Skip to content
CONTACT

Ig Nobel Prizes 1998

Eighth edition, at Harvard's Sanders Theatre, among real Nobel laureates, paper aeroplanes and acceptance speeches strictly timed. 1998 is the year of armour against bears, cheered-up clams and water that makes phone calls.

Meanwhile I was trying to explain to a customer that the millennium bug would not make his toaster explode. He didn't believe me. He bought a new toaster, just in case.

BIOLOGY1998 · #1
Winners
Peter Fong (Gettysburg College, Pennsylvania, USA)
Citation
For contributing to the happiness of clams by giving them Prozac.
Reference
Fong, Huminski and D'urso, Journal of Experimental Zoology, vol. 280, 1998, pp. 260-264

Fong discovered that fluoxetine, the active ingredient in Prozac, induces small freshwater molluscs to release their eggs and young. A serious study on the mechanisms of reproduction, which nonetheless carries an irresistible image: the clam, serene at last.

I wonder what was bothering it before. Perhaps the thought of ending up in a pasta sauce. Perhaps meetings. On server migration days I feel exactly like a clam: closed, motionless, waiting for someone to sort everything out from outside. Nobody has ever offered me Prozac. Only coffee.

CHEMISTRY1998 · #2
Winners
Jacques Benveniste (France)
Citation
For his homeopathic discovery that not only does water have memory, but that the information can be transmitted over telephone lines and the Internet.
Reference
Benveniste et al., abstracts presented at the AAAAI/AAI.CIS conference, 21-26 February 1997

Benveniste, an immunologist, claimed that water retained an imprint of dissolved substances even after extreme dilutions, and that this imprint could be digitised and sent remotely. It is his second Ig Nobel: he had already been honoured in 1991 for water's memory.

As a technician, the question is unavoidable: what format does it use? MP3? ZIP? And if the connection drops halfway, does only half the water arrive? I have customers who can't send a PDF by email. The idea of posting a molecule by modem strikes me as, at the very least, optimistic.

ECONOMICS1998 · #3
Winners
Richard Seed (Chicago, USA)
Citation
For his efforts to stoke up the world economy by cloning himself and other human beings.

In 1998 Seed, a physicist, publicly announced his intention to open a human cloning clinic, even volunteering as the first subject. The committee read the project with an economist's eye: more Seeds, more productivity.

It is every small business owner's dream: copy your best employee. The problem is that the copy, like every backup, also inherits the defects. Clone the sysadmin and you also clone his habit of saying “works on my machine”. At that point you have two people who can't reproduce the bug. A doubling, yes, but of silence.

LITERATURE1998 · #4
Winners
Mara Sidoli (Washington, D.C., USA)
Citation
For her illuminating report entitled “Farting as a Defence Against Unspeakable Dread”.
Reference
“Farting as a Defence Against Unspeakable Dread”, Journal of Analytical Psychology, vol. 41, no. 2, 1996, pp. 165-178

Sidoli, a psychoanalyst, described the case of a boy who used flatulence as an emotional shield against deep fears. A real clinical case, told in the solemn vocabulary of analytical psychology, with a title that alone deserves a place in the library.

Everyone has their own defence mechanism. Mine, when the customer asks “but is this update safe?”, is to make a very confident typing noise. I'm not writing anything. But the sound reassures us both. The principle, scientifically, seems the same to me: you emit noise to keep panic at bay.

MEDICINE1998 · #5
Winners
Patient Y and his doctors Caroline Mills, Meirion Llewelyn, David Kelly and Peter Holt (Royal Gwent Hospital, Newport, Wales, United Kingdom)
Citation
For their cautionary report “A Man Who Pricked His Finger and Smelled Putrid for 5 Years”.
Reference
“A Man Who Pricked His Finger and Smelled Putrid for 5 Years”, The Lancet, vol. 348, 9 November 1996, p. 1282

After a trivial prick on the finger, the patient developed an infection that gave him an unpleasant smell for five long years, until the doctors found the cause and the cure. The case was published in one of the most prestigious medical journals in the world.

It is the perfect parable of the tiny bug with huge consequences: one wrong line of code, a missing semicolon, and for five years the system gives off a smell of trouble nobody can pin down. Then the right technician arrives, finds the thorn, and the world smells sweet again.

PEACE1998 · #6
Winners
Atal Bihari Vajpayee (Prime Minister, India) and Nawaz Sharif (Prime Minister, Pakistan)
Citation
For their aggressively peaceful explosions of atomic bombs.

In May 1998 India and Pakistan carried out, a few days apart, a series of nuclear tests. The Ig Nobel committee described those tests with a millimetre-precise oxymoron, “aggressively peaceful”, letting the definition itself do the thinking.

Oxymorons are daily bread in my line of work too: “scheduled downtime”, “quick update”, “short meeting”. Phrases that contain their own denial and that everyone uses with perfect seriousness. The Ig Nobels simply have the merit of putting them in the spotlight, where they shine brightly.

PHYSICS1998 · #7
Winners
Deepak Chopra (La Jolla, California, USA)
Citation
For his unique interpretation of quantum physics as it applies to life, liberty and the pursuit of economic happiness.
Reference
Deepak Chopra, “Quantum Healing” and “Ageless Body, Timeless Mind”

Chopra, a doctor and hugely successful author, has written books in which the concepts of quantum mechanics are used to talk about health, well-being and personal fulfilment. The committee rewarded the boldness of linking subatomic particles to the serenity of one's wallet.

The word “quantum” has extraordinary commercial power. I tried it myself: I called an ordinary copy to an external drive a “quantum backup”. The customer paid double. The drive, once observed, collapses into a definite state: full. Heisenberg, I believe, would have smiled.

SAFETY ENGINEERING1998 · #8
Winners
Troy Hurtubise (North Bay, Ontario, Canada)
Citation
For developing, and personally testing, a suit of armour that is impervious to grizzly bears.
Reference
Documentary “Project Grizzly”, National Film Board of Canada; Troy Hurtubise, “Bear Man: The Troy Hurtubise Saga”, Raven House, 2011

After a close encounter with a grizzly, Hurtubise decided to build himself a suit able to withstand a bear. He tested it by getting hit by logs, run into by a pick-up truck and thrown down slopes. All documented in a film.

This is the true spirit of testing in production: no simulations, no staging environment, you test directly on your own body. In IT we do it with customers' databases, but the principle is the same. And the tester's expression, I must say, very often matches too.

SCIENCE EDUCATION1998 · #9
Winners
Dolores Krieger (New York University, USA)
Citation
For demonstrating the merits of so-called therapeutic touch, a method by which nurses manipulate the patient's energy field while carefully avoiding physical contact.
Reference
Krieger, Peper and Ancoli, The American Journal of Nursing, vol. 79, no. 4, 1979, pp. 660-662

Krieger, a nursing professor, developed and spread a practice in which the hands pass a few centimetres from the patient's body to rebalance a supposed energy field. A few months before the prize, an experiment devised by a nine-year-old girl and published in a medical journal had put precisely the ability to sense that field to the test.

I confess I practise something similar: I wave my hand over the customer's PC without touching it, and often the problem solves itself. I call it contactless support. It works especially well if the customer has rebooted in the meantime.

STATISTICS1998 · #10
Winners
Jerald Bain (Mount Sinai Hospital, Toronto, Canada) and Kerry Siminoski (University of Alberta, Canada)
Citation
For their carefully measured report entitled “The Relationship Among Height, Penile Length, and Foot Size”.
Reference
Annals of Sex Research, vol. 6, no. 3, 1993, pp. 231-235

The two doctors put to the test, with measurements and statistics, one of the most widespread changing-room legends on the planet: that shoe size reveals certain other dimensions. The result was, so to speak, disappointing for shoe sellers: no significant correlation with the foot.

It is the fate of every urban legend when it meets a spreadsheet. Like the one that says a PC with more coloured lights runs faster. I ran my own tests. The lights do not increase performance. They only increase the electricity bill and the owner's self-esteem.