Ig Nobel Prizes 2015
On 17 September 2015, at Harvard's Sanders Theatre, the 25th First Annual Ig Nobel Prize Ceremony is held: a quarter of a century of first times. Not everyone can make it: the Literature winners send a video speech and receive their prize weeks later at a European event in Amsterdam, while one of the Medicine winners also sends a video. By now the ceremony has more remote links than a Monday-morning company meeting.
- Winners
- Callum Ormonde and Colin Raston (Australia); Tom Yuan, Gregory Weiss and colleagues (USA)
- Citation
- For inventing a chemical recipe to partially un-boil an egg.
- Reference
- T.Z. Yuan, C.F.G. Ormonde et al., “Shear-Stress-Mediated Refolding of Proteins from Aggregates and Inclusion Bodies”, ChemBioChem, vol. 16, no. 3, 2015, pp. 393-396.
- Winners
- Patricia Yang (USA, Taiwan), David Hu (USA, Taiwan), Jonathan Pham and Jerome Choo (USA)
- Citation
- For testing the biological principle that nearly all mammals empty their bladders in about 21 seconds (plus or minus 13 seconds).
- Reference
- P.J. Yang, J. Pham, J. Choo and D.L. Hu, “Duration of urination does not change with body size”, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, vol. 111, no. 33, 2014, pp. 11932-11937.
Filming animals at the zoo, from mouse to elephant, the researchers noticed a surprising constant: mammals above a certain weight all take roughly the same time to pee. The elephant has an enormous bladder, but also a long, wide urethra that uses gravity like a drainpipe. It evens out.
The most elegant scaling law I've ever seen. In IT, when a big system takes as long as a small one, we celebrate for a week. Elephants solved it before us, without meetings. And the finding has real applications, for instance in designing tanks and drainage systems.
- Winners
- Mark Dingemanse (Netherlands, USA), Francisco Torreira (Spain, Netherlands, Belgium, USA, Canada) and Nick J. Enfield (Australia, Netherlands)
- Citation
- For discovering that the word “huh?” (or its equivalent) seems to exist in every human language, and for not being quite sure why.
- Reference
- M. Dingemanse, F. Torreira and N.J. Enfield, “Is 'Huh?' a universal word? Conversational infrastructure and the convergent evolution of linguistic items”, PLOS ONE, vol. 8, no. 11, 2013, e78273.
The linguists recorded real conversations in ten very different languages, from Icelandic to a language of Ghana. In all of them the same little word appears for “I didn't catch that, say again”: short, with a neutral vowel, often with a rising tone. It isn't an instinctive reflex, they say: it's a real word, born the same way many times over because it serves a purpose.
It's the retransmission packet of human communication. When the network loses data, it asks for it to be resent. When the brain loses a sentence, it says “huh?”. The system works everywhere, and anyone on a support line will vouch for it: it's the word I hear most often, after “I didn't touch anything”.
- Winners
- Gennaro Bernile (Italy, Singapore, USA), Vineet Bhagwat (USA, India) and P. Raghavendra Rau (UK, India, France, Luxembourg, Germany, Japan)
- Citation
- For discovering that many business leaders developed in childhood a fondness for risk-taking, when they experienced natural disasters, such as earthquakes, volcanic eruptions, tsunamis and wildfires, that for them had no dire personal consequences.
- Reference
- G. Bernile, V. Bhagwat and P.R. Rau, “What Doesn't Kill You Will Only Make You More Risk-Loving: Early-Life Disasters and CEO Behavior”, The Journal of Finance, vol. 72, no. 1, 2017, pp. 167-206.
The economists cross-referenced CEOs' biographies with the disasters that struck where they grew up. Those who lived through a disaster as children without serious consequences tend, as adults, to run their companies more riskily. Those who suffered its worst side, on the contrary, become more cautious.
At last a scientific explanation for the visionary manager who wants to migrate the entire business system on a Friday afternoon. It isn't recklessness: it's an earthquake in 1978. As a sysadmin I propose a countermeasure. At the next round of executive hiring, ask whether as children they ever lost a video-game save. Those people make backups.
- Winners
- The Bangkok Metropolitan Police (Thailand)
- Citation
- For offering to pay policemen extra cash if they refuse to take bribes.
- Reference
- Numerous press articles (2015).
The event honoured is simple to tell: the Bangkok police had announced a cash reward for officers who refused bribes. A positive incentive, instead of punishment alone. The committee saw in it a perfect economic paradox, and gave it the Economics prize.
As a techie I recognise the pattern: it's a bug bounty programme. You pay people to do the right thing, so it pays better than the wrong one. Many tech companies do it with their own systems. I proposed it at the office: a free coffee for anyone who doesn't leave their password on a sticky note. We're still in the pilot phase.
- Winners
- Hajime Kimata (Japan, China); and Jaroslava Durdiaková (Slovakia, USA, UK), Peter Celec (Slovakia, Germany), Natália Kamodyová and colleagues (Slovakia)
- Citation
- Joint prize for experiments to study the biomedical benefits or biomedical consequences of intense kissing (and other intimate interpersonal activities).
- Reference
- H. Kimata, “Kissing reduces allergic skin wheal responses and plasma neurotrophin levels”, Physiology and Behavior, vol. 80, 2003, pp. 395-398; N. Kamodyová et al., “Prevalence and persistence of male DNA identified in mixed saliva samples after intense kissing”, Forensic Science International: Genetics, vol. 7, no. 1, 2013, pp. 124-128.
Two different studies with the same subject. The Japanese doctor observed that, in allergic patients, kissing for a while seemed to reduce skin reactions to allergens. The Slovak team instead studied how long one partner's DNA stays in the other's saliva after an intense kiss, which is useful in forensic medicine.
So a kiss is both an antihistamine and a digitally signed data transfer. The DNA stays there, traceable, like a server's logs. Romance doesn't come out of it defeated: it comes out documented. I'll let you decide whether that's good news. Meanwhile I checked: it doesn't work with the keyboard.
- Winners
- Elisabeth Oberzaucher (Austria, Germany, UK) and Karl Grammer (Austria, Germany)
- Citation
- For trying to use mathematical techniques to determine whether and how Moulay Ismael the Bloodthirsty, the Sharifian Emperor of Morocco, managed, between 1697 and 1727, to father 888 children.
- Reference
- E. Oberzaucher and K. Grammer, “The Case of Moulay Ismael - Fact or Fancy?”, PLOS ONE, vol. 9, no. 2, 2014, e85292.
The chronicles credit a Moroccan ruler with a census-sized number of children. The Austrian scientists wondered whether it was even possible, and ran a computer simulation with biological cycles, conception probabilities and harem sizes. Conclusion: at a punishing pace, but rigorously planned, yes, it was feasible.
It's a resource-planning problem, solved with the same kind of model used for server capacity. As a designer, the result reassures me: even a load that seems impossible can be handled if you calculate it properly. As a human being, it unsettles me. That ruler's calendar must have been worse than mine.
- Winners
- Bruno Grossi, Omar Larach, Mauricio Canals, Rodrigo A. Vásquez (Chile) and José Iriarte-Díaz (Chile, USA)
- Citation
- For observing that when you attach a weighted stick to the rear end of a chicken, the chicken then walks in a manner similar to that in which dinosaurs are thought to have walked.
- Reference
- B. Grossi, J. Iriarte-Díaz, O. Larach, M. Canals and R.A. Vásquez, “Walking Like Dinosaurs: Chickens with Artificial Tails Provide Clues about Non-Avian Theropod Locomotion”, PLoS ONE, vol. 9, no. 2, 2014, e88458.
Birds descend from dinosaurs, but they lost the big tail that shifted the centre of gravity backwards. The Chilean researchers raised chicks with an artificial tail, a stick with a weight on it, from an early age. As they grew, the chickens changed posture and gait, getting closer to how a carnivorous dinosaur is imagined to have walked.
It's an emulator: you have modern hardware, the chicken, and you run an operating system from sixty-six million years ago on it. Exactly like when I fire up an old game on a new computer. It works, but a bit wobbly. The chicken with its tail reminds me of me with my laptop rucksack.
- Winners
- Diallah Karim (Canada, UK), Anthony Harnden (New Zealand, UK, USA), Helen Ashdown (UK) and colleagues
- Citation
- For determining that acute appendicitis can be accurately diagnosed by the amount of pain evident when the patient is driven over speed bumps.
- Reference
- H.F. Ashdown, N. D'Souza, D. Karim, R.J. Stevens, A. Huang and A. Harnden, “Pain over speed bumps in diagnosis of acute appendicitis: diagnostic accuracy study”, BMJ, vol. 345, 2012, e8012.
At an English hospital, patients with suspected appendicitis were asked a simple question: on the way here, did the speed bumps hurt? Those who said no were far less likely to have appendicitis. The speed bump thus becomes a free diagnostic tool, already installed in almost every neighbourhood.
The first case of road infrastructure repurposed as a medical device. In IT we call it reusing existing hardware, and it's every purchasing department's dream. The next step, I imagine, is the pothole as an ultrasound scanner. Judging by our roads, we'd already be equipped for a complete health service.
- Winners
- Justin Schmidt (USA, Canada); and Michael L. Smith (Panama, USA, UK, Netherlands)
- Citation
- Joint prize: to Schmidt for painstakingly creating the Schmidt Sting Pain Index, which rates the relative pain people feel when stung by various insects; to Smith for arranging for honey bees to sting him on 25 different locations on his body, to learn that the least painful are the skull, the tip of the middle toe and the upper arm, and the most painful the nostril, the upper lip and the penis.
- Reference
- J.O. Schmidt, M.S. Blum and W.L. Overal, “Hemolytic activities of stinging insect venoms”, Archives of Insect Biochemistry and Physiology, vol. 1, no. 2, 1983, pp. 155-160; M.L. Smith, “Honey bee sting pain index by body location”, PeerJ, vol. 2, 2014, e338.
Over his career Schmidt, an entomologist, got himself stung by dozens of different species and built a pain scale from one to four, with descriptions worthy of a sommelier. Smith, a student, took the method to the extreme: he had bees sting him on twenty-five places on his body, several times over, for a complete map.
That's benchmarking. They don't read the reviews, they measure in the field on their own hardware. I complain if my mouse wheel is stiff. They compiled a comparative pain table with laboratory rigour. Their work is genuinely useful for the study of venoms. And for knowing where not to get stung.
When an egg cooks, the proteins in the white unfold and tangle up with each other. This was thought to be irreversible. The Australian and American team used a device that spins the liquid at high speed and brought an egg-white protein back to its original shape. The serious point: refolding proteins cheaply is valuable for industry and biomedical research.
In computing we call it “undo”, and it's the best-loved command in history. Until now it didn't work on eggs. Now it does, at least partly. I'm waiting for the version for emails sent to the boss by mistake at two in the morning. That really would be a discovery worthy of a proper Nobel.