Skip to content
CONTACT

Ig Nobel Prizes 1992

Second edition, in MIT's Kresge Auditorium. Nobel physicist Sheldon Glashow hands out the prizes wearing a sailor's hat, a jazz harpist plays all evening, and during the Nutrition prize tinned-meat sandwiches fly towards the audience.

This is the year the prize stops being an experiment and becomes a tradition. The same happens in IT: a temporary workaround that works twice in a row officially becomes architecture.

MEDICINE1992 · #1
Winners
F. Kanda, E. Yagi, M. Fukuda, K. Nakajima, T. Ohta and O. Nakata, Shiseido Research Center (Japan)
Citation
For their pioneering research study “Elucidation of Chemical Compounds Responsible for Foot Malodour”, especially for their conclusion that people who think they have foot odour do, and those who don't, don't.
Reference
Elucidation of Chemical Compounds Responsible for Foot Malodour, British Journal of Dermatology, 1990

The researchers isolated the compounds that give feet their unmistakable fragrance, in particular an acid produced by bacteria acting on sweat. Serious, useful work, especially for deodorant makers.

But the prize-winning conclusion is a masterpiece of logic: if you think you have a problem, you have one. Same rule as users who ring up saying their PC is slow. They are always right. The PC is slow. And there is usually also a toolbar installed in 2009 that nobody has ever clicked.

ARCHAEOLOGY1992 · #2
Winners
Éclaireurs de France, scouting organisation (France)
Citation
To the fresco erasers, for cleaning the walls of a cave near Bruniquel, France, and removing ancient prehistoric paintings.

A group of young scouts, armed with good intentions, went into a cave and saw walls covered in marks. They assumed it was vandal graffiti and started scrubbing. They were prehistoric paintings of bison.

It is the great tragedy of tidying up without checking first: like the zealous colleague who frees up space on the server by deleting that old folder with the funny name. It was called backup. It was a few thousand years old too, in computer time. Moral: before cleaning, ask. And make a copy. Of the bison as well.

ECONOMICS1992 · #3
Winners
The investors of Lloyd's of London (United Kingdom)
Citation
For their bold attempt to insure against disaster by refusing to pay for their own company's losses.

Lloyd's is the world's most famous insurance market, where private members underwrite risks with their own fortunes. Between the late Eighties and early Nineties came enormous losses, and many investors refused to cover them.

A textbook paradox: people who live off insurance discover that risk, every now and then, actually happens. Like the customer who has paid for support for years and is astonished when you ring to say the disk has failed. Failed? But I pay you precisely so it won't fail.

BIOLOGY1992 · #4
Winners
Cecil Jacobson (United States)
Citation
To the prolific sperm donor and patriarch of sperm banks, for devising a simple, single-handed method of quality control.

Behind the deliberately suggestive citation lies a real court case: the doctor, who ran a fertility clinic, was convicted of using his own sperm on patients without telling them, instead of that of anonymous donors.

The prize, in its irony, focuses on home-made quality control. Every IT person knows the risk: when developer, tester and end user are the same person, every test always passes. That is why separation of duties and code review exist. And apparently they would be useful elsewhere too.

CHEMISTRY1992 · #5
Winners
Ivette Bassa (United States)
Citation
To the constructor of colourful colloids, for her part in the crowning achievement of twentieth-century chemistry: the synthesis of bright blue Jell-O.

Ivette Bassa, a food industry chemist, helped create a sweet jelly in a vivid blue, a colour that barely exists in natural food. The prize solemnly calls it the crowning achievement of the century's chemistry.

I consider it a genuine conquest. Anyone can make a red jelly. It takes courage to make one the same colour as the Windows error screen and convince children to eat it. Now that is communication: taking the blue that terrifies technicians and turning it into a pudding.

PHYSICS1992 · #6
Winners
David Chorley and Doug Bower (United Kingdom)
Citation
To the lords of the low-energy hooligans, for their circular contributions to field theory based on the geometrical destruction of English crops.

For years the English countryside filled up with mysterious crop circles, blamed on vortices, unknown energies and, naturally, aliens. Then two gentlemen admitted they had made them themselves, at night, with a plank, a rope and a great deal of patience.

The pun is perfect: field theory, but wheat fields. And the lesson is precious for anyone working in support. When something inexplicable happens, before assuming a superior intelligence, check whether there is a colleague with a plank and too much free time.

PEACE1992 · #7
Winners
Daryl Gates, former Los Angeles police chief (United States)
Citation
For his uniquely compelling methods of bringing people together.

The prize must be read in the context of the time: Gates ran the Los Angeles police in the years of the Rodney King case and the 1992 riots, and his handling was widely criticised. The ironic citation talks about bringing people together.

At the ceremony the prize was collected by the owner of a camera shop, who seized the opportunity to talk about camcorders. And that may be the driest comment of the night: in those years an amateur camcorder changed public debate more than many press conferences.

NUTRITION1992 · #8
Winners
The consumers of SPAM (United States and the rest of the world)
Citation
To the courageous consumers of tinned food, for 54 years of undiscriminating digestion.

SPAM is the tinned meat born in 1937, faithful companion of soldiers, campers and larders across half the world. The prize does not go to those who make it, but to those who eat it: a collective tribute to the resilience of the human stomach.

We IT people owe a great deal to this little tin, which lent its name to junk email. The parallel holds: both arrive in industrial quantities, nobody remembers ordering them and someone, deep down, consumes them anyway. At the ceremony sandwiches were thrown at the audience. The first spam filter in history was a duck.

LITERATURE1992 · #9
Winners
Yuri Struchkov, Institute of Organoelement Compounds, Moscow (Russia)
Citation
To the unstoppable author who between 1981 and 1990 published 948 scientific papers, an average of one every 3.9 days.

Struchkov was a respected crystallographer who determined the structure of thousands of molecules, collaborating with a great many research groups. Result: his name appeared on a paper roughly every four days, for ten years.

That pace would put any update bulletin to shame. In ten years I have written less documentation than he wrote in a month, and mine was mostly sticky notes on the monitor. If papers were Windows updates, his computer would still be restarting.

ART1992 · #10
Winners
Jim Knowlton (United States) and the National Endowment for the Arts (United States)
Citation
To Jim Knowlton, modern Renaissance man, for his classic anatomical poster “Penises of the Animal Kingdom”, and to the federal arts agency, for encouraging him to turn it into a pop-up book.

Knowlton drew a scientific poster comparing, with the precision of an anatomical plate, the male reproductive organs of various species, from the armadillo to the whale. A public arts body, so the story went, suggested he make it into a book whose figures pop up as you open the pages.

It is the classic meeting where someone says: lovely document, but couldn't we make it interactive? In IT we know it well. You start with a PDF and end up with a 3D animation nobody asked for. At least here the subject guaranteed the surprise effect.