Ig Nobel Prizes 2019
On 12 September 2019 Harvard's Sanders Theatre welcomes the 29th First Annual Ig Nobel Prize Ceremony, on the theme of habits. The mini-opera, set in a museum of bad habits, makes its debut. That year, incidentally, a Silvano wins. It isn't me. But I did a Mexican wave anyway.
- Winners
- Silvano Gallus (Italy)
- Citation
- For collecting evidence that pizza might protect against illness and death, if the pizza is made and eaten in Italy.
- Reference
- “Does Pizza Protect Against Cancer?”, International Journal of Cancer, 2003; “Pizza and Risk of Acute Myocardial Infarction”, European Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2004; “Pizza Consumption and the Risk of Breast, Ovarian and Prostate Cancer”, European Journal of Cancer Prevention, 2006
- Winners
- Karen Pryor and Theresa McKeon (USA)
- Citation
- For using a simple animal-training technique, called clicker training, to train surgeons to perform orthopedic surgery.
- Reference
- “Is Teaching Simple Surgical Skills Using an Operant Learning Program More Effective Than Teaching by Demonstration?”, Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research, 2016
The clicker is a little gadget that goes click: with dogs it's used to mark the right behaviour instantly. The winners applied it to surgical trainees, to teach them knots and precise movements. The study showed they learned better than by watching a demonstration.
Now I understand everything. The clicker is the mouse. Every time the user clicks the right button, the computer gives them a reward. Every time they click the wrong one, an update window appears. Operant conditioning. For twenty years. On a global scale.
- Winners
- Ling-Jun Kong, Herbert Crepaz, Agnieszka Górecka, Aleksandra Urbanek, Rainer Dumke and Tomasz Paterek (Singapore, Austria, China, Poland and others)
- Citation
- For discovering that dead magnetized cockroaches behave differently than living magnetized cockroaches.
- Reference
- “In-Vivo Biomagnetic Characterisation of the American Cockroach”, Scientific Reports, 2018
The physicists magnetised some cockroaches and measured how long they stayed magnetic. In live insects the magnetisation faded faster: the particles inside the body were moving. In dead insects, on the other hand, it lasted longer. Serious research into the ability to sense magnetic fields.
Excellent data for a sysadmin: the live cockroach is a disk that demagnetises itself, the dead one a stable archive. In short, the ideal insect for backups is a dead one. I don't know what that means. But I'll put it in the documentation.
- Winners
- Roger Mieusset and Bourras Bengoudifa (France)
- Citation
- For measuring scrotal temperature asymmetry in naked and clothed postmen in France.
- Reference
- “Thermal Asymmetry of the Human Scrotum”, Human Reproduction, 2007
The two doctors from Toulouse measured the temperature of both sides of the scrotum in volunteers, postmen included, both clothed and unclothed, standing and walking. In most cases the left side was warmer. Temperature matters for fertility, so the question is a serious one.
It's exactly what I do with servers: infrared thermometer, a walk round the rack, and I find the left side runs hotter. Usually because of a cable. As for French postmen, I did not look into it further, and I shall not.
- Winners
- Shigeru Watanabe, Mineko Ohnishi, Kaori Imai, Eiji Kawano and Seiji Igarashi (Japan)
- Citation
- For estimating the total saliva volume produced per day by a typical five-year-old child.
- Reference
- “Estimation of the Total Saliva Volume Produced Per Day in Five-Year-Old Children”, Archives of Oral Biology, 1995
The Japanese researchers measured the saliva produced by five-year-olds while eating, resting and sleeping. Result: about half a litre a day. A useful figure for dental health and for understanding how drugs act in the mouth.
Half a litre a day, for a five-year-old user. I can confirm it with field data: the keyboards of my clients with small children run at one hundred per cent relative humidity. It's advisable to give them a waterproof keyboard. Or, better, a second-hand tablet and a great deal of patience.
- Winners
- Iman Farahbakhsh (Iran)
- Citation
- For inventing a diaper-changing machine for use on human babies.
- Reference
- US patent 10,034,582, “Automatic baby diaper changer”, granted 31 July 2018
Iman Farahbakhsh designed and patented a device which, with a system of belts, washing and drying, changes a baby's nappy automatically. On paper it all adds up: a repetitive, unpleasant and frequent process is the perfect candidate for automation.
As a technician I admire the courage. No production system in the world has a more unpredictable input workload. I'm waiting for version 2.0, the one with the event log. But I fear the push notifications.
- Winners
- Habip Gedik, Timothy A. Voss and Andreas Voss (Turkey, Netherlands, Germany)
- Citation
- For testing which country's paper money is best at transmitting dangerous bacteria.
- Reference
- “Money and Transmission of Bacteria”, Antimicrobial Resistance and Infection Control, 2013
The researchers contaminated banknotes from various countries, including the euro, the dollar and the Romanian leu, and measured how long the bacteria survived. Plastic banknotes, like the Romanian ones, turned out to be more welcoming to some microbes. Money, in short, has an ecosystem too.
At last, proof that cash is a storage medium: it retains information, even unwanted information, for a long time. My client who pays in cash always told me: “Money doesn't smell”. The study is more nuanced.
- Winners
- Ghada A. bin Saif, Alexandru Papoiu, Liliana Banari, Francis McGlone, Shawn G. Kwatra, Yiong-Huak Chan and Gil Yosipovitch (United Kingdom, Saudi Arabia, Singapore, USA)
- Citation
- For trying to measure the pleasurability of scratching an itch.
- Reference
- “The Pleasurability of Scratching an Itch: A Psychophysical and Topographical Assessment”, British Journal of Dermatology, 2012
The researchers induced itching in various parts of volunteers' bodies and then asked how pleasant it was to scratch. The rankings: ankle and back beat forearm. Understanding the pleasure of scratching helps treat people who suffer from chronic itching.
The Ig Nobels and itching, we note, are in a stable relationship: in 2016 there was already the mirror one. Perhaps it's a subscription. For my part, I confirm that scratching a bug that has been annoying you for months gives the same satisfaction. The ankle of the code, let's say.
- Winners
- Fritz Strack (Germany)
- Citation
- For discovering that holding a pen in one's mouth makes one smile, which makes one happier, and for then discovering that it does not.
- Reference
- “Inhibiting and Facilitating Conditions of the Human Smile”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1988; “From Data to Truth in Psychological Science. A Personal Perspective”, Frontiers in Psychology, 2017
In 1988 Fritz Strack published a famous experiment: people holding a pen between their teeth, forced into a sort of smile, find cartoons funnier. Decades later, a large international replication did not confirm the effect, and Strack discussed it openly.
The prize celebrates the full cycle of science: discovery, verification, refutation, reflection. Like a patch that fixes the problem, then another patch that removes the first. Meanwhile I keep a pen in my mouth during meetings. I don't smile. But at least I don't talk.
- Winners
- Patricia Yang, Alexander Lee, Miles Chan, Alynn Martin, Ashley Edwards, Scott Carver and David Hu (USA, Taiwan, Australia, New Zealand, Sweden, United Kingdom)
- Citation
- For studying how, and why, wombats make cube-shaped poo.
- Reference
- “Intestines of Non-Uniform Stiffness Mold the Corners of Wombat Feces”, Soft Matter, 2021; abstract presented to the American Physical Society, Division of Fluid Dynamics, 2018
The wombat, an Australian marsupial, produces cube-shaped droppings. David Hu's team discovered the trick: the intestinal walls have stiffer zones and more elastic zones, which shape the corners during the slow formation. No mould, just tissue mechanics.
It's nature inventing stackability before we did. Little cubes that don't roll away and mark territory in an orderly fashion. A wombat, in practice, compiles in voxel format. I've been fitting servers into racks for thirty years, and I feel a professional envy that is hard to describe.
Silvano Gallus, an epidemiologist in Milan, observed that in Italy people who eat pizza regularly have a slightly lower risk of some diseases. He himself has always pointed out that pizza is probably a marker of a Mediterranean eating pattern rather than a medicine.
But the committee spotted the brilliant detail: the localisation clause. It only works in Italy. It's a pizza with a regional licence, like certain software. Outside the borders, no warranty. As his namesake, I feel protected. Two margheritas a week: that's prevention.