Ig Nobel Prizes 2021
The 31st Ig Nobel ceremony was held on 9 September 2021, still online only, streamed like the other pandemic years: for once, everyone threw their paper aeroplanes at their own monitor. Ten prizes, including two awarded almost as a pair: one for working out why pedestrians don't collide, the other for working out why sometimes they do. I watched it standing up, hand on heart and the router within rebooting distance.
- Winners
- Susanne Schötz, Robert Eklund, Joost van de Weijer (Sweden)
- Citation
- For analysing the variations in communication between cats and humans: purring, chirping, trilling, meowing, growling, hissing and all the other nuances of the feline repertoire.
- Reference
- Series of phonetic studies on the vocalisations of domestic cats (2011-2016), including “Melody in Human–Cat Communication (Meowsic)”.
- Winners
- Leila Satari, Alba Guillén, Àngela Vidal-Verdú, Manuel Porcar (Spain, Iran)
- Citation
- For using genetic analysis to identify the different species of bacteria that reside in wads of discarded chewing gum stuck on pavements in various countries.
- Reference
- “The Wasted Chewing Gum Bacteriome”, Scientific Reports, 2020.
They collected chewing gum from the pavements of several cities and sequenced its bacterial DNA. Every piece of gum is a little block of flats for microbes, and the population changes with the time the gum spends on the ground: first the tenants from the mouth, then those from the street.
It's exactly like an old PC in an office: somebody set it up in 2009, then programs arrived that nobody installed, and now an ecosystem lives in it. Nobody switches it off out of fear. It has its own biological dignity.
- Winners
- Jörg Wicker, Nicolas Krauter, Bettina Derstroff, Christof Stönner, Jonathan Williams and colleagues (Germany, United Kingdom, New Zealand, Greece, Cyprus, Austria)
- Citation
- For chemically analysing the air inside cinemas, to test whether the odours given off by the audience reliably indicate the level of violence, sex, bad language and other content in a film.
- Reference
- “Proof of Concept Study: Testing Human Volatile Organic Compounds as Tools for Age Classification of Films”, PLoS ONE, 2018; “Cinema Data Mining: The Smell of Fear”, proceedings of ACM SIGKDD, 2015.
They put sensors in cinemas and measured the substances the audience gives off during the film. Suspense scenes leave a chemical trace in the air. Without knowing it, the audience reviews the film with its breath.
It seems to me the definitive solution to the problem of online star ratings: no more fake votes, just air analysis. I propose applying it to company meetings. After forty minutes of slides on the three-year strategic plan, the instrument would report, with scientific precision, a lethal concentration of boredom.
- Winners
- Pavlo Blavatskyy (France, Switzerland, Australia, Austria, Czech Republic, United Kingdom)
- Citation
- For discovering that the obesity of a country's politicians may be a good indicator of that country's corruption.
- Reference
- “Obesity of Politicians and Corruption in Post-Soviet Countries”, Economics of Transition and Institutional Change, 2021.
The economist estimated the build of ministers from various post-Soviet countries from their official photos, and compared the figure with existing corruption indices. The correlation was there. An economic indicator measured in belt notches.
As a technician I mostly appreciate the method: no access to accounts, no archives, just public photographs. It's the first audit in history carried out with a ruler. I don't know if it would stand up in court, but in a purchasing department it would already make quite a few desks tremble.
- Winners
- Olcay Cem Bulut, Dare Oladokun, Burkard Lippert, Ralph Hohenberger (Germany, Turkey, United Kingdom)
- Citation
- For demonstrating that sexual orgasms can be as effective as decongestant medicines at improving nasal breathing.
- Reference
- “Can Sex Improve Nasal Function? — An Exploration of the Link Between Sex and Nasal Function”, Ear, Nose & Throat Journal, 2021.
A team of ENT specialists measured the airflow in the noses of some couples before and after intimacy, comparing the effect with that of a decongestant spray. For about an hour the nose breathes better, then goes back to how it was. Like the sprays, but without the patient leaflet.
It's the typical discovery the marketing department would instantly turn into a slogan. I'll merely note that it's the only cold remedy that nobody, in twenty years of tech support, has ever asked me to install.
- Winners
- Ethan Beseris, Steven Naleway, David Carrier (USA)
- Citation
- For testing the hypothesis that humans evolved beards to protect themselves from punches to the face.
- Reference
- “Impact Protection Potential of Mammalian Hair: Testing the Pugilism Hypothesis for the Evolution of Human Facial Hair”, Integrative Organismal Biology, 2020.
To simulate a bearded jaw the researchers used samples covered in sheepskin, with and without the wool, and struck them with a weight. With the fleece, the impact is absorbed better. The beard, therefore, might be a slow-growing airbag.
The Peace prize is perfect: it's the first piece of research to offer a solution to conflict without asking anyone to stop fighting. Just stop shaving. Like certain sysadmins who don't shave during a server migration: now I know it's preventive defence.
- Winners
- Alessandro Corbetta, Jasper Meeusen, Chung-min Lee, Roberto Benzi, Federico Toschi (Netherlands, Italy, Taiwan, USA)
- Citation
- For conducting experiments to learn why pedestrians do not constantly collide with other pedestrians.
- Reference
- “Physics-based modeling and data representation of pairwise interactions among pedestrians”, Physical Review E, 2018.
Using sensors, they tracked the trajectories of a huge number of people walking and derived a physical model from them: each pedestrian swerves ever so slightly, in good time, and collisions don't happen. A crowd is a distributed algorithm that works without a central server.
It's every company network's dream: thousands of nodes dodging each other on their own without anyone having written a single rule. Then the colleague with a coffee and his eyes on his phone walks into the corridor, and the model collapses. But that's what the next prize is for.
- Winners
- Hisashi Murakami, Claudio Feliciani, Yuta Nishiyama, Katsuhiro Nishinari (Japan, Switzerland, Italy)
- Citation
- For conducting experiments to learn why pedestrians do sometimes collide with other pedestrians.
- Reference
- “Mutual Anticipation Can Contribute to Self-Organization in Human Crowds”, Science Advances, 2021.
Here is the twin of the Physics prize. The researchers had two groups of people cross in opposite directions, asking some of them to look at their smartphones. A handful of distracted walkers is enough to ruin the spontaneous order: the others can no longer anticipate their moves and the crowd jams.
Two prizes in the same year, one to explain why we don't collide and one to explain why we do. It's science making a backup of itself. And the conclusion is clear: the problem isn't the network, it's the user.
- Winners
- John Mulrennan Jr., Roger Grothaus, Charles Hammond, Jay Lamdin (USA)
- Citation
- For their research study “A New Method of Cockroach Control on Submarines”.
- Reference
- “A New Method of Cockroach Control on Submarines”, Journal of Economic Entomology, 1971.
A submarine is an enclosed, warm environment, full of food and people, that nobody can leave for weeks. For a cockroach it's an all-inclusive resort. This 1971 study described how to fumigate it without opening the windows, given that there are no windows.
It reminds me of a client's server room: closed, hot, with cables like creepers. There were no cockroaches there, but there was an old switch nobody knew the purpose of. We treated it with the same respect: nobody ever touched it.
- Winners
- Robin Radcliffe, Mark Jago, Peter Morkel, Estelle Morkel, Pierre du Preez and colleagues (Namibia, South Africa, Tanzania, Zimbabwe, Brazil, United Kingdom, USA)
- Citation
- For experimentally determining whether it is safer to transport an airborne rhinoceros upside-down.
- Reference
- “The Pulmonary and Metabolic Effects of Suspension by the Feet Compared with Lateral Recumbency in Immobilized Black Rhinoceroses”, Journal of Wildlife Diseases, 2021.
To move black rhinos to protected areas, they are sometimes carried by helicopter, sedated and hung by their feet. The vets measured the breathing of suspended animals compared with those lying on their side. Result: upside down, the rhino doesn't breathe worse; if anything, slightly better.
It's a deadly serious study, useful for conserving an endangered species. But the sentence “we hung up a rhino to see if it felt better” is the closest thing to a project meeting I have ever heard in biology.
Three Swedish phoneticians did to cats what is usually done to dialects: record, measure the intonation, classify. Result: the meow has a melody, and it changes depending on what the cat wants. In practice they wrote the documentation for an interface users have been operating for ten thousand years without a manual.
I have a cat that only talks to me when I'm on a video call. Now I know it isn't interference: it's a protocol. The cat always had an API. We were the ones not reading the logs.