Skip to content
CONTACT

Ig Nobel Prizes 2006

October 2006, Harvard University's Sanders Theatre: the sixteenth Ig Nobel ceremony, the prizes for research that first makes people laugh and then makes them think. The audience, as tradition demands, throws paper aeroplanes at the stage. I would have catalogued them by model and stall speed, but nobody asked me.

That year science turned its attention to cheese, spaghetti, fingernails on blackboards and the most stubborn hiccups in history. A serious vintage. Very serious. Almost too serious.

ACOUSTICS2006 · #1
Winners
D. Lynn Halpern, Randolph Blake and James Hillenbrand (USA)
Citation
For conducting experiments to learn why people dislike the sound of fingernails scraping on a blackboard.
Reference
“Psychoacoustics of a Chilling Sound”, Perception and Psychophysics, 1986.

Three researchers took humanity's most hated sound and took it apart like an old modem: frequency by frequency, to find out which bit gives us the shivers. Surprise: it isn't the high notes, it's the middle frequencies. Which explains why cutting the treble does nothing. Like buying antivirus software for the computer when the real problem is the cousin who clicks on everything.

I ran a similar experiment at the office with the jammed laser printer. Same result, but nobody gave me a prize. Just a technician, who never turned up.

BIOLOGY2006 · #2
Winners
Bart Knols and Ruurd de Jong (Netherlands; also affiliated in Tanzania, Austria and Italy)
Citation
For showing that the female malaria mosquito Anopheles gambiae is attracted equally to the smell of Limburger cheese and to the smell of human feet.
Reference
“On Human Odour, Malaria Mosquitoes, and Limburger Cheese”, The Lancet, 1996; “Limburger Cheese as an Attractant for the Malaria Mosquito Anopheles gambiae s.s.”, Parasitology Today, 1996.

Malaria mosquitoes can't tell a human foot from a mature cheese. To them it's the same file with a different extension. The clever part is that the discovery is deadly serious: if you know what attracts them, you can build better traps and save lives. Limburger becomes bait; the foot stays a foot.

My uncle kept cheese in the cellar next to the server. He said it kept the hackers away. He never suffered a cyberattack, but the mosquitoes queued up to get in. Now I understand why.

CHEMISTRY2006 · #3
Winners
Antonio Mulet, José Javier Benedito, José Bon (University of Valencia, Spain) and Carmen Rosselló (University of the Balearic Islands, Spain)
Citation
For their study of the speed of ultrasound in Cheddar cheese at different temperatures.
Reference
“Ultrasonic Velocity in Cheddar Cheese as Affected by Temperature”, Journal of Food Science, 1999.

A team of Spanish researchers gave a Cheddar an ultrasound scan. Not to find out whether it was a boy or a girl, but to measure how fast sound travels through cheese at different temperatures. It sounds like a joke; it's actually quality control: ultrasound tells you what a cheese is like inside without cutting it. Non-invasive diagnosis. For a cheese.

I do the same with hard drives: I listen to them. If they go tick-tick, ultrasound or not, it's time for a backup. The Cheddar, on the other hand, is always in excellent spirits.

LITERATURE2006 · #4
Winners
Daniel Oppenheimer (Princeton University, USA)
Citation
For his research on the consequences of using difficult words when they aren't needed, under a title made of deliberately enormous words.
Reference
“Consequences of Erudite Vernacular Utilized Irrespective of Necessity: Problems with Using Long Words Needlessly”, Applied Cognitive Psychology, 2006.

Oppenheimer showed that people who write in a complicated way to sound clever are judged... less clever. And to say so he picked a title that reads like a software licence agreement. The paradox is perfect: the paper is living proof of its own thesis.

I recommend it to every consultant I know. The ones who say “implement a scalable value-oriented synergy” when they mean “turn it off and on again”. I once wrote a three-line email. The client replied: “Is that it?”. Yes. That's it. It works.

MATHEMATICS2006 · #5
Winners
Nic Svenson and Piers Barnes (CSIRO, Australia)
Citation
For calculating the number of photographs you must take to (almost) ensure that nobody in a group photo will have their eyes closed.
Reference
“Blink-free photos, guaranteed”, Velocity magazine, June 2006.

The oldest problem in group photography finally has a formula. The more people, the more shots you need; in poor light, even more. A rule of thumb every wedding photographer should have tattooed on their arm. Pure statistics applied to the aunt who shuts her eyes exactly on the click.

I tried the formula at the company dinner. Thirty-two colleagues, forty-seven shots. In the best one nobody had their eyes closed, but the mail server had gone down and everyone was staring at their phone. Mathematics can't foresee everything.

MEDICINE2006 · #6
Winners
Francis M. Fesmire (University of Tennessee, USA); Majed Odeh, Harry Bassan and Arie Oliven (Bnai Zion Medical Center, Israel)
Citation
Prize shared by two teams who, in separate case reports, described how intractable hiccups were stopped with digital rectal massage.
Reference
“Termination of Intractable Hiccups with Digital Rectal Massage”, Annals of Emergency Medicine, 1988; study of the same name in the Journal of Internal Medicine, 1990.

Persistent hiccups are a serious bug: some patients have them for days. The doctors tried the least elegant fix in the manual, and it worked. Twice, in two different countries, with two papers bearing the same title. In IT we'd call that a “reproducible bug”, which is every technician's dream.

The principle, apparently, is to stimulate a nerve that resets the reflex. A hard reboot, in short. I shall keep recommending a glass of water drunk upside down. It doesn't work, but at least you can do it in the kitchen.

NUTRITION2006 · #7
Winners
Wasmia Al-Houty (Kuwait University) and Faten Al-Mussalam (Kuwait Environment Public Authority) (Kuwait)
Citation
For showing that dung beetles are finicky eaters.
Reference
“Dung Preference of the Dung Beetle Scarabaeus cristatus Fab (Coleoptera-Scarabaeidae) from Kuwait”, Journal of Arid Environments, 1997.

You'd think a dung beetle would settle for anything. Wrong. The researchers offered the beetles various kinds of dung and they chose with the fussiness of a restaurant critic. They have precise preferences. They have a menu. They probably leave reviews too.

It confirms a universal law: even those who work with the humblest material have standards. Like the sysadmin who has handled twenty-year-old dusty cables but flatly refuses to use a mouse whose scroll wheel grinds.

ORNITHOLOGY2006 · #8
Winners
Ivan R. Schwab (University of California, Davis, USA) and the late Philip R.A. May (UCLA, USA)
Citation
For exploring and explaining why woodpeckers don't get headaches.
Reference
“Cure for a Headache”, British Journal of Ophthalmology, 2002; “Woodpeckers and Head Injury”, The Lancet, 1976.

A woodpecker headbutts a tree thousands of times a day, with decelerations that would flatten anyone. And yet no migraine. The secret is anatomy: a small, firmly anchored brain, a sturdy skull, blows perfectly in line. A system designed specifically for banging your head. The very thing I need in front of certain accounting software.

The studies have even inspired ideas for better helmets and protection. That's the lovely part of the Ig Nobels: you start with a silly question and end up with something useful. Meanwhile, the woodpecker keeps working. No holidays.

PEACE2006 · #9
Winners
Howard Stapleton (Merthyr Tydfil, Wales, UK)
Citation
For inventing an electromechanical device that annoys teenagers but not adults, and for later using the same technology to make ringtones that only teenagers can hear.
Reference
The “Mosquito” device and its high-frequency ringtone.

Stapleton exploited a real fact: as we age we lose the ability to hear the highest frequencies. He built a gadget that emits a whine only young people can hear, to discourage them from hanging around outside shops. Then the kids turned the idea on its head: a high-frequency ringtone, so the phone rings in class and the teacher hears nothing.

That's the history of technology in two lines. You invent a firewall, and the next day somebody uses it to hide their traffic. Teenagers, in this respect, are the finest penetration testers on the planet.

PHYSICS2006 · #10
Winners
Basile Audoly and Sébastien Neukirch (Université Pierre et Marie Curie, Paris, France)
Citation
For their insights into why, when you bend dry spaghetti, it often breaks into more than two pieces.
Reference
“Fragmentation of Rods by Cascading Cracks: Why Spaghetti Does Not Break in Half”, Physical Review Letters, 2005.

You bend a strand of spaghetti to snap it in two and get three, four, sometimes a tiny fragment that vanishes under the fridge for ever. The two physicists found out why: the first break sends a wave that makes the pieces vibrate and break again. A cascading failure, like an update that breaks the driver that breaks the printer that breaks the day.

Science has answered a question a famous twentieth-century physicist once asked himself in the kitchen. In the kitchen I only ask myself where the charger has gone.