Ig Nobel Prizes 1995
On 6 October 1995 the ceremony moves from MIT to Harvard University's Sanders Theatre, on the other side of Cambridge, and is broadcast live on the Internet. This is 1995: to watch it you needed a modem, patience and a connection that didn't drop when someone picked up the phone.
It is the year of pigeons that recognise Picasso and of soggy cereal studied rigorously by engineers. Improbable science officially enters the digital age, network broadcast and all. The rest of the world will get there in its own good time.
- Winners
- John Martinez, J. Martinez & Company of Atlanta (United States)
- Citation
- For Luak coffee, the world's most expensive coffee, made from beans ingested and excreted by the palm civet, a small mammal from Indonesia.
- Winners
- Dominique M. R. Georget, R. Parker and Andrew C. Smith, Institute of Food Research, Norwich (United Kingdom)
- Citation
- For their rigorous analysis of soggy breakfast cereal, published in the study on the effects of water content on the compaction behaviour of breakfast cereal flakes.
- Reference
- A Study of the Effects of Water Content on the Compaction Behaviour of Breakfast Cereal Flakes, Powder Technology, 1994
Three researchers measured how cereal flakes behave under pressure as humidity varies. Translation: why cereal in milk turns to mush, and how fast. A serious problem for the food industry, which has to guarantee crunchiness.
It is one of those cases where science puts a universal trauma into formulas. Every one of us has watched our breakfast go limp while answering a phone call. I have only now understood the phenomenon: it is not my fault, it is compaction behaviour. I shall say so too when the bowl stays on the desk next to the server.
- Winners
- Nick Leeson and his superiors at Barings Bank (United Kingdom) and Robert Citron of Orange County, California (United States)
- Citation
- For using the calculus of derivatives to demonstrate that every financial institution has its limits.
- Reference
- Barings Lost; Big Bets Gone Bad
Leeson, a Barings trader in Singapore, ran up enormous losses on derivatives trades, until in 1995 one of the oldest banks in the United Kingdom collapsed. Citron, Orange County treasurer, drove the county into bankruptcy in 1994 with very risky investments.
The citation plays on the mathematical double meaning: derivatives and derivatives, limits and limits. It is a lesson every sysadmin knows. A disk has a space limit, a server has a load limit, and sooner or later somebody goes to check it in person. The most expensive way is to do it with real money.
- Winners
- Marcia E. Buebel, David S. Shannahoff-Khalsa and Michael R. Boyle (United States)
- Citation
- For their invigorating study of the effects of unilateral forced nostril breathing on cognitive performance.
- Reference
- The Effects of Unilateral Forced Nostril Breathing on Cognition, International Journal of Neuroscience, 1991
The researchers tested whether breathing with one nostril closed affected different mental tasks, starting from the idea that each side of the nose might be linked to one hemisphere of the brain. One nostril for logic, the other for space.
If it worked, it would be the cheapest optimisation ever invented: no new processor, just a finger on your nose. I can already picture company meetings, with half the room breathing through the left for the budget figures and the other half through the right for the slides. Meanwhile I carry on with both, for redundancy.
- Winners
- David B. Busch and James R. Starling, Madison, Wisconsin (United States)
- Citation
- For their deeply penetrating study of rectal foreign bodies, with case reports and a comprehensive review of the world's literature on the subject.
- Reference
- Rectal Foreign Bodies: Case Reports and a Comprehensive Review of the World's Literature, Surgery, 1986
Two surgeons collected the cases described in the medical literature of objects ending up where they shouldn't, which then have to be retrieved in hospital. The list quoted by the prize includes light bulbs, torches, a cup, a tobacco tin and even a whole set with spectacles and a suitcase key.
It is a catalogue that leaves you speechless, compiled with the seriousness of a warehouse inventory. Working in support I have found impossible things inside printers, including a teaspoon. I thought I had seen it all. This study taught me there is always a stranger place.
- Winners
- The Legislative Yuan, the national parliament of Taiwan (Taiwan)
- Citation
- For demonstrating that politicians gain more by punching, kicking and gouging each other than by waging war against other nations.
In the Nineties Taiwan's parliament became known for brawls in the chamber during the most heated debates, filmed by television crews from all over the world. The prize ironically reinterprets them as a way of letting off conflict at home rather than abroad.
It is the sandbox principle: a closed environment where processes can fight as much as they like without damaging the rest of the system. Every office should have one. Ours already does, it's called the Monday meeting: lots of noise, no casualties, and at the end the printer is still broken anyway.
- Winners
- Shigeru Watanabe, Junko Sakamoto and Masumi Wakita, Keio University (Japan)
- Citation
- For their success in training pigeons to discriminate between the paintings of Picasso and those of Monet.
- Reference
- Pigeons' Discrimination of Paintings by Monet and Picasso, Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 1995
The pigeons were rewarded with food when they pecked the paintings by the right artist. After training they recognised the style even in paintings they had never seen. In effect, the first image classifier trained on birdseed.
Today we call all this machine learning: lots of examples, a reward when the answer is right, and the system learns to generalise. Except we use ruinously expensive graphics cards and they used a bag of seeds. If a pigeon ever applies for a data scientist job, I shall interview it with the utmost respect.
- Winners
- Martha Kold Bakkevig, SINTEF Unimed, Trondheim (Norway), and Ruth Nielsen, Technical University of Denmark (Denmark)
- Citation
- For their exhaustive study of the impact of wet underwear on thermoregulatory responses and thermal comfort in the cold.
- Reference
- Impact of Wet Underwear on Thermoregulatory Responses and Thermal Comfort in the Cold, Ergonomics, 1994
Two Scandinavian researchers measured how body temperature changes when wearing wet underwear in a cold environment, comparing different fabrics. A serious matter for people who work outdoors, fish in the North Sea or do winter sports.
The result, in short, confirms what every child discovers after a snowball fight: it is a terrible idea. But science needs measurements, not impressions. It is like server cooling: everyone knows heat is bad, but you need a thermometer to convince accounts to buy the air conditioning.
- Winners
- Robert H. Beaumont, Shoreview, Minnesota (United States)
- Citation
- For his incisive study of patient preference between waxed and unwaxed dental floss.
- Reference
- Patient Preference for Waxed or Unwaxed Dental Floss, Journal of Periodontology, 1990
Beaumont asked patients which type of dental floss they preferred, waxed or unwaxed, collecting the answers with scientific method. The prize plays on the adjective incisive, which in dentistry is also a tooth.
It is survey fever applied to the oral cavity, and I understand it. In IT we spend months arguing over light theme or dark theme, mechanical keyboard or silent one. The great technological holy wars are born this way. The difference is that he at least published his results, while we are still arguing.
- Winners
- Bijan Pakzad, Beverly Hills (United States)
- Citation
- For creating DNA cologne and DNA perfume, neither of which contains deoxyribonucleic acid, both sold in a triple-helix bottle.
A fashion designer launched two fragrances called DNA, with a bottle inspired by the shape of the famous molecule. Pity that DNA has a double helix, while the bottle had three. And of DNA in the liquid, not a trace.
It is tech marketing in its purest form: take a scientific word that sounds impressive, put it on the label and add an extra helix for good measure. Today the same happens with artificial intelligence, which appears on the packaging of toothbrushes and toasters. I eagerly await the quantum toaster. With three helices, naturally.
The civet eats the coffee cherries, digests the pulp and expels the beans. Someone collects them, cleans them, roasts them and sells them at jeweller's prices. Martinez sold exactly this coffee, one of the dearest on the planet.
It is a business model every consultant should study: the raw material is processed for free by an animal, the process is slow and weird, and precisely for that reason the end product is worth more. In software we call it added value. In the forest they call it something else, but the result is the same.