Skip to content
CONTACT

Ig Nobel Prizes 2011

On 29 September 2011, at Harvard's Sanders Theatre, the 21st First Annual Ig Nobel Prize Ceremony takes place. Yes, the twenty-first first: the most honest version-numbering scheme I have ever seen, more honest than any operating system's. That year the prizes go to beetles in love with a bottle, a fire alarm that smells of sushi and a whole squad of apocalypse calculators with the wrong rounding.

BIOLOGY2011 · #1
Winners
Darryl Gwynne (Canada, Australia, UK, USA) and David Rentz (Australia, USA)
Citation
For discovering that a certain kind of beetle mates with a certain kind of Australian beer bottle.
Reference
D.T. Gwynne and D.C.F. Rentz, “Beetles on the Bottle: Male Buprestids Mistake Stubbies for Females (Coleoptera)”, Journal of the Australian Entomological Society, vol. 22, no. 1, 1983, pp. 79-80.

In Australia someone drinks a beer and leaves the stubby on the ground. Along comes a male beetle, sees a brown, shiny surface covered in little raised dots, and decides it's the love of his life. Gwynne and Rentz documented it with the gravity of a police report: the male prefers the bottle to a real female, because it's bigger and shinier. Better than the original.

It's the first known case of image recognition with too many false positives. I get it: my spam filter once fell in love with a gas bill. But the lesson is serious: a piece of litter left lying around can crash an instinct millions of years old.

CHEMISTRY2011 · #2
Winners
Makoto Imai, Naoki Urushihata, Hideki Tanemura, Yukinobu Tajima, Hideaki Goto, Koichiro Mizoguchi and Junichi Murakami (Japan)
Citation
For determining the ideal density of airborne wasabi to awaken sleeping people in case of a fire or other emergency, and for applying this knowledge to invent the wasabi alarm.
Reference
US patent 9082274B2, “Odor generation alarm and method for informing unusual situation” (application filed 5 February 2009).

The problem is real: people who are hard of hearing may sleep straight through a screaming fire alarm. The solution is Japanese: if the ears don't respond, go through the nose. The device sprays wasabi vapour into the room at just the right concentration, calculated through tests on sleeping people. Nobody stays in bed when the room smells of hot sauce.

It's the push notification taken to its logical extreme. I have a client who hasn't read a warning email in six years. I've asked for a quote on the office model. I'll mount it above the printer, next to the “do not switch off” sign.

LITERATURE2011 · #3
Winners
John Perry (USA, Stanford University)
Citation
For his Theory of Structured Procrastination, which says: to be a high achiever, always work on something important, using it as a way to avoid doing something that's even more important.
Reference
John Perry, “How to Procrastinate and Still Get Things Done”, The Chronicle of Higher Education, 23 February 1996 (later republished as “Structured Procrastination”).

A Stanford philosopher has given academic dignity to what I do every Monday morning. The trick is simple: put a huge, vague task at the top of the list, and to avoid doing it you enthusiastically polish off all the others. The list empties, the huge task stays put, the unmoved mover of productivity.

I've applied it rigorously. To avoid backing up the server I tidied the cables, updated three websites and wrote this comment. The backup is still at the top of the list. I consider it a load-bearing component. Removing it would bring everything down. Touching detail: a colleague went to collect the prize in Perry's place.

MATHEMATICS2011 · #4
Winners
Dorothy Martin (USA), Pat Robertson (USA), Elizabeth Clare Prophet (USA), Lee Jang Rim (Korea), Credonia Mwerinde (Uganda) and Harold Camping (USA)
Citation
For teaching the world to be careful when making mathematical assumptions and calculations. Each of them predicted the end of the world on a specific date: respectively 1954, 1982, 1990, 1992, 1999 and, for Camping, 6 September 1994 and then 21 October 2011.

Six people, six dates for the end of the world, zero releases deployed to production. The committee doesn't judge anyone's beliefs: it rewards the method, namely fixing a deadline to the exact day with no margin of error. The same mistake as the project manager who promises the website for Friday because the Gantt chart says so.

Technical detail: the prize was awarded on 29 September 2011, three weeks before the last announced date. Calculated risk. The world, punctual as an automatic update, then decided to postpone. Moral for developers: always write the delivery date in pencil.

MEDICINE2011 · #5
Winners
Mirjam Tuk (Netherlands, UK), Debra Trampe (Netherlands) and Luk Warlop (Belgium); and jointly Matthew Lewis, Peter Snyder, Robert Feldman (USA), Robert Pietrzak, David Darby and Paul Maruff (Australia)
Citation
For demonstrating that people make better decisions about some kinds of things, but worse decisions about other kinds of things, when they have a strong urge to urinate.
Reference
M.A. Tuk, D. Trampe and L. Warlop, “Inhibitory Spillover: Increased Urination Urgency Facilitates Impulse Control in Unrelated Domains”, Psychological Science, vol. 22, no. 5, 2011, pp. 627-633; M.S. Lewis et al., “The Effect of Acute Increase in Urge to Void on Cognitive Function in Healthy Adults”, Neurourology and Urodynamics, vol. 30, no. 1, 2011, pp. 183-187.

Two independent research groups made volunteers drink water and then put them to the test. Result: those holding on get better at resisting temptation, because self-control “spills over” from one area to another. But in certain attention tasks they do worse, like someone so focused on one thing that they miss everything else.

Now I understand three-hour meetings. Towards the end nobody buys anything, nobody approves budgets, everyone says no. It isn't corporate prudence. It's the bladder running the board of directors. Advice for salespeople: present the quote after the coffee, not before.

PEACE2011 · #6
Winners
Arturas Zuokas, mayor of Vilnius (Lithuania)
Citation
For demonstrating that the problem of illegally parked luxury cars can be solved by running them over with an armoured tank.
Reference
Demonstration video and official statement from Vilnius City Council (2011).

In 2011 the mayor of Vilnius released a video in which an armoured vehicle crushes a luxury car parked where it shouldn't have been. It was a staged demonstration to send a message about illegal parking, and the message made it all the way to Harvard: Zuokas turned up in person to collect the prize.

As a techie I appreciate the solution: it's the “kill -9” of traffic management. No warnings, no fines queued for processing, the process is simply terminated. I don't recommend it for the office car park, but I confess that faced with certain vans parked across the driveway I've considered it. Then I sent an email. Nobody replied.

PSYCHOLOGY2011 · #7
Winners
Karl Halvor Teigen (Norway, University of Oslo)
Citation
For trying to understand why, in everyday life, people sigh.
Reference
K.H. Teigen, “Is a Sigh 'Just a Sigh'? Sighs as Emotional Signals and Responses to a Difficult Task”, Scandinavian Journal of Psychology, vol. 49, no. 1, 2008, pp. 49-57.

Professor Teigen studied the sigh as a communication protocol. His experiments show that people who sigh are usually communicating not joy but resignation: it's the signal of someone giving up on a difficult task, or thinking about something that went wrong.

I know the sigh well. It's the sound a user makes when I ask whether they've tried restarting. It's a compressed data packet: inside is the history of every restart they've ever done, a distrust of technology and a small verdict on me. Teigen decompressed it. He deserves a prize, and perhaps a cup of camomile.

PHYSICS2011 · #8
Winners
Philippe Perrin, Cyril Perrot, Dominique Deviterne, Bruno Ragaru (France) and Herman Kingma (Netherlands)
Citation
For determining why discus throwers become dizzy, and why hammer throwers don't.
Reference
P. Perrin, C. Perrot, D. Deviterne, B. Ragaru and H. Kingma, “Dizziness in Discus Throwers is Related to Motion Sickness Generated While Spinning”, Acta Oto-Laryngologica, vol. 120, no. 3, 2000, pp. 390-395.

Two athletes spin round and throw a heavy object. One staggers off the circle, the other doesn't. The Franco-Dutch team investigated: according to the study, the discus thrower's dizziness is a form of motion sickness linked to how he spins, while the hammer thrower, with a different movement, suffers much less.

It's the same difference as between the CPU fan and the hard drive: both spin, but one makes a racket and the other hums along quietly. I get dizzy even on the office swivel chair. I asked to be enrolled as a control case. They said there was no need: mine is just rotational laziness.

PHYSIOLOGY2011 · #9
Winners
Anna Wilkinson (UK), Natalie Sebanz (Netherlands, Hungary, Austria), Isabella Mandl and Ludwig Huber (Austria)
Citation
For their study entitled “No Evidence of Contagious Yawning in the Red-Footed Tortoise”.
Reference
A. Wilkinson, N. Sebanz, I. Mandl and L. Huber, “No Evidence Of Contagious Yawning in the Red-Footed Tortoise Geochelone carbonaria”, Current Zoology, vol. 57, no. 4, 2011, pp. 477-484.

In humans, yawning spreads like a virus on a network with no antivirus. The researchers wondered whether the same holds for tortoises. They trained a tortoise to yawn on command and put it in front of its companions. The companions watched, with the calm of creatures with a century ahead of them. No contagion.

A negative result, and precious for that very reason: it suggests contagious yawning isn't a simple imitation reflex. Meanwhile I repeated the experiment in a meeting. I yawned in front of the sales manager. He didn't yawn. But he gave me three new tasks. Contagion exists, but it only travels in one direction.

PUBLIC SAFETY2011 · #10
Winners
John Senders (Canada, University of Toronto)
Citation
For conducting a series of safety experiments in which a person drives a car on a major highway while a visor repeatedly flaps down over his face, blinding him.
Reference
J.W. Senders et al., “The Attentional Demand of Automobile Driving”, Highway Research Record, vol. 195, 1967, pp. 15-33.

In the 1960s Senders wanted to measure how much attention driving really takes. The method: a helmet with a visor that drops over the eyes at intervals, which the driver can lift only briefly when he feels the need. That way you measure how long someone can drive in the dark without causing trouble.

It sounds mad, and yet it's one of the foundations of research into distracted driving. Today we have a far more effective visor: it's called a phone, and it drops over our eyes every time a notification arrives. Senders was simply fifty years ahead of his time, and he didn't even need Wi-Fi.