Ig Nobel Prizes 2004
On 30 September 2004 at Harvard the inventor of karaoke also took the stage, honoured for peace, that is, for teaching humanity to tolerate one another while singing off-key. The same evening: the patented comb-over, the gorilla nobody sees and the five-second rule. I sang only in my head, out of respect for my desk neighbours.
- Winners
- Steven Stack and James Gundlach (USA)
- Citation
- For their report on the effect of country music on suicide.
- Reference
- “The Effect of Country Music on Suicide”, Social Forces, vol. 71, no. 1, 1992
- Winners
- Ramesh Balasubramaniam (Canada) and Michael Turvey (USA)
- Citation
- For exploring and explaining the dynamics of hula-hooping.
- Reference
- “Coordination Modes in the Multisegmental Dynamics of Hula Hooping”, Biological Cybernetics, vol. 90, no. 3, 2004
Spinning a hoop around your hips looks like a beach game, but it requires coordinating ankles, knees, hips and torso in real time. The two researchers filmed and measured the movements, discovering how the body finds different coordination modes to keep the hoop in orbit.
It is a feedback control system, like the CPU fan that speeds up when it gets hot. Except here you are the processor and the heatsink is made of coloured plastic. I gave it a go: kernel panic on the second turn.
- Winners
- Jillian Clarke (USA)
- Citation
- For investigating the scientific validity of the five-second rule, according to which food dropped on the floor is safe to eat if picked up quickly.
- Reference
- News release from the College of ACES, University of Illinois, 2 September 2003
Jillian Clarke was a secondary school student on an internship at the University of Illinois. She placed biscuits and sweets on contaminated tiles and found that a few seconds are enough for bacteria to transfer to the food. She also noticed that people apply the rule mostly to sweet things.
The five-second rule is like “it's fine, there's a backup”: a legend we keep because it's convenient. Science says no. We, faced with the biscuit, pretend we never read it.
- Winners
- The Coca-Cola Company of Great Britain (United Kingdom)
- Citation
- For using advanced technology to convert ordinary tap water from the River Thames into Dasani, which was then made unavailable to consumers as a precaution.
In 2004 the company launched Dasani bottled water in the United Kingdom, produced from mains water through a purification process. A few weeks later the batches were recalled when tests found bromate levels above the legal limit, and the brand was withdrawn in the country.
A story every technician knows: you add a step to improve the product and that step introduces the problem. In IT we call it an update. Always test in a staging environment before bottling.
- Winners
- Donald J. Smith and the late Frank J. Smith (USA)
- Citation
- For patenting the comb-over, the method of combing hair to cover partial baldness.
- Reference
- US Patent no. 4,022,227, 1977
Father and son from Orlando, Florida, set down in a patent the exact method for dividing hair into three sections and layering them so as to cover a bald patch. A layered procedure, technical drawings and all.
It is the very definition of a workaround: you don't solve the problem, you cover it elegantly and hope nobody looks from above. I know entire corporate systems designed like that. They work beautifully until a windy day comes along.
- Winners
- American Nudist Research Library (USA)
- Citation
- For preserving nudist history so that everyone can see it.
In Kissimmee, Florida, there is a library devoted to collecting books, magazines, photographs and documents of the American naturist movement. A serious archive, run by volunteers, on a subject many treat only with an embarrassed snigger.
The citation plays on the double meaning, but the work is the precious one of every archivist: saving things before they vanish. The same mission as people who keep old installation floppies. Nobody wants to see them. Then one day they're needed, and you're a hero in your pants. Or without.
- Winners
- Daniel Simons and Christopher Chabris (USA)
- Citation
- For demonstrating that when people pay close attention to something, it's all too easy to overlook anything else, even a woman in a gorilla suit.
- Reference
- “Gorillas in Our Midst: Sustained Inattentional Blindness for Dynamic Events”, Perception, vol. 28, 1999
In the famous experiment, participants watched a video and counted one team's passes. Halfway through, a person dressed as a gorilla walked across the scene and beat their chest. About half the viewers did not see it at all. It's called inattentional blindness.
It is the scientific explanation for every time a user tells me “there was no error message”. There was. It was big. It was flashing. But he was counting passes. From today I forgive him: the gorilla is invisible even to the best of us.
- Winners
- The Vatican (Vatican City)
- Citation
- For outsourcing prayers to India.
The prize refers to a practice reported in the press: Mass intentions requested by Western faithful, accompanied by offerings, were partly forwarded to priests in India, where clergy are numerous and local requests less frequent. The citation describes it in corporate language.
And it's precisely that language that raises a smile: “outsourcing”, “offshoring”, boardroom words applied to something ancient. The global world has turned everything into a service to be routed. Even I, these days, get support from a call centre that is always in another time zone.
- Winners
- Daisuke Inoue (Japan)
- Citation
- For inventing karaoke, thereby providing an entirely new way for people to learn to tolerate each other.
Daisuke Inoue, a musician in Kobe, built a machine in the Seventies that played backing tracks so bar customers could sing. He never patented it, so he never got rich from it, but he changed evenings out across half the world for ever.
The peace prize is well deserved: karaoke is the only social system in which everyone knows they're getting it wrong and everyone applauds anyway. A test environment open to the public, with the bugs belted out at full volume. If meetings worked like that, we'd close far more projects.
- Winners
- Ben Wilson, Lawrence Dill (Canada), Robert Batty (United Kingdom), Magnus Wahlberg (Denmark) and Håkan Westerberg (Sweden)
- Citation
- For showing that herrings apparently communicate by farting.
- Reference
- “Pacific and Atlantic Herring Produce Burst Pulse Sounds”, Biology Letters, vol. 271, 2003 (suppl.); Aquatic Living Resources, vol. 16, 2003
The researchers recorded herrings and found that they release bursts of bubbles from the anal opening, producing a high-frequency sound. They christened it with a very witty acronym, FRT. The hypothesis is that it helps them keep in touch with the shoal at night, when they can't see.
It is a low-power, always-on communication network, with a protocol no engineer would have dared propose in a meeting. And yet it works. It reminds me of certain company systems: noisy, embarrassing, but they hold the group together.
The two sociologists compared, across various US metropolitan areas, how much airtime country music got with suicide rates, finding a correlation and suggesting a link with the songs' melancholy themes. The study was later debated and challenged by other researchers.
The prize recalls a golden rule that applies to company charts too: correlation is not causation. I once noticed that the servers always failed when the consultant came in. It wasn't him. It was the July heat. I think.