Skip to content
CONTACT

Ig Nobel Prizes 1994

Fourth edition, the last in MIT's Kresge Auditorium: over twelve hundred spectators, officially invited to heckle, with a radio presenter in the role of designated heckler. Banned from the hall: food, water, live animals and nuclear devices.

The prizes officially listed are nine: a tenth, for Physics, was later withdrawn because it was based on press reports that turned out to be wrong. So even the Ig Nobels ship bug fixes. And they document them, which is more than many pieces of software do.

BIOLOGY1994 · #1
Winners
W. Brian Sweeney, Brian Krafte-Jacobs, Jeffrey W. Britton and Wayne Hansen (United States)
Citation
For their study “The Constipated Serviceman: Prevalence Among Deployed US Troops”, and especially for its numerical analysis of bowel movement frequency.
Reference
The Constipated Serviceman: Prevalence Among Deployed US Troops, Military Medicine, 1993

Four military doctors studied how soldiers' bowel habits change when they are sent on deployment: different food, stress, uncomfortable latrines. A concrete issue for troop health, treated with tables and statistics.

What makes you smile is the very seriousness of the charts. We IT people measure everything too: response times, CPU load, minutes of downtime. But none of us has ever had the courage to tabulate the comfort breaks. And yet, come to think of it, the bottleneck is a concept that comes from exactly there.

PEACE1994 · #2
Winners
John Hagelin, Maharishi University of Management (United States)
Citation
For his experimental conclusion that 4,000 trained meditators caused an 18% decrease in violent crime in Washington.
Reference
Report of the Institute of Science, Technology and Public Policy, 1994

In the summer of 1993 thousands of meditation practitioners gathered in Washington, and physicist Hagelin claimed their collective concentration had reduced violent crime in the city. An effect measured remotely, wirelessly and with no need to sign any reports.

It is the power of positive thinking applied to security. I tried it myself with the antivirus: the whole office in silence for ten minutes, eyes closed, visualising a clean network. The viruses didn't notice. On the other hand, it was the calmest meeting of the year.

MEDICINE1994 · #3
Winners
Patient X, former Marine (United States); Richard C. Dart, Rocky Mountain Poison Center, and Richard A. Gustafson, University of Arizona (United States)
Citation
Double prize: to the patient, bitten by his own rattlesnake, for insisting on electroshock treatment, with car spark plug leads attached to his lip and the engine revved to 3,000 rpm for five minutes; to the two doctors, for their study on the failure of this treatment.
Reference
Failure of Electric Shock Treatment for Rattlesnake Envenomation, Annals of Emergency Medicine, 1991

A man bitten by his pet snake became convinced that an electric shock would neutralise the venom. He had the car leads connected to his mouth and the engine revved. He arrived at hospital not only poisoned but electrocuted too. The doctors who treated him wrote a paper explaining that no, it does not work.

It is the hard reboot taken to the extreme: when something goes wrong, apply power and hope. With computers it sometimes works. With the human body, as the two doctors put in black and white, it definitely does not. The golden rule stands: call the helpdesk, not the battery.

ENTOMOLOGY1994 · #4
Winners
Robert A. Lopez (United States)
Citation
To the valiant veterinarian and friend of all creatures great and small, for his series of experiments in obtaining ear mites from cats, inserting them into his own ear, and carefully observing and analysing the results.
Reference
Of Mites and Man, Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, 1993

Lopez wanted to know whether cat ear mites could also infest humans. Instead of looking for volunteers, he used the only patient who is always available and never complains: himself. He repeated the experiment several times, noting itching, noises and healing times.

It is the true technician's approach: before installing an update on customers' computers, you try it on your own. If something goes wrong, only one person is to blame and complaints arrive in a single inbox. Admirable dedication, though I would still prefer a virtual machine.

PSYCHOLOGY1994 · #5
Winners
Lee Kuan Yew, former Prime Minister of Singapore (Singapore)
Citation
To the practitioner of the psychology of negative reinforcement, for his thirty-year study of the effects of punishing three million citizens whenever they spat, chewed gum or fed pigeons.

Singapore is famous for its strict rules on cleanliness and public decorum, with fines for behaviour that goes unnoticed elsewhere, from chewing gum to pigeons. The prize ironically presents all this as a gigantic psychology experiment lasting thirty years.

Seen through a sysadmin's eyes, it is a security policy applied to an entire nation: clear rules, checks, sanctions. The dream of anyone running a company network full of users who install everything. I would settle for a token fine for anyone who leaves their password on a sticky note.

LITERATURE1994 · #6
Winners
L. Ron Hubbard (United States)
Citation
To the science fiction author and founder of Scientology, for his book “Dianetics”, highly profitable to mankind or at least to a portion of it.
Reference
Dianetics, 1950

Hubbard was a prolific science fiction writer, and his book Dianetics, published in 1950, presented a method for mental well-being that later became the basis of a movement. The prize, awarded after his death, plays on the word profitable, leaving readers to wonder who gained what.

As a science fiction reader, I will limit myself to a technical observation: very few authors in the genre have seen a book of theirs have such a concrete sequel off the page. Most of us make do with a tidy bookshelf and the odd heated argument down the pub.

CHEMISTRY1994 · #7
Winners
Bob Glasgow, Texas State Senator (United States)
Citation
To the wise writer of logical legislation, for sponsoring the 1989 drug law that makes it illegal to buy beakers, flasks, test tubes and other laboratory glassware without a permit.

To hamper clandestine drug labs, Texas passed a law requiring a permit to buy laboratory glassware. The result was that students, chemistry enthusiasts and small laboratories also found themselves having to request authorisation for a test tube.

It is the classic problem of rules that are too broad. In IT it happens when, to block a virus, you block every PDF attachment. The virus stays out, sure. But so do the supplier's invoice, the contract and the canteen menu.

ECONOMICS1994 · #8
Winners
Juan Pablo Dávila, former trader at the state-owned company Codelco (Chile)
Citation
For instructing his computer to “buy” when he meant “sell”, and then trying to recoup with increasingly disastrous trades, until he had lost 0.5% of Chile's gross national product. In his honour his fellow countrymen coined the verb “davilar”, meaning to make a colossal mess of things.

A trader at the state copper company entered the wrong command: buy instead of sell. Then, to put things right, he made more trades, which made things worse, and more still. In the end the loss amounted to half a point of national product.

This is the most IT-related prize in the whole history of the Ig Nobels. One wrong click, no confirmation prompt, no undo button. Every time a program asks me whether I am sure, I think of him and thank him. Being remembered as a verb, in any case, is something not even the great inventors have achieved.

MATHEMATICS1994 · #9
Winners
Southern Baptist Church of Alabama (United States)
Citation
To the measurers of morality, for their county-by-county estimate of how many Alabama citizens will go to Hell if they don't repent.

A religious community drew up a detailed estimate, broken down by county, of the number of people at risk of eternal damnation, based on its own criteria. The prize does not judge the beliefs: it celebrates the statistical ambition of putting the afterlife into a table.

As a technician, I admire the granularity. Not a national estimate, not one per state, but county by county, like a regional sales report. I only wonder what format the spreadsheet was in and who had the job of keeping it up to date. I imagine it was the most stressful job in the office.