet. Stapp, the doctor who had himself brought to a sudden stop from insane speeds, made it famous.

To me it isn't a law: it's a technical specification. Every time a connector only fits one way, the universe tries the other way first. Three times. With the customer watching.

PHYSICS2003 · #2
Winners
Jack Harvey, John Culvenor, Warren Payne, Steve Cowley, Michael Lawrance, David Stuart and Robyn Williams (Australia)
Citation
For their report analysing the forces required to drag sheep over various surfaces.
Reference
“An Analysis of the Forces Required to Drag Sheep over Various Surfaces”, Applied Ergonomics, vol. 33, no. 6, 2002

In Australia shearers move sheep by dragging them, and their backs pay the price. This group of researchers measured how much force is needed depending on the floor, to find out which surface reduces fatigue and injury. Real ergonomics, with a woolly protagonist.

The title is funny; the result protects real people. Like the time I carried a thirty-kilo server up three floors because the lift had been “under maintenance forever”. Nobody had measured the friction of the carpet. I could have done with this paper.

MEDICINE2003 · #3
Winners
Eleanor Maguire, David Gadian, Ingrid Johnsrude, Catriona Good, John Ashburner, Richard Frackowiak and Christopher Frith (United Kingdom)
Citation
For presenting evidence that the brains of London taxi drivers are more highly developed than those of their fellow citizens.
Reference
“Navigation-Related Structural Change in the Hippocampi of Taxi Drivers”, PNAS, vol. 97, no. 8, 2000

To drive a cab in London you have to learn thousands of streets by heart, a legendary exam. The researchers scanned the taxi drivers and found the hippocampus, the area linked to navigation, larger in one part, the more so the longer they had been on the job.

The brain is hardware that expands with use. That is wonderful news and also slightly worrying: satnav, then, is freeing up disk space for us. It remains to be seen what we use it for. Forgotten passwords, I fear.

PSYCHOLOGY2003 · #4
Winners
Gian Vittorio Caprara, Claudio Barbaranelli (Italy) and Philip Zimbardo (USA)
Citation
For their report on the uniquely simple personalities of politicians.
Reference
“Politicians' Uniquely Simple Personalities”, Nature, vol. 385, 1997

Three psychologists, two of them from the University of Rome, asked Italian voters to describe both themselves and politicians using the classic personality traits. For ordinary people five dimensions were needed; for politicians, in the public's perception, two were enough.

It is not a verdict on politicians, but on how we see them: in low resolution, like an image compressed too many times. The same phenomenon whereby the techie, to his colleagues, has only two states: “working” and “broke something”. Everything else is lost in compression.

CHEMISTRY2003 · #5
Winners
Yukio Hirose (Japan)
Citation
For his chemical investigation of a bronze statue in Kanazawa that fails to attract pigeons.

In Kanazawa there was a bronze statue that pigeons carefully avoided, the only exception in a city full of statues decorated by birds. Professor Hirose found the reason: the metal contained arsenic, which pigeons apparently don't care for. The next idea was to use it to create a genuine eco-friendly repellent.

An exemplary piece of debugging: there is an anomaly, nobody notices, only one person asks why. I did the same with the only PC in the office that never caught a virus. It had been switched off since 2009.

LITERATURE2003 · #6
Winners
John Trinkaus (USA)
Citation
For meticulously publishing more than 80 academic reports about things that annoyed him.
Reference
“Trinkaus: An Informal Look”, Annals of Improbable Research, vol. 9, no. 3, 2003

Professor Trinkaus, a business lecturer in New York, counted the small irritations of daily life: how many young people wear baseball caps backwards, how many shoppers exceed the item limit at the express checkout, how many people can't stand Brussels sprouts. Then he published the results.

Annoyance turned into data science. Come to think of it, it is also the only sane way to run an IT department. For years I have kept a spreadsheet of people who print their emails to read them. I have never published it. Perhaps I'm wrong.

ECONOMICS2003 · #7
Winners
Karl Schwärzler and the Principality of Liechtenstein
Citation
For making it possible to rent the entire country for corporate conventions, weddings, bar mitzvahs and other gatherings.

Karl Schwärzler, an entrepreneur, had put together a surprising tourist offer: renting Liechtenstein, or large chunks of it, for private events, with fittings, custom signage and tailored hospitality. A real country, available like a conference hall.

It is cloud computing applied to geography: why buy a nation when you can rent it pay-as-you-go? I expect the subscription version any minute now, with a basic plan, a premium plan and an extra valley if you pay annually.

INTERDISCIPLINARY RESEARCH2003 · #8
Winners
Stefano Ghirlanda, Liselotte Jansson and Magnus Enquist (Sweden)
Citation
For their report entitled “Chickens Prefer Beautiful Humans”.
Reference
“Chickens Prefer Beautiful Humans”, Human Nature, vol. 13, no. 3, 2002

The Stockholm researchers trained chickens to react to human faces and found that their preferences matched those of a group of students. The serious point: the taste for certain features might depend on how image processing works in the brain in general, not just on human factors.

So even a chicken has a facial recognition algorithm. And it gives the same scores we do. Meanwhile I've had a new profile picture taken. You never know who's looking.

PEACE2003 · #9
Winners
Lal Bihari (India)
Citation
For a triple accomplishment: leading an active life even though he had been declared legally dead; waging a lively posthumous campaign against bureaucratic inertia and greedy relatives; and founding the Association of Dead People.

Lal Bihari, in Uttar Pradesh, discovered he was dead: a relative had had him recorded as deceased in the registers in order to grab his land. It took him about eighteen years to prove he was alive, and in the meantime he founded an association to help others in the same situation.

It is the ultimate case of the database being right against reality. I know the feeling well: once the management system deactivated my account and for three days I didn't exist. He was far more patient than me.

BIOLOGY2003 · #10
Winners
C. W. Moeliker (Netherlands)
Citation
For documenting the first scientifically recorded case of homosexual necrophilia in the mallard duck.
Reference
“The First Case of Homosexual Necrophilia in the Mallard Anas platyrhynchos”, Deinsea, vol. 8, 2001

Kees Moeliker, curator at the Rotterdam natural history museum, heard a thud against the museum's glass front: a mallard had crashed into it. What he saw in the following minutes, another male mating with the deceased, he noted down with a notary's precision and published.

Scientific observation in its purest form: don't judge, record. Like when you find absurd behaviour in a program and, instead of shouting, you open the log. Moeliker later became an ambassador for curious science. The mallard, sadly, did not.