Ig Nobel Prizes 2012
On 20 September 2012, at Harvard's Sanders Theatre, the 22nd First Annual Ig Nobel Prize Ceremony is held. During the evening the organisers also fix a thirteen-year-old bug: in 1999 they had forgotten a winner, Joseph Keller, who thus becomes a winner twice in one go. And two days after the ceremony, two of the Psychology winners get married: no Windows update has ever had such happy side effects.
- Winners
- Kazutaka Kurihara and Koji Tsukada (Japan)
- Citation
- For creating the SpeechJammer, a machine that disrupts a person's speech by making them hear their own spoken words at a very slight delay.
- Reference
- K. Kurihara and K. Tsukada, “SpeechJammer: A System Utilizing Artificial Speech Disturbance with Delayed Auditory Feedback”, arXiv:1202.6106, 28 February 2012.
- Winners
- Frans de Waal (Netherlands, USA) and Jennifer Pokorny (USA)
- Citation
- For discovering that chimpanzees can identify other chimpanzees individually from seeing photographs of their rear ends.
- Reference
- F.B.M. de Waal and J.J. Pokorny, “Faces and Behinds: Chimpanzee Sex Perception”, Advanced Science Letters, vol. 1, 2008, pp. 99-103.
Chimpanzees were shown photos of faces and photos of behinds. They matched the two correctly: they recognised a familiar companion both by the face and by the other end. For a primate living in a group, where plenty of social signals come from precisely there, it makes perfect sense.
In IT this is called two-factor authentication: something you are at the front and something you are at the back. I don't even recognise colleagues' faces when they change their profile picture. Chimpanzees beat us at this too. The day they require it to log in to email, I resign.
- Winners
- Johan Pettersson (Sweden, Rwanda)
- Citation
- For solving the puzzle of why, in certain houses in the town of Anderslöv, Sweden, people's hair turned green.
A Swedish town, new houses, and residents who come out of the shower with blond hair turning green. Not a new fashionable cut: Pettersson's investigation pointed to copper getting into the hot water through the plumbing, which then bonded to the hair.
It's the classic ticket: “since I moved house my hair's gone green, could it be the Wi-Fi?”. No, madam, it's the plumbing. I love it because it's pure debugging: a bizarre symptom, one hypothesis at a time, and in the end the culprit is a pipe. Like with servers, where in the end the culprit is always a cable. Or DNS.
- Winners
- Rouslan Krechetnikov (USA, Russia, Canada) and Hans Mayer (USA)
- Citation
- For studying the dynamics of liquid-sloshing, to learn what happens when a person walks while carrying a cup of coffee.
- Reference
- H.C. Mayer and R. Krechetnikov, “Walking with coffee: Why does it spill?”, Physical Review E, vol. 85, 2012, 046117.
We've all spilled coffee on the way back to our desk. These two physicists asked why, and discovered that the human stride has a frequency that matches the natural oscillations of the liquid in the cup all too well. The coffee resonates, like a bridge under a marching battalion, and slops over the rim.
So the stain on the keyboard isn't my fault. It's physics. I'll put that in my next fault report. The study also suggests remedies: walk more slowly, watch the cup, use different cups. I've adopted a more radical one: I drink my coffee in front of the machine. Standing. Like a silicon monk.
- Winners
- US Government General Accountability Office (USA)
- Citation
- For issuing a report about reports about reports that recommends the preparation of a report about the report about reports about reports.
- Reference
- US GAO, “Actions Needed to Evaluate the Impact of Efforts to Estimate Costs of Reports and Studies”, report GAO-12-480R, 10 May 2012.
The US government's audit office examined how much the reports requested from the Department of Defense cost. To do so it wrote a report, about the reports on the cost of reports, which concludes by recommending a further report. Recursion on official letterhead.
Every programmer recognises the problem: a function that calls itself with no exit condition. Sooner or later you run out of stack, or out of paper. The committee awarded it the Literature prize, and rightly so: it's a work best read in a loop. I printed a copy. The printer is still asking whether I'd like a print report.
- Winners
- Emmanuel Ben-Soussan and Michel Antonietti (France)
- Citation
- For advising doctors who perform colonoscopies how to minimise the chance that their patients will explode.
- Reference
- S.D. Ladas, G. Karamanolis and E. Ben-Soussan, “Colonic gas explosion during therapeutic colonoscopy with electrocautery”, World Journal of Gastroenterology, vol. 13, no. 40, 2007, pp. 5295-5298; E. Ben-Soussan, M. Antonietti et al., European Journal of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, vol. 16, no. 12, 2004, pp. 1315-1318.
The gut produces flammable gases. During some colonoscopies, instruments that heat up or spark are used for cauterisation. Put the two together and you understand why the medical literature contains rare but documented cases of explosion. The two French gastroenterologists explain how to avoid them: above all, with perfect bowel preparation before the procedure.
It's the golden rule of every server room: no flames near anything that can catch fire. The preparation paragraph, which patients hate, now takes on an epic meaning. It isn't a nuisance, it's an explosion-proofing procedure. Like earthing in an electrical installation: nobody notices it, until it isn't there.
- Winners
- Craig Bennett, Abigail Baird, Michael Miller and George Wolford (USA)
- Citation
- For demonstrating that brain researchers, by using complicated instruments and simple statistics, can see meaningful brain activity anywhere, even in a dead salmon.
- Reference
- C.M. Bennett, A.A. Baird, M.B. Miller and G.L. Wolford, “Neural correlates of interspecies perspective taking in the post-mortem Atlantic Salmon: an argument for multiple comparisons correction”, poster, Organization for Human Brain Mapping, 2009; Journal of Serendipitous and Unexpected Results, vol. 1, no. 1, 2010.
A dead salmon, bought at the market, is slid into an MRI scanner and shown photos of people in social situations. Analyse the data with the wrong statistics and “activity” pops up somewhere in its brain. The salmon, apparently, had opinions. The real message: if you make thousands of comparisons without correcting your calculations, you'll always find something significant purely by chance.
It's why I distrust overly colourful dashboards. With enough charts, even a switched-off server shows an upward trend. This study did more good for science than many serious papers. And the salmon, at last, was heard.
- Winners
- SKN Company (Russia)
- Citation
- For converting old Russian ammunition into new diamonds.
A Russian company took decommissioned military explosives and, by detonating them under controlled conditions, obtained tiny industrial diamonds, the kind used for abrasives and machining. From the arms depot to the workshop bench: a format conversion worthy of a Peace prize.
We IT folk do the same with old computers: we strip them and recover the gold from the contacts, that is three grams of hope per tonne of plastic. Here, though, recycling actually works, and turns a problem into a product. A representative came to collect the prize. There's no record of him handing out rings to the audience.
- Winners
- Joseph Keller (USA); and Raymond Goldstein (USA, UK), Patrick Warren and Robin Ball (UK)
- Citation
- For calculating the balance of forces that shape and move the hair in a human ponytail.
- Reference
- R.E. Goldstein, P.B. Warren and R.C. Ball, “Shape of a Ponytail and the Statistical Physics of Hair Fiber Bundles”, Physical Review Letters, vol. 108, no. 7, 2012; J.B. Keller, “Ponytail Motion”, SIAM Journal on Applied Mathematics, vol. 70, no. 7, 2010, pp. 2667-2672.
A ponytail looks simple. In reality it's a bundle of thousands of elastic fibres, bent by gravity and puffed out because every hair is slightly curly and pushes against the others. The British team wrote an equation for its shape; Keller studied why, when you run, the ponytail swings sideways and not just up and down.
It's the same problem as the tangle of cables behind the desk, only more elegant. I have my own cable equation: any cable left alone overnight knots itself to all the others. Keller, incidentally, won twice that evening: also for the non-drip teapot of 1999.
- Winners
- Anita Eerland, Rolf Zwaan (Netherlands) and Tulio Guadalupe (Peru, Russia, Netherlands)
- Citation
- For their study “Leaning to the Left Makes the Eiffel Tower Seem Smaller”.
- Reference
- A. Eerland, T.M. Guadalupe and R.A. Zwaan, “Leaning to the Left Makes the Eiffel Tower Seem Smaller: Posture-Modulated Estimation”, Psychological Science, vol. 22, no. 12, 2011, pp. 1511-1514.
Volunteers stood on a platform that, without their noticing, tilted them slightly to the right or left. Meanwhile they had to estimate quantities, such as the height of the Eiffel Tower. Those leaning left gave lower numbers. The idea is that we picture numbers on a mental line, small on the left and large on the right, and the body sticks its oar in.
Practical advice: when you present a quote, sit to the client's right. When you receive one, lean left. Does it work? No idea. But the office swivel chair is now a negotiating tool. And two of the authors got married two days after the ceremony. No leaning, just affection.
The principle is well known: if you hear your own voice in headphones a fraction of a second late, your brain gets confused and your speech jams. The two Japanese researchers turned it into a sort of gun: a directional microphone picks up the speaker's voice and a loudspeaker fires it back at them with a delay. Result: the speaker stammers and stops.
It's network latency applied to conversation. Anyone who has had a video call with a colleague up a mountain knows what I mean. My dream is to install one in the meeting room, pointed at the visionary manager on his fourth “let's create synergy”. For now it remains a prototype. Like all beautiful things.