Ig Nobel Prizes 2007
On 4 October 2007, at Harvard's Sanders Theatre, the seventeenth Ig Nobel ceremony takes place. The official theme of the evening is chicken. Don't ask me why: some decisions follow the same logic as the names of the neighbours' Wi-Fi networks.
Among the winners: jet-lagged hamsters, linguist rats, overcrowded beds and a soup that never ends. A rich vintage. The chicken, as far as we know, won nothing.
- Winners
- Patricia V. Agostino, Santiago A. Plano and Diego A. Golombek (National University of Quilmes, Argentina)
- Citation
- For their discovery that Viagra aids jet lag recovery in hamsters.
- Reference
- “Sildenafil Accelerates Reentrainment of Circadian Rhythms After Advancing Light Schedules”, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2007.
- Winners
- Johanna E.M.H. van Bronswijk (Eindhoven University of Technology, Netherlands)
- Citation
- For doing a census of all the mites, insects, spiders, ferns, fungi and microorganisms with whom we share our beds each night.
- Reference
- Series of studies published between 1972 and 1994.
You thought you slept alone. In fact your mattress is a crowded block of flats, with tenants of every species and no residents' meetings. Professor van Bronswijk spent years keeping the register of this invisible population, extremely useful work for anyone studying allergies and house dust.
Since reading it, I look at my bed the way I look at the office shared server: full of processes I didn't start and nobody knows how to kill. Tonight I'm sleeping in the chair. Even there, I fear, I'm not alone.
- Winners
- Mayu Yamamoto (International Medical Center of Japan, Japan)
- Citation
- For developing a way to extract vanillin, the flavour and fragrance of vanilla, from cow dung.
- Reference
- “Novel Production Method for Plant Polyphenol from Livestock Excrement Using Subcritical Water Reaction”, International Journal of Chemical Engineering, 2008.
Cow dung contains plant remains, and plants contain lignin, from which vanillin can be obtained. Yamamoto found a way to do it with water at high temperature and pressure. Result: the scent of vanilla from a material normally kept well away from the nose. Recycling in its bravest form.
It reminds me of recovering data from a disk everyone had written off. Inside was somebody's degree dissertation. Something precious always comes out of the rubbish; just don't ask too many questions about where the ice cream came from.
- Winners
- Kuo Cheng Hsieh (Taichung, Taiwan)
- Citation
- For patenting a device, in the year 2001, that catches bank robbers by dropping a net over them.
- Reference
- US patent no. 6,219,959, “Net Trapping System for Capturing a Robber Immediately”, 2001.
The robber walks in, makes threats, and a net drops from the ceiling. End of robbery. The patent really exists and has the beauty of old-fashioned mechanical solutions: no software, no updates, no passwords to remember. Just gravity applied to bank security.
I'd like a corporate version for people who walk into the server room to “quickly fix something”. A soft net, a sign saying “Call IT” and a serene wait. Cybersecurity, after all, has always been a matter of networks.
- Winners
- Juan Manuel Toro, Josep B. Trobalón and Núria Sebastián-Gallés (University of Barcelona, Spain)
- Citation
- For showing that rats sometimes cannot tell the difference between a person speaking Japanese backwards and a person speaking Dutch backwards.
- Reference
- “Effects of Backward Speech and Speaker Variability in Language Discrimination by Rats”, Journal of Experimental Psychology: Animal Behavior Processes, 2005.
Rats can tell different languages apart by the rhythm of speech. But if the recordings are played backwards, the natural rhythm goes and they get confused too. It's serious research into how the brain recognises languages, but the phrase “Japanese backwards versus Dutch backwards” remains pure poetry.
Listening to certain technical meetings, I can't tell business English from church Latin either. And nobody has ever rewarded me. The rats, at least, got a treat for every right answer.
- Winners
- Glenda Browne (Blaxland, Australia)
- Citation
- For her study of the English definite article “the”, and of the many problems it causes for anyone who tries to put things into alphabetical order.
- Reference
- “The Definite Article: Acknowledging 'The' in Index Entries”, The Indexer, 2001.
A band is called “The” something: does it go under T or under the next letter? Glenda Browne, a professional indexer, devoted a study to this little word that throws indexes, catalogues and libraries into crisis. A tiny detail treated as a matter of State, and rightly so.
Anyone who has ever sorted a database knows: one stray space and the customer “Smith” ends up after “Young”. I've seen offices split over less. Once over a hyphen. We don't talk about it any more.
- Winners
- Brian Witcombe (Gloucestershire Royal NHS Foundation Trust, UK) and Dan Meyer (Antioch, Tennessee, USA)
- Citation
- For their penetrating medical report on the side effects of swallowing swords.
- Reference
- “Sword Swallowing and Its Side Effects”, British Medical Journal, 2006.
A radiologist and a professional sword swallower surveyed dozens of fellow practitioners to find out what happens when you slide a blade down your throat. Result: frequent sore throats, serious risks if you get distracted or attempt fancy tricks. Occupational medicine, for a very particular occupation.
The best bit is that the study is real, methodical and published in a major medical journal. The practical summary applies to IT too: if you're doing something risky, don't rush it and don't do it while someone is talking to you.
- Winners
- Brian Wansink (Cornell University, USA)
- Citation
- For exploring the seemingly boundless appetites of human beings, by feeding volunteers from a self-refilling bowl of soup.
- Reference
- “Bottomless Bowls: Why Visual Cues of Portion Size May Influence Intake”, Obesity Research, 2005.
A bowl secretly connected to a tank under the table: the more you eat, the more soup appears. Those with the rigged bowl ate a great deal more, without feeling any fuller. The message is that we often eat with our eyes, not our stomach.
Same principle as the inbox: you empty it, and it fills itself back up. Nobody ever feels full of email. If someone ever invents a bowl that empties itself, I swear I'll plug it into the mail server.
- Winners
- The US Air Force Wright Laboratory (Dayton, Ohio, USA)
- Citation
- For instigating research on a chemical weapon, the so-called “gay bomb”, that would make enemy soldiers sexually irresistible to each other.
- Reference
- Wright Laboratory proposal, 1994, made public years later.
The facts: a 1994 research proposal floated non-lethal chemical weapons to disrupt enemy troops, including a substance meant to cause mutual attraction between soldiers. The idea never left the paper. The Peace prize, with the usual irony, celebrates a weapon whose worst ambition was to make love, not war.
We've all written at least one project proposal that should never have left the Friday-afternoon meeting. This one made it. Proof that documents, sooner or later, always escape from the drawer.
- Winners
- L. Mahadevan (Harvard University, USA; India) and Enrique Cerda Villablanca (University of Santiago, Chile)
- Citation
- For studying how wrinkles form in sheets and thin surfaces.
- Reference
- “Geometry and Physics of Wrinkling”, Physical Review Letters, 2003; further studies in Nature (2002) and PNAS (2004).
Why does a stretched plastic sheet wrinkle? Why does skin get lines? Mahadevan and Cerda found the mathematical rules that decide how many wrinkles appear and how big they are. Elegant physics, useful in everything from biology to advanced materials.
I immediately thought of my meeting shirt, which comes out of the wardrobe with a complete geological survey. Now I know it isn't my fault: it's geometry. I'll put it in my next email to the client, attached to the quote, to sound more authoritative.
The researchers moved the light clock forward, simulating an eastbound flight, and saw that hamsters treated with sildenafil adjusted to the new time faster. The drug acts on a molecule involved in the body clock. The rest I leave to the imagination of that era's headline writers.
The detail that moves me is the travelling hamster. I picture him in economy, eye mask on, asking the flight attendant whether there's Wi-Fi on board. There isn't. There never is.