Ig Nobel Prizes 2016
On 22 September 2016, at Harvard's Sanders Theatre, the 26th First Annual Ig Nobel Prize Ceremony takes the stage. Also on stage: the mini-opera “The Last Second”, about officials who slip a leap second in at the end of the year to commit financial crimes. I used that second to reboot the router. It wasn't enough.
- Winners
- The late Ahmed Shafik (Egypt)
- Citation
- For studying the effects of wearing polyester, cotton, or wool trousers on the sex life of rats, and for conducting similar tests with human males.
- Reference
- “Effect of Different Types of Textiles on Sexual Activity. Experimental study”, European Urology, 1993; “Contraceptive Efficacy of Polyester-Induced Azoospermia in Normal Men”, Contraception, 1992
- Winners
- Mark Avis, Sarah Forbes and Shelagh Ferguson (New Zealand, United Kingdom)
- Citation
- For assessing the perceived personalities of rocks, from a sales and marketing perspective.
- Reference
- “The Brand Personality of Rocks: A Critical Evaluation of a Brand Personality Scale”, Marketing Theory, 2014
The researchers asked people to describe the character of some rocks, using the scales marketing uses to measure brand personality. People answered. With conviction. One rock was sincere, another decidedly sophisticated.
The real point was serious: if a measuring tool gives results even on a pebble, maybe the tool has a bug. Brothers and sisters of branding! Every stone has a soul. And a target audience. Meanwhile my server, down in the cellar, has been classified as an introverted rock. It hasn't answered a ping since Tuesday.
- Winners
- Gábor Horváth, Susanne Åkesson, Hansruedi Wildermuth and colleagues (Hungary, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland)
- Citation
- For discovering why white-haired horses are the most horsefly-proof horses, and for discovering why dragonflies are fatally attracted to black tombstones.
- Reference
- “An Unexpected Advantage of Whiteness in Horses”, Proceedings of the Royal Society B, 2010; “Ecological Traps for Dragonflies in a Cemetery”, Freshwater Biology, 2007
It all comes down to polarised light. Horseflies and dragonflies look for water by recognising light reflected by surfaces in a certain way. A white horse reflects weakly polarised light and is almost invisible to horseflies. A shiny black tombstone, on the other hand, looks like a perfect pond: the dragonflies lay their eggs on it and things end badly.
It's the same principle as my black monitor when it's switched off: from a distance it looks like a minimalist operating system. Users click on it for ten minutes. Then they call me.
- Winners
- Volkswagen (Germany)
- Citation
- For solving the problem of excessive automobile pollution emissions by automatically, electromechanically producing fewer emissions whenever the cars are being tested.
- Reference
- Press release from the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), “EPA, California Notify Volkswagen of Clean Air Act Violations”, 18 September 2015
The facts are well known: control software recognised when the car was on the test bench and made it behave impeccably at that very moment. Outside the lab, life went back to normal. The Ig Nobel committee awarded it in Chemistry, with the solemnity of someone pinning on a medal for merit.
As a sysadmin I recognise the pattern: it's the computer that works perfectly the moment the technician arrives. Except that usually it does it on its own, out of spite. Here someone had written the code on purpose.
- Winners
- Christoph Helmchen, Carina Palzer, Thomas Münte, Silke Anders and Andreas Sprenger (Germany)
- Citation
- For discovering that if you have an itch on the left side of your body, you can relieve it by looking into a mirror and scratching the right side of your body (and vice versa).
- Reference
- “Itch Relief by Mirror Scratching. A Psychophysical Study”, PLoS ONE, 2013
The volunteers looked in a mirror and scratched the arm that wasn't itching. The brain saw the reflection, believed it was scratching the right one and the itch calmed down. An optical trick put to good use.
It's the principle of the backup server nobody has ever checked: just knowing it's there lets everyone sleep soundly. I'll try the method on support requests. A user writes to me about the first-floor printer. I reboot the second-floor one in front of a mirror. Let's see if it goes away.
- Winners
- Evelyne Debey, Maarten De Schryver, Gordon Logan, Kristina Suchotzki and Bruno Verschuere (Belgium, Netherlands, Germany, Canada, USA)
- Citation
- For asking a thousand liars how often they lie, and for deciding whether to believe those answers.
- Reference
- “From Junior to Senior Pinocchio: A Cross-Sectional Lifespan Investigation of Deception”, Acta Psychologica, 2015
The study followed lying across the whole lifespan: you learn to lie as a child, reach peak form as a young adult, then decline. To measure it the researchers did the most logical and most absurd thing at once: they asked liars how many lies they tell.
A textbook paradox, like asking Windows how long until the update finishes. It answers. Confidently. Three minutes. Meanwhile I call it by its name, we keep each other company, and the figure has stayed the same since 2019.
- Winners
- Gordon Pennycook, James Allan Cheyne, Nathaniel Barr, Derek Koehler and Jonathan Fugelsang (Canada, USA)
- Citation
- For their scholarly study called “On the Reception and Detection of Pseudo-Profound Bullshit”.
- Reference
- “On the Reception and Detection of Pseudo-Profound Bullshit”, Judgment and Decision Making, 2015
The researchers generated random sentences made of lofty words, grammatically perfect and devoid of meaning, and asked people how profound they were. Many found them very profound indeed. The original title uses a rude word, but with scientific rigour.
I've heard these sentences live. They're called digital transformation meetings. “The cloud is not a place, it is a journey towards the inner self of the data.” Applause. Now we know there's a measure for this. It should be installed in every conference room, next to the projector that doesn't work.
- Winners
- Charles Foster and Thomas Thwaites (United Kingdom), joint award
- Citation
- Awarded jointly to Charles Foster, for living in the wild as, at different times, a badger, an otter, a deer, a fox, and a bird; and to Thomas Thwaites, for creating prosthetic extensions of his limbs that allowed him to move in the manner of, and spend time roaming hills in the company of, goats.
- Reference
- Charles Foster, “Being a Beast”, Profile Books, 2016; Thomas Thwaites, “GoatMan: How I Took a Holiday from Being Human”, Princeton Architectural Press, 2016
Two Englishmen, one question: what is it like to be an animal? Foster slept in a sett and ate earthworms to understand the badger. Thwaites built himself goat legs and grazed in Switzerland, complete with an attempt to digest grass.
It's total immersion, like when a sysadmin tries to understand the user: he spends a day double-clicking everything and saving files on the desktop. Then he goes back to being human. But something stays with him. Me, for instance: since then I always drink my coffee standing up, like a goat.
- Winners
- Fredrik Sjöberg (Sweden)
- Citation
- For his three-volume autobiographical work about the pleasures of collecting flies that are dead, and flies that are not yet dead.
- Reference
- Fredrik Sjöberg, “The Fly Trap” (first volume of the trilogy published in English), Pantheon Books, 2015
Fredrik Sjöberg lives on a Swedish island and collects hoverflies, flies that disguise themselves as bees. He has drawn three books from it, and it's real literature: reflections on patience, on obsession and on cataloguing the world one species at a time.
I understand him. I too collect things other people swat away: USB cables in extinct shapes, orphaned power supplies, floppy disks whose contents I do not know. My wife says they're all flies. I reply that only the third volume is missing to turn them into culture.
- Winners
- Atsuki Higashiyama and Kohei Adachi (Japan)
- Citation
- For investigating whether things look different when you bend over and view them between your legs.
- Reference
- “Perceived Size and Perceived Distance of Targets Viewed From Between the Legs: Evidence for Proprioceptive Theory”, Vision Research, 2006
The scholars had volunteers look at distant objects while bent over upside down, gazing between their knees. The objects looked smaller and closer. In Japan there's even a tradition recommending this position for admiring certain landscapes.
I've been applying the method for years: when a network problem looks huge, I bend down under the desk and look at the cables between my legs. The problem immediately looks smaller. It remains unsolved, but smaller. Then I stand up again, and now I've got backache too.
Ahmed Shafik dressed rats in little trousers made of different fabrics and took notes. Result: polyester, with its static electricity, does not help one's love life. Not for rats and, as he later checked, not for humans either. Polyester creates electrostatic fields: in practice, the trousers were acting as a firewall.
The genius part is that Dr Shafik genuinely explored the idea of a textile contraceptive. I own a shell suit from 1994. A great deal about my adolescence now makes sense.