Ig Nobel Prizes 2017
On 14 September 2017 Harvard's Sanders Theatre hosts the 27th First Annual Ig Nobel Prize Ceremony, devoted to the theme of uncertainty. Also on stage, a mini-opera about incompetence, set in a crowded bar. The audience, as tradition demands, threw paper aeroplanes. Nobody was sure where they would land. Thematic consistency.
- Winners
- Marc-Antoine Fardin (France, Singapore, USA)
- Citation
- For using fluid dynamics to probe the question “Can a Cat Be Both a Solid and a Liquid?”.
- Reference
- “On the Rheology of Cats”, Rheology Bulletin, 2014
- Winners
- Milo Puhan, Alex Suarez, Christian Lo Cascio, Alfred Zahn, Markus Heitz and Otto Braendli (Switzerland, Canada, Netherlands, USA)
- Citation
- For demonstrating that regular playing of a didgeridoo is an effective treatment for obstructive sleep apnoea and snoring.
- Reference
- “Didgeridoo Playing as Alternative Treatment for Obstructive Sleep Apnoea Syndrome: Randomised Controlled Trial”, BMJ, 2006
A serious clinical study, control group and all: playing the didgeridoo, the long Aboriginal wind instrument, trains the muscles of the airways. Those who play it snore less, and their partners sleep better. That's why it's a Peace prize.
The nerd paradox is delightful: to get rid of a night-time noise you introduce a daytime noise, louder and with more bass. It's like fixing a noisy PC fan by putting a subwoofer next to it. The problem disappears. So do the neighbours.
- Winners
- Matthew Rockloff and Nancy Greer (Australia, USA)
- Citation
- For experiments to see how contact with a live crocodile affects a person's willingness to gamble.
- Reference
- “Never Smile at a Crocodile: Betting on Electronic Gaming Machines is Intensified by Reptile-Induced Arousal”, Journal of Gambling Studies, 2010
The volunteers held a small crocodile, then played the fruit machines. Those who were wound up by the reptile, and in a good mood, bet more. Excitement, in short, makes you stake more. All true, all published.
This is strategic information. From tomorrow I'll bring a crocodile to budget meetings. Just a little crocodile, to lift morale. The director will approve the new server without batting an eyelid. If he doesn't, at least I'll have a credible excuse to leave early.
- Winners
- James Heathcote (United Kingdom)
- Citation
- For his medical research study “Why Do Old Men Have Big Ears?”.
- Reference
- “Why Do Old Men Have Big Ears?”, British Medical Journal, 1995
Dr Heathcote, a GP, measured his patients' ears and found they grow by about two millimetres every ten years. The question in the title remains somewhat open, but the data is there, ruler in hand.
I have a sysadmin's hypothesis: it's a hardware upgrade. With age the user listens less, so the system enlarges the antennae. Unfortunately the problem was the software. My uncle has ears like two satellite dishes and keeps saying “eh?”. Perfect signal. Old decoder.
- Winners
- Kazunori Yoshizawa, Rodrigo Ferreira, Yoshitaka Kamimura and Charles Lienhard (Japan, Brazil, Switzerland)
- Citation
- For their discovery of a female penis, and a male vagina, in a cave insect.
- Reference
- “Female Penis, Male Vagina and Their Correlated Evolution in a Cave Insect”, Current Biology, 2014
In some caves in Brazil lives a tiny insect of the genus Neotrogla in which the anatomical roles are reversed: it's the female that has an organ that is inserted into the male. A genuine and fascinating biological discovery, which forces a few textbook pages to be rewritten.
It's nature's equivalent of discovering that in the server room the male cable comes out of the wall and the female socket is on the computer. Everyone said it couldn't be done. Then you look more closely, in the dark, at the back of a cave. And it works.
- Winners
- Jiwon Han (South Korea, USA)
- Citation
- For studying the dynamics of liquid-sloshing, to learn what happens when a person walks backwards while carrying a cup of coffee.
- Reference
- “A Study on the Coffee Spilling Phenomena in the Low Impulse Regime”, Achievements in the Life Sciences, 2016
Jiwon Han wrote this study as a secondary school student. He found that holding the cup from above, with fingers like a claw, reduces the sloshing, and that walking backwards helps you not spill your coffee. Science applied to the office's most precious resource.
From tomorrow, the whole company goes to the coffee machine in reverse gear. Someone will crash into the printer, obviously. But the printer is broken anyway. And the keyboard, at last, will be safe.
- Winners
- Fernanda Ito, Enrico Bernard and Rodrigo Torres (Brazil, Canada, Spain)
- Citation
- For the first scientific report of human blood in the diet of the hairy-legged vampire bat.
- Reference
- “What is for Dinner? First Report of Human Blood in the Diet of the Hairy-Legged Vampire Bat”, Acta Chiropterologica, 2016
The hairy-legged vampire bat usually feeds on bird blood. Analysing its droppings in north-eastern Brazil, the researchers also found human DNA. Perhaps because wild birds are getting scarce and people aren't.
It's the old story of forced migration: when the old server is switched off, the program goes looking for resources wherever it can. This bat has ported itself to a new platform. Without documentation. And with some nasty compatibility issues with the user.
- Winners
- Jean-Pierre Royet, David Meunier, Nicolas Torquet, Anne-Marie Mouly and Tao Jiang (France, United Kingdom)
- Citation
- For using advanced brain-scan technology to measure the extent to which some people are disgusted by cheese.
- Reference
- “The Neural Bases of Disgust for Cheese: An fMRI Study”, Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 2016
In France, the homeland of cheese, a team of neuroscientists put people who detest cheese into an MRI scanner. Faced with the smell, the reward areas of their brains lit up differently. Disgust has a map.
I approve with provincial pride. My uncle ages cheeses in his cellar, next to the server: he says the logs help the rind. If anyone wants to do a follow-up study, we have material. Plenty of material. Arriving with a mask is recommended.
- Winners
- Matteo Martini, Ilaria Bufalari, Maria Antonietta Stazi and Salvatore Maria Aglioti (Italy, Spain, United Kingdom)
- Citation
- For demonstrating that many identical twins cannot tell themselves apart visually.
- Reference
- “Is That Me or My Twin? Lack of Self-Face Recognition Advantage in Identical Twins”, PLoS ONE, 2015
Normally we recognise our own face faster than other people's. In identical twins this advantage disappears: faced with a photo, the brain hesitates. Is that me or him? A fine piece of Italian research on identity.
All my files called “final”, “final2” and “final_really” have the same problem. They're twins. Nobody, not even me, knows any more which one is the original. Every now and then I open the wrong one and work on it for a whole afternoon. Then I save it as “final_really2”. The family grows.
- Winners
- Marisa López-Teijón, Álex García-Faura, Alberto Prats-Galino and Luis Pallarés Aniorte (Spain)
- Citation
- For showing that a developing human foetus responds more strongly to music that is played electromechanically inside the mother's vagina than to music that is played electromechanically on the mother's belly.
- Reference
- “Fetal Facial Expression in Response to Intravaginal Music Emission”, Ultrasound, 2015; patent ES2546919B1, “Fetal Acoustic Stimulation Device”, 2015
Using ultrasound, the researchers watched the movements of foetuses' faces and mouths while they listened to music. With a small internal speaker the reactions were far more evident than with headphones resting on the belly. A patented device came out of it too.
It's the eternal audio problem: the speaker at the back of the hall never sounds right. Better to get closer to the source. Any sound engineer will confirm it. The foetus, meanwhile, already has its first hi-fi system. At its age I only had a demagnetised cassette tape.
A liquid takes the shape of its container. A cat gets into a vase, a box, a sink, and takes its shape. Marc-Antoine Fardin took the matter seriously and tackled it with rheology, the science of how matter flows. The conclusion: it depends on the observation time.
It's the same quantum state as my Downloads folder: solid when I'm looking for a file, liquid when I'm looking for free space. The cat, meanwhile, is lying on the keyboard. In cat form. It has sent three emails on my behalf.