Ig Nobel Prizes 2013
On 12 September 2013, at Harvard's Sanders Theatre, the 23rd First Annual Ig Nobel Prize Ceremony is held and broadcast live. That year there's an Italian among the physicists, and someone who swallowed a shrew for science. The Public Health winners can't attend: their acceptance speech is read aloud by a real Nobel laureate, Eric Maskin. It's like having a poet read out the printer manual.
- Winners
- Masateru Uchiyama (Japan), Xiangyuan Jin (China, Japan), Qi Zhang, Toshihito Hirai, Atsushi Amano, Hisashi Bashuda (Japan) and Masanori Niimi (Japan, UK)
- Citation
- For assessing the effect of listening to opera on heart transplant patients who are mice.
- Reference
- M. Uchiyama et al., “Auditory stimulation of opera music induced prolongation of murine cardiac allograft survival and maintained generation of regulatory CD4+CD25+ cells”, Journal of Cardiothoracic Surgery, vol. 7, no. 26, 2012.
- Winners
- Laurent Bègue (France), Brad Bushman (USA, UK, Netherlands, Poland), Oulmann Zerhouni, Baptiste Subra and Medhi Ourabah (France)
- Citation
- For confirming, by experiment, that people who think they are drunk also think they are attractive.
- Reference
- L. Bègue, B.J. Bushman, O. Zerhouni, B. Subra and M. Ourabah, “'Beauty is in the eye of the beer holder': People who think they are drunk also think they are attractive”, British Journal of Psychology, vol. 104, no. 2, 2013, pp. 225-234.
Volunteers were served drinks: some got alcohol, others a non-alcoholic drink that looked alcoholic. Then they had to rate how attractive they felt. Those who believed they'd been drinking gave themselves higher marks, whether they'd actually drunk or not. You don't need alcohol: the idea of alcohol will do.
It's the placebo effect applied to self-esteem, and it closely resembles the effect the word “cloud” has on certain executives. Just say it and they instantly feel younger, more agile, more scalable. Meanwhile, the external judges in the study didn't agree at all. Like colleagues when the executive presents the new project.
- Winners
- Marie Dacke (Sweden, Australia), Emily Baird (Sweden, Australia, Germany), Marcus Byrne (South Africa, UK), Clarke Scholtz (South Africa) and Eric J. Warrant (Sweden, Australia, Germany)
- Citation
- For discovering that when dung beetles get lost, they can navigate their way home by looking at the Milky Way.
- Reference
- M. Dacke, E. Baird, M. Byrne, C.H. Scholtz and E.J. Warrant, “Dung Beetles Use the Milky Way for Orientation”, Current Biology, vol. 23, no. 4, 2013, pp. 298-300.
The dung beetle makes a ball and has to roll it away in a straight line before a rival steals it. At night, with no moon, it still manages: it uses the glowing band of the Milky Way as a reference. To prove it, the researchers took it to a planetarium and fitted it with little caps that blocked its view of the sky.
So an insect that hauls manure has a galactic navigation system. With satnav I manage to get lost in the shopping-centre car park. The prize is a double, Biology and Astronomy, and well deserved: it's the only living creature that uses the galaxy for removals work.
- Winners
- The late Gustano Pizzo (USA)
- Citation
- For inventing an electromechanical system to trap aircraft hijackers: the hijacker drops through a trap door, is sealed into a package, is dropped through specially installed doors in the belly of the plane and parachutes to earth, where police, alerted by radio, await his arrival.
- Reference
- US patent 3811643, Gustano A. Pizzo, “Anti hijacking system for aircraft”, 1972.
The patent describes a sequence worthy of a cartoon, but with all the technical drawings in order. The hijacker approaches the cockpit, the floor opens, he lands in a container, gets packaged, dropped by parachute and delivered to the police waiting at the landing site. Flawless logistics: tracking and delivery included.
The first documented case of a human being handled like an express parcel. No airline has ever installed it, and the reason is easy to imagine: the trap door in the aisle. I want one under my desk, though, for people who walk in saying “just a quick question”.
- Winners
- Alberto Minetti (Italy, UK, Denmark, Switzerland), Yuri Ivanenko (Italy, Russia, France), Germana Cappellini (Italy), Nadia Dominici (Italy, Switzerland, Netherlands) and Francesco Lacquaniti (Italy)
- Citation
- For discovering that some people would be physically capable of running across the surface of a pond, if those people and that pond were on the Moon.
- Reference
- A.E. Minetti, Y.P. Ivanenko, G. Cappellini, N. Dominici and F. Lacquaniti, “Humans Running in Place on Water at Simulated Reduced Gravity”, PLoS ONE, vol. 7, no. 7, 2012, e37300.
An Italian-led team put volunteers in a small pool, hanging from a harness that simulated reduced gravity, with flippers on their feet. At something like lunar gravity, some of them managed to run on the spot without sinking. On Earth nobody can: you'd need superhero legs.
It's the classic “works on my machine”: sure, but your machine is on the Moon. I find it wonderful because it rigorously answers a question nobody felt the need to ask. When they build the first lunar base with a pond, we'll already know how to cross it. Flippers, obviously, go in hand luggage.
- Winners
- Shinsuke Imai, Nobuaki Tsuge, Muneaki Tomotake, Yoshiaki Nagatome, H. Sawada, Hidehiko Kumagai (Japan) and Toshiyuki Nagata (Japan, Germany)
- Citation
- For discovering that the biochemical process by which onions make people cry is even more complicated than scientists previously realised.
- Reference
- S. Imai et al., “An onion enzyme that makes the eyes water”, Nature, vol. 419, no. 6908, 2002, p. 685.
It was thought that the substance that makes your eyes water formed almost by itself when you cut an onion. The Japanese team discovered that an extra, previously unknown enzyme is required, a mandatory step. Find the enzyme and, in theory, you can grow an onion that doesn't make you cry.
In practice they found the hidden component in a process everyone thought they knew. It happens in the office too: there's always a forgotten service, started in 2009 by an intern, that holds the whole network together. Cut that and everyone cries. According to the organisers, all the authors went to collect the prize. Dry-eyed, I imagine.
- Winners
- Brian Crandall (USA) and Peter Stahl (Canada, USA)
- Citation
- For parboiling a dead shrew, swallowing it without chewing, and then carefully examining everything excreted during the following days, to see which bones dissolve inside the human digestive system and which do not.
- Reference
- P.W. Stahl and B.D. Crandall, “Human digestive effects on a micromammalian skeleton”, Journal of Archaeological Science, vol. 22, 1995, pp. 789-797.
Archaeologists often find tiny bones of small animals in ancient remains and wonder: did humans eat them, or something else? To know, you have to know what's left of a bone after a trip through the human gut. And to know that, somebody had to take the trip. Crandall volunteered. Whole shrew, freshly parboiled, no chewing.
That's the true spirit of the tester: they don't trust simulations, they go to production with their own body. To test a backup I merely restore it to a test server, and even that feels heroic. I take my hat off to them. And skip my snack.
- Winners
- Alexander Lukashenko, president of Belarus; and the Belarus State Police
- Citation
- Joint prize: to the president for making it illegal to applaud in public, and to the State Police for arresting a one-armed man for applauding.
- Reference
- Press reports from July 2011.
The events honoured date back to 2011: in Belarus public applause had been banned and, according to reports at the time, the police had even detained a one-armed man for it. The committee split the prize in two, to the president and to the police, with the same citation divided into two symmetrical halves.
I'll leave the commentary to logic, which is my trade: clapping with one hand is a textbook philosophy problem, and it turns out it also has an administrative answer. I'll restrict myself to a technician's note: it's one of the few cases in which the ceremony's audience, noisy by tradition, had one more reason to clap.
- Winners
- Bert Tolkamp (UK, Netherlands), Marie Haskell (UK), Fritha Langford (UK, Canada), David Roberts and Colin Morgan (UK)
- Citation
- For making two related discoveries: first, that the longer a cow has been lying down, the more likely that cow will soon stand up; and second, that once a cow stands up, you cannot easily predict how soon that cow will lie down again.
- Reference
- B.J. Tolkamp, M.J. Haskell, F.M. Langford, D.J. Roberts and C.A. Morgan, “Are cows more likely to lie down the longer they stand?”, Applied Animal Behaviour Science, vol. 124, no. 1-2, 2010, pp. 1-10.
Sensors on cows' legs, thousands of hours of data, and an asymmetrical conclusion. Lying down, the cow has a sort of internal timer: the longer she stays down, the closer the moment she gets up. Standing, though, she's a mystery: she might lie down again in a minute or in hours, and statistics throws up its hands.
That's exactly how a network printer behaves. When it's off, you know it will switch on sooner or later. When it's on, no mathematical model can tell you when it will stop working. Now I know I'm dealing with a grazing animal. I'll speak to it with more respect. And perhaps give it some hay.
- Winners
- Kasian Bhanganada, Tu Chayavatana, Chumporn Pongnumkul, Anunt Tonmukayakul, Piyasakol Sakolsatayadorn, Krit Komaratal and Henry Wilde (Thailand)
- Citation
- For the surgical techniques described in their report on managing an epidemic of penile amputations in Siam, techniques which they recommend except in cases where the amputated part had been partially eaten by a duck.
- Reference
- K. Bhanganada et al., “Surgical management of an epidemic of penile amputations in Siam”, The American Journal of Surgery, vol. 146, no. 3, 1983, pp. 376-382.
Behind the citation, which sounds like a joke, lies serious work: in 1970s Thailand surgeons faced a series of dramatic cases and developed reattachment techniques, documenting them rigorously. The duck detail is real and made it into the report as a limitation of the method, with the typical sobriety of the medical literature.
It's the most memorable “unsupported scenarios” section ever written. Every technical manual has one, but it usually says “not guaranteed with third-party printers”. Here the limitation is a farmyard animal. The absent winners' speech was read by a Nobel laureate. With a steady voice, it must be said.
Mice with a transplanted heart, split into groups: some listen to opera, some to other music, some to nothing. The opera group, treated to La Traviata, kept the new heart longer before rejection. The researchers linked the effect to the immune system, apparently calmer with the right music.
As an Italian I take it as a national victory: Verdi works as medicine too. Just in case, I play opera in the server room. I don't know whether the disks last longer, but the fans seem to join in the chorus. When the system goes into thermal shutdown, I call it the finale of Act Three.