Ig Nobel Prizes 2010
On 30 September 2010, at Harvard's Sanders Theatre, the twentieth Ig Nobel ceremony is celebrated. The theme of the evening is bacteria: small, everywhere, impossible to uninstall. Like certain browser toolbars.
That year the winners include a slime mould that designs railways better than engineers, a group of physicists wearing socks over their shoes and three Italians who recommend promoting people at random. I reread the citation three times. It makes sense.
- Winners
- Libiao Zhang, Min Tan, Guangjian Zhu, Jianping Ye, Tiyu Hong, Shanyi Zhou, Shuyi Zhang (China) and Gareth Jones (University of Bristol, UK)
- Citation
- For scientifically documenting fellatio by fruit bats.
- Reference
- “Fellatio by Fruit Bats Prolongs Copulation Time”, PLoS ONE, 2009.
- Winners
- Eric Adams (MIT, USA), Scott Socolofsky (Texas A&M, USA), Stephen Masutani (University of Hawaii, USA) and BP (UK)
- Citation
- For disproving the old belief that oil and water don't mix.
- Reference
- Studies and technical report (2005) on the behaviour of oil and gas released in deep water.
The three scientists studied how oil leaking at depth disperses in the water, forming droplets and plumes that stay suspended instead of all rising to the surface. The prize, in the year of the Deepwater Horizon platform disaster in the Gulf of Mexico, was also awarded, with typical Ig Nobel irony, to the company involved.
The scientific lesson is that proverbs are fine in the kitchen, but in the lab they need checking. Like “don't mix network cables and power cables”. That one, though, is true. Trust me.
- Winners
- The executives and directors of Goldman Sachs, AIG, Lehman Brothers, Bear Stearns, Merrill Lynch and Magnetar (USA)
- Citation
- For creating and promoting new ways to invest money, ways presented as able to maximise financial gain and minimise financial risk for the world economy, or for a portion thereof.
The prize refers to the complex financial instruments, such as mortgage-linked derivatives, at the heart of the 2007-2008 financial crisis. The Ig Nobels, with their customary satirical formula, honour the idea of an investment that promises maximum gain with minimum risk.
Anyone in IT knows that promise: “the new system will do everything by itself, with no costs and no risks”. The next sentence is usually “except the migration”. The moral applies to everyone: if a project has no risks, it's only because they haven't been written into the quote yet.
- Winners
- Karina Acevedo-Whitehouse and Agnes Rocha-Gosselin (Zoological Society of London, UK) and Diane Gendron (Instituto Politécnico Nacional, Mexico)
- Citation
- For perfecting a method to collect whale snot, using a remote-control helicopter.
- Reference
- “A Novel Non-Invasive Tool for Disease Surveillance of Free-Ranging Whales and Its Relevance to Conservation Programs”, Animal Conservation, 2010.
When a whale breathes, its blowhole sends up a spray full of information about its health. To collect it without disturbing the animal, the researchers flew a small remote-control helicopter fitted with collection plates over it. A medical drone, before drones were fashionable.
This is engineering in its purest form: absurd problem, practical solution. It reminds me of the time I fished a cable out from behind a cupboard with a broom handle and an elastic band. Nobody gave me a prize, but the cable still works.
- Winners
- Alessandro Pluchino, Andrea Rapisarda and Cesare Garofalo (University of Catania, Italy)
- Citation
- For demonstrating mathematically that organisations would become more efficient if they promoted people at random.
- Reference
- “The Peter Principle Revisited: A Computational Study”, Physica A, 2010.
The Peter Principle says everyone gets promoted until they reach the level at which they are incompetent. The three physicists from Catania simulated an organisation on a computer and found that, under certain conditions, promoting at random gives better results than promoting whoever was best in their previous role. Because a good programmer isn't automatically a good boss.
An Italian prize, and a very practical one. A proposal for companies: at the next internal interview, a die. Roll a six, you're director. Roll a one, you get the third-floor printer. Which is still a promotion, spiritually.
- Winners
- Simon Rietveld (University of Amsterdam, Netherlands) and Ilja van Beest (Tilburg University, Netherlands)
- Citation
- For discovering that symptoms of asthma can be relieved by a roller-coaster ride.
- Reference
- “Rollercoaster Asthma: When Positive Emotional Stress Interferes with Dyspnea Perception”, Behaviour Research and Therapy.
The researchers took a group of people with asthma to a funfair and measured how they perceived their breathing before and after the roller coaster. Positive stress, adrenaline and fun reduced the feeling of breathlessness. Careful: the perception improved, but lung function itself did not. So no prescriptions for the funfair.
It reminds me of the client who, after a reboot, says “it's much better now”. The problem is identical, but the perception has changed. The mind is the most powerful component in the system.
- Winners
- Richard Stephens, John Atkins and Andrew Kingston (Keele University, UK)
- Citation
- For confirming the widely held belief that swearing relieves pain.
- Reference
- “Swearing as a Response to Pain”, NeuroReport, 2009.
Volunteers kept a hand in ice-cold water for as long as possible, repeating either a swear word or a neutral word. With the swear word they held out longer and felt less pain. The reason seems to be a small fight-or-flight response that raises the pain threshold.
At last a scientific basis for what you hear in every office when the printer jams for the third time. It isn't rudeness: it's analgesia. One tip, though: it works better if swearing is rare. Those who swear all the time, the study found, get less benefit.
- Winners
- Lianne Parkin, Sheila Williams and Patricia Priest (University of Otago, New Zealand)
- Citation
- For demonstrating that, on icy footpaths in wintertime, people slip less if they wear socks on the outside of their shoes.
- Reference
- “Preventing Winter Falls: A Randomised Controlled Trial of a Novel Intervention”, New Zealand Medical Journal, 2009.
In Dunedin, New Zealand, there's a local tradition: in winter people pull socks over their shoes so as not to slip. The researchers tested it with a controlled trial on icy downhill streets. Result: those wearing socks slipped less and felt safer. Folk wisdom, for once, passes the test.
The kind of solution I love: cheap, ridiculous, effective. Like sticky tape over the webcam. Nobody would sell it in an elegant catalogue, but it works better than plenty of things that are sold.
- Winners
- Manuel Barbeito, Charles Mathews and Larry Taylor (Industrial Health and Safety Office, Fort Detrick, Maryland, USA)
- Citation
- For determining by experiment that microbes cling to bearded scientists.
- Reference
- “Microbiological Laboratory Hazard of Bearded Men”, Applied Microbiology, 1967.
In 1967 the three researchers sprayed harmless bacteria on the beards of some volunteers, then washed the beards and checked how many bacteria were left. Plenty, even after washing. The conclusion concerned laboratory safety: a beard can trap microbes and carry them out of the lab.
Every bearded techie now knows he's a small portable archive, an external drive nobody has ever formatted. I don't have a beard, but the office keyboard, judging by what it contains, deserves a study of its own.
- Winners
- Toshiyuki Nakagaki, Atsushi Tero, Seiji Takagi, Tetsu Saigusa, Kentaro Ito, Kenji Yumiki, Ryo Kobayashi (Japan), Dan Bebber and Mark Fricker (UK)
- Citation
- For using slime mould to determine the optimal routes for railway lines.
- Reference
- “Rules for Biologically Inspired Adaptive Network Design”, Science, 2010.
The researchers laid out oat flakes as if they were the cities around Tokyo and added Physarum, the food-seeking slime mould. Within a few hours the mould had built a network of links very similar to the area's actual railway network, efficient and resilient to faults. Nakagaki, already honoured in 2008, wins his second Ig Nobel.
A slime mould that designs railways for free and without meetings. The day they use it to design corporate networks, I'm changing jobs. Maybe I'll become an oat flake.
Watching a colony of fruit bats, the researchers noticed a behaviour that until then had been described almost only in humans. They documented it rigorously, even timing the mating. Serious ethology, reminding us how little we know about the animal world.
The funny part is the contrast between the subject and the academic tone: tables, minutes, seconds, statistics. Like reading a washing-machine manual written by a solicitor. All precise, all correct, and meanwhile the reader can't keep a straight face.