Ig Nobel Prizes 1999
Ninth edition, at Harvard's Sanders Theatre, with the usual bombardment of paper aeroplanes and real Nobel laureates handing over the prizes. 1999 is a profoundly British year: prizes go to the standard for making tea, the physics of the dunked biscuit and the teapot that doesn't drip.
It was also the year of millennium bug panic. I had prepared a detailed emergency plan: a torch, a boot floppy and a packet of biscuits. With hindsight, the packet of biscuits was the most scientific part.
- Winners
- Paul Bosland (New Mexico State University, USA)
- Citation
- For breeding a spiceless jalapeño chilli pepper.
- Winners
- Takeshi Makino (Osaka, Japan)
- Citation
- For his involvement in S-Check, an infidelity detection spray that wives can apply to their husbands' underwear.
Makino headed an agency that marketed a spray able, according to its makers, to reveal suspicious traces on underwear. Analytical chemistry in the service of relationship matters, with results I imagine were hotly debated over dinner.
In IT we have an equivalent tool: it's called browser history. There too a quick check is enough to bring out the truth, and there too a long, tense conversation always follows. The technical lesson is the same: every system leaves logs. Wisdom consists in not reading them at dinner.
- Winners
- Hyuk-ho Kwon (Kolon Company, Seoul, South Korea)
- Citation
- For inventing the self-perfuming business suit.
Kwon developed an office suit with perfume microcapsules woven into the fabric, releasing fragrance for a long time. The businessman thus becomes a walking air freshener, with a very positive impact on the atmosphere of the meeting room.
I'd have wanted one back in the golden age of server rooms without air conditioning, when after eight hours of cabling my smell had the same consistency as the dust on top of the switches. A suit that perfumes itself is the real green economy: the colleague next to you can breathe, and the environment is grateful.
- Winners
- British Standards Institution (United Kingdom)
- Citation
- For its six-page specification, BS 6008, on the proper way to make a cup of tea.
- Reference
- Standard BS 6008
The British standards body really did codify, complete with quantities, brewing times and procedures, the standard method for making tea, originally intended for professional tasting. Six pages of precision on the most sacred ritual in the United Kingdom.
It is the technical documentation every company dreams of and nobody writes: clear, repeatable, unambiguous. I tried to do the same for the office coffee machine. I got to forty pages, with diagrams and exception handling. Then the coffee ran out and the document is still under review.
- Winners
- George and Charlotte Blonsky (New York and San Jose, California, USA), awarded posthumously
- Citation
- For inventing a device to aid childbirth, in which the woman is strapped onto a circular table that is rotated at high speed.
- Reference
- US Patent no. 3,216,423
In the Sixties the Blonskys patented a sort of obstetric centrifuge: the idea was that centrifugal force would help the baby out. The patent exists, drawings and all, and is one of the masterpieces of engineering applied to problems nobody asked to have solved that way.
It is the mindset of the technician who only has a hammer and sees nails everywhere, but in washing-machine form. The spin cycle solves everything, according to this school. Even I, when a file won't download, shake the laptop. It doesn't work, but the principle has a certain nobility.
- Winners
- Arvid Vatle (Stord, Norway)
- Citation
- For carefully collecting, classifying and analysing the kinds of containers his patients chose when bringing him urine samples.
- Reference
- “Unyttig om urinprøver”, Tidsskrift for Den norske legeforening, no. 8, 20 March 1999, p. 1178
The Norwegian doctor noticed that patients handed in samples in the most varied receptacles, and decided to study the matter methodically: jam jars, bottles, phials of every kind, all catalogued and analysed. A taxonomy of household recycling.
It is exactly what happens when you ask a customer to send you a file: it arrives as a photo of the screen, as a PDF inside a Word document, as an attachment in an email forwarded five times. I ought to publish some statistics too. The most popular container, obviously, is the unlabelled USB stick.
- Winners
- Charl Fourie and Michelle Wong (Johannesburg, South Africa)
- Citation
- For inventing a car burglar alarm consisting of a detection circuit and a flamethrower.
- Reference
- Patent WO/1999/032331, “A Security System for a Vehicle”
Fourie and Wong designed a car security system, called Blaster, which in the event of an attempted hijacking shot flames out of the sides of the vehicle. A device born in a context where violent car theft was a very real problem.
It is the mechanical version of the firewall: anyone attempting unauthorised access gets a very, very clear response. On servers I limit myself to blocking suspicious addresses. A firewall with a flamethrower would tempt me, but the residents' committee already has words to say about the noisy fan.
- Winners
- Len Fisher (Bristol, United Kingdom, and Sydney, Australia)
- Citation
- For calculating the optimal way to dunk a biscuit.
- Reference
- “Physics Takes the Biscuit”, Nature, vol. 397, no. 6719, 11 February 1999, p. 469
Fisher applied the physics of liquids rising through porous materials to the biscuit in your tea, to work out how long and in what way to dip it before it breaks. Published in Nature, no less. The practical advice: dunk the biscuit holding it flat.
At last a piece of research that has solved a real problem, felt by billions of people every morning. The biscuit that snaps off and sinks is the system crash of breakfast: sudden, irreversible and with no backup. Fisher has given us the procedure. Now all we need is the courage to apply it.
- Winners
- Jean-Marc Vanden-Broeck (United Kingdom and Belgium) and Joseph Keller (USA)
- Citation
- For calculating how to design a teapot spout that does not drip.
- Reference
- “Pouring Flows”, Physics of Fluids, vol. 29, no. 12, 1986, pp. 3958-3961
The two mathematicians used the equations of fluid dynamics to study the phenomenon whereby tea, instead of ending up in the cup, runs down the spout and onto the tablecloth. The so-called teapot effect is a real and surprisingly complex problem.
In the same year, two physics prizes about tea: one for the biscuit, one for the teapot. A full stack, from the back end to the front end of afternoon tea. I have had a teapot that drips since 2004. I always treated it as a feature. After this study, I fear it needs a ticket.
- Winners
- Kansas State Board of Education and Colorado State Board of Education (USA)
- Citation
- For mandating that children should not believe in Darwin's theory of evolution any more than they believe in Newton's theory of gravitation, Faraday's and Maxwell's theory of electromagnetism, or Pasteur's theory that germs cause disease.
In 1999 the two school boards took decisions that downgraded the weight of evolution in science curricula. The committee's citation is built with impeccable logical irony: if evolution is only a theory, then so are gravity and electromagnetism.
It is reasoning I know well from the office. “Cyber security is only a theory”, a customer once told me, shortly before using “password” as his password. Gravity is also a theory. And yet, when I dropped that hard drive, it worked very convincingly.
- Winners
- Steve Penfold (York University, Toronto, Canada)
- Citation
- For writing his doctoral thesis on the sociology of Canadian doughnut shops.
- Reference
- Steve Penfold, “The Social Life of Donuts: Commodity and Community in Postwar Canada”, doctoral thesis, York University
Penfold studied the role of doughnut chains in the social life of post-war Canada: meeting places, symbols of national identity, little neighbourhood parliaments with coffee. Serious historical research, showing how much you can understand about a country by looking at where it has breakfast.
The IT world has its sacred places too: the coffee machine, where more gets decided than in all the official meetings put together. Projects are born there, conflicts are settled, and you find out who deleted the shared folder. Someone should write a thesis on it. I already have all the sources, if needed.
Bosland, director of an institute devoted to chilli peppers, used cross-breeding to obtain a variety of jalapeño with all the flavour and none of the burn. A thoroughly respectable agricultural result, which nonetheless raises a philosophical question: is a jalapeño that doesn't burn still a jalapeño?
It is like an antivirus that never flags anything, a printer that never jams, a meeting without slides. Technically they exist. But everyone eyes them with suspicion, convinced there's a catch. I would try it, though. With a fire extinguisher within reach, out of habit.