Ig Nobel Prizes 2022
The 32nd ceremony took place on 15 September 2022, once again online only, streamed. Ten prizes ranging from lovers' hearts to scorpions with intestinal problems, by way of a moose-shaped crash test dummy. It was the typical year in which science did its job: answering seriously questions that no committee would ever have approved.
- Winners
- Eliska Prochazkova, Elio Sjak-Shie, Friederike Behrens, Daniel Lindh, Mariska Kret (Czech Republic, Netherlands, United Kingdom, Sweden, Aruba)
- Citation
- For seeking and finding evidence that when new romantic partners meet for the first time, and feel attracted to each other, their heart rates synchronize.
- Reference
- “Physiological Synchrony is Associated with Attraction in a Blind Date Setting”, Nature Human Behaviour, 2022.
- Winners
- Eric Martínez, Francis Mollica, Edward Gibson (Canada, USA, United Kingdom, Australia)
- Citation
- For analyzing what makes legal documents unnecessarily difficult to understand.
- Reference
- “Poor Writing, Not Specialized Concepts, Drives Processing Difficulty in Legal Language”, Cognition, 2022.
They compared contracts with ordinary texts and ran reading tests. Chief culprit: not the technical terms, but the endless sentences with clauses stuffed inside other clauses. Legalese is hard because it's badly written, not because it's deep.
I knew it. I once read the terms of use of some accounting software: after page three there was a sentence with seven subordinate clauses and a reference to an appendix that didn't exist. I clicked “I accept” like everyone else. Now I've found out it wasn't me being ignorant: the text was written in spaghetti code.
- Winners
- Solimary García-Hernández, Glauco Machado (Brazil, Colombia)
- Citation
- For studying whether and how constipation affects the mating prospects of scorpions.
- Reference
- “Fitness Implications of Nonlethal Injuries in Scorpions: Females, but Not Males, Pay Reproductive Costs”, American Naturalist, 2021; other related studies on tail autotomy in scorpions (2020-2021).
Some scorpions, when grabbed by a predator, detach their tail to escape. The problem is that the tail also contains the last part of the intestine. The scorpion survives, but can no longer relieve itself: it becomes constipated, for ever. The researchers studied how this affects its love life.
It's the biological version of the quick fix in production: you solve today's emergency by cutting off a piece of the system, and find out months later that the piece was used to offload the data. The scorpion, at least, doesn't have to explain it in a meeting.
- Winners
- Marcin Jasiński, Martyna Maciejewska, Anna Brodziak, Emilian Snarski and colleagues (Poland)
- Citation
- For showing that, during certain kinds of toxic chemotherapy, replacing the traditional ice with ice cream reduces painful side effects in the mouth.
- Reference
- “Ice-Cream Used as Cryotherapy During High-Dose Melphalan Conditioning Reduces Oral Mucositis after Autologous Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation”, Scientific Reports, 2021.
During some chemotherapy treatments, patients are given ice to suck: the cold reduces painful sores in the mouth. But ice is unpleasant and many give up. The Polish doctors tried ice cream. It works just as well, and patients take it gladly.
It's the most important lesson of IT applied to medicine: a perfect solution the user doesn't use is worth nothing. A good solution the user adores is worth everything. The only funny part here is the title. The rest is pure genius, with whipped cream.
- Winners
- Gen Matsuzaki, Kazuo Ohuchi, Masaru Uehara, Yoshiyuki Ueno, Goro Imura (Japan)
- Citation
- For trying to discover the most efficient way for people to use their fingers when turning a knob.
- Reference
- “How to Use Fingers during Rotary Control of Columnar Knobs”, Bulletin of Japanese Society for the Science of Design, 1999.
They watched dozens of volunteers turning knobs of different diameters, counting how many fingers they used. The bigger the knob, the more fingers are needed, following a precise progression. There are data, graphs and diameters to the millimetre.
I feel personally addressed. For thirty years I've been turning volume knobs, thermostats and the dials of old CRT monitors with no strategy whatsoever, wasting fingers at random. Now I know there was a method. And like every method that arrives thirty years late, I shan't follow it.
- Winners
- Peter de Smet, Nicholas Hellmuth (Netherlands, Guatemala, USA, Austria)
- Citation
- For their study “A Multidisciplinary Approach to Ritual Enema Scenes on Ancient Maya Pottery”.
- Reference
- “A Multidisciplinary Approach to Ritual Enema Scenes on Ancient Maya Pottery”, Journal of Ethnopharmacology, 1986.
A pharmacologist and a scholar of Maya art examined vases showing scenes of ritual enemas, probably used to take intoxicating substances. They combined iconography and pharmacology to understand what those paintings really show.
It's a useful reminder for anyone who designs interfaces: in a thousand years someone will study our icons and understand nothing. Why does a floppy disk mean save? Why does a cog mean settings? I only hope that, for us, an equally serious research group will be set up.
- Winners
- Frank Fish, Zhi-Ming Yuan, Minglu Chen, Laibing Jia, Chunyan Ji, Atilla Incecik (China, United Kingdom, Turkey, USA)
- Citation
- For trying to understand how ducklings manage to swim in formation.
- Reference
- “Energy Conservation by Formation Swimming: Metabolic Evidence from Ducklings”, 1994; “Wave-Riding and Wave-Passing by Ducklings in Formation Swimming”, Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 2021.
Ducklings lined up behind their mother don't do it for looks: they ride the waves made by the one in front and save energy, a bit like cyclists in a peloton. A study from the nineties measured it, one from 2021 explained it with fluid dynamics.
Every office has this formation. At the front is the one who opens the tickets, behind is the line of colleagues advancing in his wake. The first one toils, the others glide. The difference is that ducklings, every so often, change places.
- Winners
- Junhui Wu, Szabolcs Számadó, Pat Barclay, Bianca Beersma, Paul Van Lange and colleagues (China, Hungary, Canada, Netherlands, United Kingdom, Italy, Australia, Switzerland, USA)
- Citation
- For developing an algorithm to help gossipers decide when to tell the truth and when to lie.
- Reference
- “Honesty and Dishonesty in Gossip Strategies: A Fitness Interdependence Analysis”, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B, 2021.
The team built a theoretical model of gossip: who spreads it, who receives it, who it's about, and how closely their interests are linked. Depending on the relationships, the model predicts when it pays to be honest and when it doesn't.
At last, an algorithm for the coffee machine. From today, office gossip is no longer an art, it's a flowchart. The only thing that worries me is the next step: someone will put it into a chatbot, and corridor chatter will get its own automatic overnight update.
- Winners
- Alessandro Pluchino, Alessio Emanuele Biondo, Andrea Rapisarda (Italy)
- Citation
- For explaining, mathematically, why success most often goes not to the most talented people, but instead to the luckiest.
- Reference
- “Talent vs. Luck: The Role of Randomness in Success and Failure”, Advances in Complex Systems, 2018.
Three physicists from the University of Catania ran a computer simulation of a population with different talents, exposed for years to random lucky and unlucky events. In the end the richest weren't the most able, but those with average talent and plenty of luck.
It's scientific confirmation of what every technician suspects on seeing a mediocre project go into production without a single error first time. It isn't merit, it's the random number generator. Luckily, at least the prize went to some very capable people.
- Winners
- Magnus Gens (Sweden)
- Citation
- For developing a moose crash test dummy.
- Reference
- “Moose Crash Test Dummy”, master's thesis, KTH Royal Institute of Technology, published by the Swedish National Road and Transport Research Institute, 2001.
In Sweden collisions between cars and moose are a serious problem: the animal is tall, heavy, and when hit it ends up on the windscreen. To study these accidents, a dummy with the right proportions was needed. Magnus Gens built one for his thesis.
I admire the consistency: if the problem is a moose, the test is done with a moose. No abstract simulations, no slides. For years I ran load tests on servers with fake data. I should have built a full-scale fake user, with the same patience and the same weight.
The researchers organised blind dates with the participants wired up to sensors. What predicted attraction wasn't smiles or glances, but physiological synchrony: heartbeat and sweating keeping time together.
In practice, love is a system clock synchronisation protocol. Two nodes meet, negotiate the frequency, and if the signal lines up the connection is made. If it doesn't, timeout. That's how it went with my wife. She says it isn't true, but her heartbeat wasn't configured to testify.