Ig Nobel Prizes 1991
October 1991, MIT Museum, Cambridge, Massachusetts: the very first Ig Nobel ceremony takes place, hosted by Marc Abrahams. Winners receive a medal that, when turned over, lets out a piercing scream. A real Nobel laureate turns up in a fake nose and glasses, and the Education prize is collected by a young girl who swears she will study maths.
That year three prizes also went to openly fictitious winners, including the discovery of Administratium, the heaviest element in the universe. Here you will find the seven real ones. Which, for a version 1.0, is an excellent ratio of real data: I know databases in far worse shape.
- Winners
- Robert Klark Graham (United States)
- Citation
- For creating the Repository for Germinal Choice, a sperm bank that accepted donations only from Nobel laureates and Olympic champions.
- Winners
- Jacques Benveniste (France)
- Citation
- For his persistent discovery that water would be an intelligent liquid, able to remember substances of which no trace remains.
- Reference
- Davenas et al., Nature, 1988
Benveniste claimed that water, even diluted until not a single molecule of the original substance was left, kept a memory of it. A sort of cache that survives formatting the disk. Every technician's dream, every data protection officer's nightmare.
The problem was that other labs could not reproduce the experiment. In IT we call that the bug that only shows up on the customer's PC. Benveniste thus became one of the very few people to win two Ig Nobels: the second in 1998, for sending water's memory down the phone line and over the Internet. Attachment included.
- Winners
- Michael Milken (United States)
- Citation
- To the Wall Street titan regarded as the father of junk bonds, for his contribution to the world of finance.
Junk bonds are high-yield, high-risk securities: loans to people offering generous interest precisely because they might not pay you back. In the Eighties Milken turned them into a huge market, with legal consequences that made the papers all over the world.
What strikes me is the name. Calling a product junk and still managing to sell it is the summit of marketing. I tried it with an old Pentium sitting in a drawer: honest ad, honest price, not a single call. Clearly I lacked the vision.
- Winners
- J. Danforth Quayle (United States)
- Citation
- To the Vice President of the United States, for demonstrating better than anyone else the need for science education.
An Education prize that rewards not a teacher, but the need for teachers. It is like giving the best antivirus trophy to the most infected computer in the office: it did nothing, but it convinced everybody to install one.
At the ceremony the prize was collected by a young girl who introduced herself as his stand-in and solemnly promised to study maths and science. Which, come to think of it, was exactly the point. When a prize achieves its goal during the handover itself, the efficiency is such that any company would cut it at once for excessive results.
- Winners
- Erich von Däniken (Switzerland)
- Citation
- For the book “Chariots of the Gods?”, in which he argues that human civilisation was influenced by ancient astronauts from outer space.
- Reference
- Chariots of the Gods?, 1968
The book's thesis is that pyramids, giant ground drawings and ancient monuments are the work, or at least the consultancy, of extraterrestrial visitors. Humans, bless them, could never have managed on their own.
It is the same theory I hear in the office whenever a printer works first time: someone from outside must have come in. I, on the other hand, rather admire the ancients. They moved blocks weighing tonnes with no manual, no helpdesk and no forgotten passwords. Had aliens come, they would at least have left a power cable behind.
- Winners
- Alan Kligerman (United States)
- Citation
- To the pioneer of digestive technology, inventor of Beano, for his anti-gas liquids that prevent bloat, gassiness and embarrassment.
Beano is an enzyme supplement that helps digest the sugars in beans and vegetables, the ones that would otherwise ferment and produce gas. A firewall for the gut: it blocks outbound traffic before it becomes a diplomatic incident.
Kligerman was the happiest winner of the evening, with the audience chanting the product's name as if at a football match. And he has a point: of all the 1991 laureates, he is the one who has actually improved the most meetings. Every windowless meeting room should have his portrait hanging next to the projector.
- Winners
- Edward Teller (United States)
- Citation
- To the father of the hydrogen bomb and first champion of the “Star Wars” space shield, for his lifelong efforts to change the meaning of the word peace.
The paradox is all in the citation: the Peace prize to the physicist who helped build the most powerful bomb ever made and then promoted a missile defence system in space. Peace through deterrence, meaning the serenity of whoever holds the biggest stick.
In IT we know the doctrine well: the sysadmin who, to prevent attacks, puts a firewall in front of the firewall, then a third firewall to keep an eye on the first two. Nobody gets in any more. Not even the users. At the ceremony nobody collected the prize, and the band played a space theme.
The idea was simple: if you want clever, athletic children, get the genetic material straight from certified manufacturers. It is the logic of someone who buys the most expensive PC convinced it will write better emails by itself. Genetics, sadly, does not read spec sheets.
The best part is the entry filter: Nobel or gold medal. Stricter access control than any server room I have ever seen. Shame nobody planned an intermediate tier for sysadmins, who can reboot anything but never win anything.