Skip to content
CONTACT

Ig Nobel Prizes 2008

October 2008, Harvard's Sanders Theatre: the eighteenth Ig Nobel ceremony. The official theme of the evening is redundancy. I repeat: redundancy. As a sysadmin, I finally felt understood. Two power supplies, two disks, two themes.

Across the stage paraded archaeologist armadillos, intelligent slime moulds, crisps crunchier than the real thing and an entire country honoured for granting dignity to plants.

ARCHAEOLOGY2008 · #1
Winners
Astolfo G. Mello Araujo and José Carlos Marcelino (University of São Paulo, Brazil)
Citation
For measuring how the contents of an archaeological dig site can be scrambled by the actions of a live armadillo.
Reference
“The Role of Armadillos in the Movement of Archaeological Materials: An Experimental Approach”, Geoarchaeology, 2003.

Archaeologists date finds partly by the layer they're found in. Then along comes an armadillo, digs like a hammer drill and moves everything: the ancient pot goes down, the recent coin comes up. The two researchers put an armadillo in a pen with fake artefacts and measured the damage.

Scientific proof that the past is as fragile as a shared folder. All it takes is one keen colleague who “tidies up the files a bit” and three hundred years of history become a single folder called “New folder (7)”.

BIOLOGY2008 · #2
Winners
Marie-Christine Cadiergues, Christel Joubert and Michel Franc (National Veterinary School of Toulouse, France)
Citation
For discovering that the fleas that live on a dog can jump higher than the fleas that live on a cat.
Reference
“A Comparison of Jump Performances of the Dog Flea, Ctenocephalides canis, and the Cat Flea, Ctenocephalides felis felis”, Veterinary Parasitology, 2000.

The dog flea versus cat flea contest is finally settled. Team Dog wins, jumping higher and further. Put like that it raises a smile, but understanding how fleas move helps fight them better, and pet owners are grateful.

I picture the Flea Olympics, with the opening ceremony on the living-room rug. The cat flea, interviewed after the event, declares that she doesn't jump: she waits for the cat to walk past. A truly feline strategy.

CHEMISTRY2008 · #3
Winners
Sharee A. Umpierre, Joseph A. Hill and Deborah J. Anderson (USA); Chuang-Ye Hong, C.C. Shieh, P. Wu and B.N. Chiang (Taiwan)
Citation
Shared prize: the first team for discovering that Coca-Cola is an effective spermicide, the second for discovering that it is not.
Reference
“Effect of Coke on Sperm Motility”, New England Journal of Medicine, 1985; “The Spermicidal Potency of Coca-Cola and Pepsi-Cola”, Human Toxicology, 1987.

One research team says yes, another says no, and the Ig Nobels reward both with a single citation. The perfect summary of science: a result counts for nothing until someone tries to repeat it. And if it doesn't add up, you argue. For the record, Coca-Cola is not a contraceptive, and nobody should use it as one.

Same thing happens on tech forums: one user writes that the trick works, the one below swears it doesn't. The difference is that here they at least published their data. On forums, usually, only their caps lock.

COGNITIVE SCIENCE2008 · #4
Winners
Toshiyuki Nakagaki, Hiroyasu Yamada, Ryo Kobayashi, Atsushi Tero, Akio Ishiguro (Japan) and Ágota Tóth (University of Szeged, Hungary)
Citation
For discovering that slime moulds can solve puzzles.
Reference
“Intelligence: Maze-Solving by an Amoeboid Organism”, Nature, 2000.

A brainless slime mould, Physarum, placed in a maze with food at the entrance and the exit, spreads everywhere and then retreats until only the shortest path is left. It solved the maze. No neurons, no screen, no online tutorial.

Ever since, whenever a meeting spends two hours choosing a cable route, I think of the slime mould. It would have settled it in one night, in the dark, for free. And it wouldn't have asked to reconvene next week to “look into it further”.

ECONOMICS2008 · #5
Winners
Geoffrey Miller, Joshua Tybur and Brent Jordan (University of New Mexico, USA)
Citation
For discovering that professional lap dancers earn higher tips when they are in the fertile phase of their cycle.
Reference
“Ovulatory Cycle Effects on Tip Earnings by Lap Dancers: Economic Evidence for Human Estrus?”, Evolution and Human Behavior, 2007.

The researchers collected tip data from dozens of work shifts and matched them against the ovulatory cycle. Result: on fertile days, takings rose markedly. It's evolutionary psychology, suggesting how subtle, unconscious signals influence other people's behaviour.

Economics, in short, isn't just charts and interest rates. Sometimes it's signals nobody sees, like the computer fan warning you of a fault weeks in advance. Except nobody listens to it.

LITERATURE2008 · #6
Winners
David Sims (Cass Business School, London, UK)
Citation
For his study of the experience of indignation within organisations, under a decidedly unacademic exclamation of a title.
Reference
“You Bastard: A Narrative Exploration of the Experience of Indignation within Organizations”, Organization Studies, 2005.

Anyone who has worked in an office knows the feeling: someone takes credit for your work and you seethe inside. David Sims studied it the way you study a natural phenomenon, gathering stories and analysing how indignation is born and grows in the workplace. The paper's title is the part everyone remembers.

I know indignation well. It arrives when a colleague writes “works for me” under your bug report. You don't need a doctorate to understand it, but having it in your bibliography does look good.

MEDICINE2008 · #7
Winners
Dan Ariely (Duke University, USA), Rebecca L. Waber (MIT, USA), Baba Shiv (Stanford University, USA) and Ziv Carmon (INSEAD, Singapore)
Citation
For demonstrating that high-priced fake medicine is more effective than low-priced fake medicine.
Reference
“Commercial Features of Placebo and Therapeutic Efficacy”, Journal of the American Medical Association, 2008.

Two identical pills, both with no active ingredient. One presented as expensive, the other as discounted. Volunteers taking the “pricey” one reported less pain. Price alone cures. Or at least convinces us we've been cured.

Sellers of gold-plated HDMI cables know this well; their customers swear they see brighter colours. I tried a three-euro network cable and a thirty-euro one. The packets arrived identical. But the thirty-euro cable, I admit, made me feel safer.

NUTRITION2008 · #8
Winners
Massimiliano Zampini (University of Trento, Italy) and Charles Spence (University of Oxford, UK)
Citation
For electronically modifying the sound of a potato crisp to make the person chewing it believe it to be crisper and fresher than it really is.
Reference
“The Role of Auditory Cues in Modulating the Perceived Crispness and Staleness of Potato Chips”, Journal of Sensory Studies, 2004.

Volunteers bit into crisps wearing headphones, and the researchers amplified the “crunch” in real time. The louder the sound, the fresher the crisps seemed. Taste goes through the ears too: the brain mixes all the senses and draws its own conclusions. A slice of Italy on the podium, and well deserved.

I'm thinking of an office application: a sound effect that makes any vending-machine snack crunchy. The problem remains the vending machine, which eats your coins without making any sound at all.

PEACE2008 · #9
Winners
The Swiss Federal Ethics Committee on Non-Human Biotechnology and the citizens of Switzerland (Switzerland)
Citation
For adopting the legal principle that plants have dignity.
Reference
“The Dignity of Living Beings with Regard to Plants”, Committee report, 2008.

The Swiss Constitution requires respect for the “dignity of creation”, and the ethics committee pondered what that means for plants. The conclusion: you may not harm them without good reason. Picking a flower at random out of boredom, for instance, is ethically questionable. The rest of plant life carries on undisturbed.

Since that day I've treated the office ficus with more respect. It's been there fifteen years, has seen six versions of Windows come and go and has never complained. It deserves dignity. And perhaps some water.

PHYSICS2008 · #10
Winners
Dorian M. Raymer (Scripps Institution of Oceanography, USA) and Douglas E. Smith (University of California, San Diego, USA)
Citation
For proving mathematically that heaps of string or hair or almost anything else will inevitably tangle themselves up in knots.
Reference
“Spontaneous Knotting of an Agitated String”, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2007.

The two physicists put pieces of string in a spinning box and counted the knots, thousands of times. Result: the longer and floppier the string, the more likely it is to knot itself. We all suspected it, but now there's proof.

At last I have a scientific justification for the cable drawer. I put them away neatly, coil them, label them. A week later they're a single organism. It isn't untidiness: it's physics. I'll write it on a sign and stick it on the drawer.