Ig Nobel Prizes 1996
Sixth edition of the Ig Nobels, handed out as tradition demands at Harvard's Sanders Theatre under a regulation shower of paper aeroplanes. 1996 is the year physics proves that toast has it in for us, chemistry lights the barbecue with liquid oxygen and art bows down before a plastic flamingo.
That year I was installing Windows 95 from thirteen floppies. The thirteenth was always unreadable. That too, in its own way, was a scientific experiment.
- Winners
- Don Featherstone (Fitchburg, Massachusetts, USA)
- Citation
- For inventing an ornamental object of inestimable evolutionary value: the pink plastic garden flamingo.
- Reference
- Book: “Pink Flamingos: Splendor on the Grass”
- Winners
- Chonosuke Okamura (Okamura Fossil Laboratory, Nagoya, Japan)
- Citation
- For announcing the discovery of fossils of dinosaurs, dragons, princesses and more than a thousand other extinct “mini-species”, each less than one hundredth of an inch long.
- Reference
- “Reports of the Okamura Fossil Laboratory”, Nagoya, 1970s-1980s
Okamura looked at rock sections under the microscope and saw an entire miniature universe: dinosaurs, dragons and even humans a few millimetres tall, all diligently catalogued and published. An immense body of work, carried out with touching dedication.
It is the same thing that happens to me when I stare too long at a CRT monitor full of dead pixels: after an hour I swear I can see my old line manager's face. The difference is that Okamura had the consistency to start a journal about it. I just rebooted.
- Winners
- Anders Bærheim and Hogne Sandvik (University of Bergen, Norway)
- Citation
- For their tasty and tasteful study of the effects of ale, garlic and soured cream on the appetite of leeches.
- Reference
- “Effect of Ale, Garlic, and Soured Cream on the Appetite of Leeches”, British Medical Journal, vol. 309, December 1994, p. 1689
The two Norwegian doctors asked themselves, in all seriousness, whether garlic really protects against bloodsuckers. They took some leeches and offered them hands smeared with various substances. Result: garlic did not frighten them at all, in fact it attracted them, while beer seemed to ruin their evening.
It is the scientific method in its purest form: take a village legend and put it through a regression test. Like when a customer swears to me that blowing into the cartridge connector fixes everything. I tested it. It fixes nothing, but the customer feels calmer.
- Winners
- George Goble (Purdue University, USA)
- Citation
- For setting the world record for igniting a barbecue: about three seconds, using charcoal and liquid oxygen.
Goble, a computer scientist and engineer, was fed up with waiting for the coals to be ready. So he poured liquid oxygen over the charcoal and in a few seconds got a red-hot, smoking grill, considerably more spectacular than planned. The barbecue, it seems, came out of it with some mild trauma.
It is exactly the spirit in which a sysadmin tackles slowness: I don't optimise the code, I buy a thirty-two-core server. Problem solved; the electricity bill is another ticket. The sausages, mind you, don't cook at that temperature. They teleport.
- Winners
- Robert J. Genco (University at Buffalo, USA)
- Citation
- For discovering that financial strain is a risk indicator for destructive periodontal disease.
- Reference
- Genco et al., Annals of Periodontology, vol. 3, no. 1, 1998, pp. 288-302; Journal of Periodontology, vol. 70, 1999, pp. 711-23
Genco observed that the stress of an empty wallet shows up in the gums too: people worried about money tend to have more periodontal problems. In practice the bank account and the mouth are connected by a cable nobody had ever seen on the diagram.
There is something cruel and perfect about it: you have little money, so your teeth suffer, so you have to see the dentist, so you have even less money. The first infinite loop ever diagnosed in dentistry. All that's missing is the error message: stack overflow, please smile.
- Winners
- The editors of the journal Social Text (USA)
- Citation
- For eagerly publishing research that they could not understand, that the author said was meaningless, and which claimed that reality does not exist.
- Reference
- Alan Sokal, “Transgressing the Boundaries: Toward a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity”, Social Text, Spring-Summer 1996, pp. 217-252
Physicist Alan Sokal deliberately wrote an article full of big words and no meaning, sent it to the journal, and the journal published it. Then Sokal revealed the hoax, sparking one of the most heated academic debates of the decade about rigour and jargon.
Anyone who works in IT knows the phenomenon well: it is the consultant's slide that says “value-oriented cloud-native synergistic paradigm”. Everyone nods. Nobody understands. Somebody signs the contract. The editors, at least, deserve credit for making us laugh and then think quite a lot.
- Winners
- James Johnston (R.J. Reynolds), Joseph Taddeo (U.S. Tobacco), Andrew Tisch (Lorillard), William Campbell (Philip Morris), Edward A. Horrigan (Liggett Group), Donald S. Johnston (American Tobacco) and Thomas E. Sandefur Jr. (Brown and Williamson) (USA)
- Citation
- For declaring unequivocally, before the United States Congress, that nicotine is not addictive.
- Reference
- Hearing before the United States Congress, 1994
In 1994 the heads of seven major US tobacco companies, one after another, told Congress they did not believe nicotine was addictive. The scene, with all of them lined up giving the same answer, has gone down in history.
The Ig Nobel committee rewarded the firmness of the statement. I find it a lesson in technical communication: like when someone in a meeting declares that our management software “has no bugs, only unexpected features”. Clear message, confident tone, and an audience taking notes with a very particular expression.
- Winners
- Jacques Chirac (President of the Republic, France)
- Citation
- For commemorating the fiftieth anniversary of Hiroshima with atomic bomb tests in the Pacific.
In 1995 France resumed a series of nuclear tests in the Pacific, in the very year of the fiftieth anniversary of Hiroshima. The committee seized on the calendar coincidence and turned it into a peace prize, with the irony that is the ceremony's trademark.
It is the kind of synchronicity I have only ever seen in my career with mandatory updates: the system decides to restart exactly during the presentation to the client. Nobody programmed it that way. And yet the timing is perfect, and everyone in the room remembers it for years.
- Winners
- Robert Matthews (Aston University, United Kingdom)
- Citation
- For his studies of Murphy's Law, and especially for demonstrating that toast often falls on the buttered side.
- Reference
- “Tumbling Toast, Murphy's Law and the Fundamental Constants”, European Journal of Physics, vol. 16, no. 4, 1995, pp. 172-176
Matthews calculated that a slice of bread sliding off the table has just enough time to make half a turn before hitting the floor. Table height, human size and gravity conspire: the butter ends up on the floor not through bad luck, but because of the fundamental constants of the universe.
At last a scientific explanation for what we technicians have always known: the USB cable always goes in on the third attempt, and it is not our fault. It is physics. Matthews suggests using taller tables. I suggest having breakfast on top of the server rack: at least it is air-conditioned.
- Winners
- Ellen Kleist (Nuuk, Greenland) and Harald Moi (Oslo, Norway)
- Citation
- For their cautionary medical report on a case of gonorrhoea transmitted via an inflatable doll.
- Reference
- Genitourinary Medicine, vol. 69, no. 4, August 1993, p. 322
The two doctors documented, with all the sobriety of clinical literature, a case of infection passed from one person to another via a shared inflatable doll. The paper had a very serious purpose: to remind us that objects can act as carriers too.
In IT we call it “a colleague's USB stick”. It goes round the office, passes from hand to hand, nobody knows where it came from, and one day it brings a virus with it. The moral is identical in both disciplines: shared peripherals must be sanitised. And preferably not shared.
In 1957 Featherstone designed the pink plastic flamingo, the one that has stood on one leg for decades in the gardens of half of America, unmoved by hail, lawnmowers and art critics. It is the first documented case of an art installation distributed across millions of nodes, with no central server and one hundred per cent uptime.
My cousin has one in front of his garage. He says it keeps burglars away. In twenty years not a single burglar has got in. Not a single guest has either, but statistics are statistics.