Ig Nobel Prizes 2001
On 4 October 2001, at Harvard's Sanders Theatre, science took its usual night off: ten prizes, a shower of paper aeroplanes and real Nobel laureates forced to hand out improbable trophies. I followed it the way I follow Windows updates: with respect, fear and a sandwich. This is the year someone patented the wheel. In 2001. In Australia. And it went through.
- Winners
- Peter Barss (Canada)
- Citation
- For his impactful study of injuries caused by falling coconuts.
- Reference
- “Injuries Due to Falling Coconuts”, The Journal of Trauma, vol. 24, no. 11, 1984
- Winners
- David Schmidt (USA)
- Citation
- For his partial solution to the question of why shower curtains billow inwards.
Professor Schmidt took the shower curtain, humanity's age-old enemy, and fed it into fluid simulation software. The calculation ran for weeks. The answer: the spray creates a small vortex, a sort of pocket hurricane that lowers the pressure and sucks the plastic towards you.
A partial solution, says the citation. Quite right too: my support tickets also get closed as “partially resolved”. The curtain still hugs you, but now you know it does so out of fluid dynamics, not affection.
- Winners
- Buck Weimer (USA)
- Citation
- For inventing Under-Ease, airtight underwear with a replaceable charcoal filter that removes bad-smelling gases before they escape.
Mr Weimer tackled a problem humanity had been solving for millennia by blaming the dog. He designed airtight underwear with an activated-carbon outlet filter, like a cooker hood but far more discreet. The filter is replaceable, like a printer cartridge, and probably costs less.
It is network engineering applied to the person: outbound firewall, no suspicious packet leaves the perimeter. The colleague who says “it wasn't me” in a meeting would finally have a system log to back him up.
- Winners
- Joel Slemrod (USA) and Wojciech Kopczuk (Canada)
- Citation
- For discovering that people find a way to postpone their deaths if that would qualify them for a lower rate on the inheritance tax.
- Reference
- “Dying to Save Taxes: Evidence from Estate Tax Returns on the Death Elasticity”, NBER Working Paper no. 8158, 2001
Two economists looked at American estate tax returns around changes in the tax rate and found an anomaly: a small number of deaths shift by a few days towards the most tax-efficient date. With an accountant's coolness, they called it the elasticity of death.
It is the definitive proof that bureaucracy is stronger than biology. I know servers that stay on out of sheer stubbornness until the support contract expires. Now I know they aren't odd: they're just prudent.
- Winners
- John Richards (United Kingdom)
- Citation
- For founding the Apostrophe Protection Society and devoting his efforts to protecting, promoting and defending the differences between plural and possessive.
John Richards, a retired journalist in Boston, the one in Lincolnshire, founded a society with a single mission: to rescue the English apostrophe from greengrocers' signs reading “banana's”. Polite letters, correct examples, infinite patience.
I sympathise. I have been fighting a similar war for years against people who write “it's” for “its” in meeting minutes. A comma in the wrong place crashes a program; an apostrophe in the wrong place crashes me. Mr Richards is a proofreader with an army.
- Winners
- Lawrence W. Sherman (USA)
- Citation
- For his ecological study of glee in small groups of preschool children.
- Reference
- “An Ecological Study of Glee in Small Groups of Preschool Children”, Child Development, vol. 46, no. 1, 1975
Professor Sherman observed nursery children and measured with scientific seriousness when and how the giggles break out: how many children it takes, who starts, how it spreads. In practice he studied the contagion of laughter the way you study a virus on a network.
The result strikes me as applicable to company meetings too: all it takes is one person snorting at the wrong moment during the director's slides and the glee spreads through the whole room, with no possibility of a patch. A serious phenomenon, documented with a smile.
- Winners
- Jack and Rexella Van Impe (USA)
- Citation
- For their discovery that black holes fulfil all the technical requirements to be the location of Hell.
- Reference
- Television programme “Jack Van Impe Presents”, 31 March 2001
The Van Impes, television preachers, proposed during a broadcast an astronomical location for Hell: black holes, places from which nothing escapes and where everything gets crushed. The prize pokes fun at the meeting, not exactly foreseen in the textbooks, between astrophysics and otherworldly geolocation.
As a technician, I must admit the description also fits certain users' “Downloads” folder: everything goes in, nothing comes out, time warps and nobody dares look inside. Approaching the event horizon is not recommended. There either.
- Winners
- Viliumas Malinauskas (Lithuania)
- Citation
- For creating the amusement park known as “Stalin World”.
After the fall of the regime, Lithuania found itself with a great many Soviet statues and no idea what to do with them. Mr Malinauskas, a mushroom entrepreneur, gathered them in Grūtas Park, among watchtowers, barbed wire and period loudspeakers. An open-air museum you visit with a shiver.
It is the historical equivalent of the folder “Old_DO_NOT_DELETE”: you don't use it any more, you don't want to see it any more, but throwing it away feels wrong. So you archive it in a forest and put in a ticket office. Managing the past in read-only mode.
- Winners
- John Keogh (Australia) and the Australian Patent Office
- Citation
- Shared prize: to Keogh for patenting the wheel in 2001, and to the Australian Patent Office for granting him Innovation Patent no. 2001100012.
- Reference
- Australian Innovation Patent no. 2001100012 (later revoked)
John Keogh, a lawyer, wanted to show that the new fast-track patent system, with no thorough examination, had a hole in it. He filed a “circular transportation facilitation device”. The office accepted it. The wheel, five thousand years later, finally had an owner.
It is a penetration test carried out with official forms, and it worked beautifully. The patent was later revoked, but the lesson remains: if a system accepts everything automatically, sooner or later someone gets it to sign off the wheel. Or the password “1234”.
- Winners
- Chittaranjan Andrade and B. S. Srihari (India)
- Citation
- For their probing medical discovery that nose-picking is a common activity among adolescents.
- Reference
- “A Preliminary Survey of Rhinotillexomania in an Adolescent Sample”, Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, vol. 62, no. 6, 2001
Two psychiatrists from Bangalore handed out questionnaires to two hundred students to measure a practice everyone knows and nobody confesses to. They also found a splendid technical name, rhinotillexomania, which makes the habit sound like a rare science-fiction disease.
The result, nearly everyone does it, is what we suspected, but now it is certified with numbers and tables. Same thing with office surveys on switching off the PC: everyone says they do it every evening. System logs, like psychiatrists, know the truth.
Working in Papua New Guinea, Dr Barss noticed that some of his admissions were arriving from above: coconuts weighing a couple of kilos dropping from twenty metres. He counted, measured and calculated the impact energy. Result: a real threat, underestimated because it sounds funny.
It shares the fate of the UPS in the server room. Nobody thinks about it until something falls. Since then I park well away from palm trees and from rack cabinets with a vibrating fan. Danger gives no warning: it rolls.