Skip to content
CONTACT

Ig Nobel Prizes 1997

Seventh edition, again at Harvard's Sanders Theatre, with real Nobel laureates handing out the awards and the audience armed with paper aeroplanes. In 1997 the prizes go to the Tamagotchi, lift music and, prophetically, the king of junk mail.

That year my 33.6 modem made a noise like a fax machine having an existential crisis. Downloading a photo took a cup of coffee. Downloading two took a holiday.

ASTRONOMY1997 · #1
Winners
Richard C. Hoagland (New Jersey, USA)
Citation
For identifying artificial structures on the Moon and on Mars, including a human face on Mars and ten-mile-high buildings on the far side of the Moon.
Reference
Richard C. Hoagland, “The Monuments of Mars: A City on the Edge of Forever”, North Atlantic Books, 1996

Hoagland studied photographs from space probes and saw a face, pyramids and gigantic constructions in them. He turned this into books and lectures, with a narrative energy many novelists would envy.

The human brain loves finding faces everywhere: in clouds, in plug sockets, in damp patches on the ceiling. I once saw the logo of a well-known operating system at the bottom of a coffee cup. I didn't write a book about it. I just switched to tea. Everyone reacts to cosmic revelations in their own way.

BIOLOGY1997 · #2
Winners
T. Yagyu and colleagues (Zurich, Switzerland; Osaka, Japan; Prague, Czech Republic)
Citation
For measuring the brainwave patterns of people chewing gum of different flavours.
Reference
“Chewing-Gum Flavor Affects Measures of Global Complexity of Multichannel EEG”, Neuropsychobiology, vol. 35, 1997, pp. 46-50

An international group of neurophysiologists attached electrodes to volunteers' heads and had them chew gum of various flavours, to see whether the taste changed the brain's electrical activity. And some differences, apparently, do show up.

It is the most relaxing benchmark in history: instead of stressing the CPU with impossible calculations, you give it a mint gum and watch the charts. If it worked with computers too, the office would have a chewing-gum dispenser instead of a UPS. Strawberry for the mail servers, obviously.

COMMUNICATIONS1997 · #3
Winners
Sanford Wallace (Cyber Promotions, Philadelphia, USA)
Citation
For tirelessly delivering enormous quantities of unsolicited email to the world.

In the Nineties Wallace ran a company that sent email advertising in industrial quantities, so much so that he became one of the best-known, and least loved, names on the network of the day. The prize celebrates an era in which the inbox discovered it had an enemy.

For a sysadmin it is a historic moment, like the discovery of the common cold for a doctor. From it came filters, blacklists, rules and entire careers, including part of mine. Every time I configure an anti-spam filter, in a sense, I am still replying to that first digital envelope.

ECONOMICS1997 · #4
Winners
Akihiro Yokoi (Wiz Company, Chiba, Japan) and Aki Maita (Bandai, Tokyo, Japan)
Citation
For diverting millions of man-hours of work into the husbandry of virtual pets.

They are the parents of the Tamagotchi, the electronic egg with a little creature inside to feed, clean and comfort, on pain of its digital death. In 1997 half the world interrupted meetings and lessons to feed a hungry pixel.

It was the first true mass training course for sysadmins: a device that calls you at any hour, complains if you ignore it and dies if you go on holiday. That's how I started. Today my Tamagotchis are called mail servers, but the sound of the alarm at three in the morning is identical.

ENTOMOLOGY1997 · #5
Winners
Mark Hostetler (University of Florida, USA)
Citation
For his scholarly book that teaches how to identify insects from the splatter they leave on car windscreens.
Reference
Mark Hostetler, “That Gunk on Your Car”, Ten Speed Press

Hostetler wrote a genuine field guide to identifying insects squashed on the glass: shape, colour and consistency of the splat reveal who the unlucky passenger was. Applied entomology, at sixty miles an hour.

It is the same job I do with error logs: I look at what's left after the impact and reconstruct who caused the disaster. The expert technician, like the entomologist, doesn't see a stain. He sees a story. And in the end, in both cases, you wipe it with a sponge and pretend nothing happened.

LITERATURE1997 · #6
Winners
Doron Witztum, Eliyahu Rips and Yoav Rosenberg (Israel) and Michael Drosnin (USA)
Citation
For their statistical discovery of an alleged hidden code in the text of the Bible.
Reference
Witztum, Rips and Rosenberg, “Equidistant Letter Sequences in the Book of Genesis”, Statistical Science, vol. 9, no. 3, 1994, pp. 429-438; Michael Drosnin, “The Bible Code”, Simon & Schuster

The method consists of taking a very long text and reading its letters at regular intervals, looking for words and names that appear as if by magic. Drosnin's book made the idea a worldwide phenomenon; other mathematicians then showed that, with enough text and enough attempts, you can find messages almost anywhere.

I know from experience: if you read a six-gigabyte log file skipping one line in seventeen, sooner or later you'll find “buy bread”. Statistics is a great friend. But like all friends, if you push it too hard, it tells you what you want to hear.

MEDICINE1997 · #7
Winners
Carl J. Charnetski and Francis X. Brennan Jr. (Wilkes University, USA) and James F. Harrison (Muzak Ltd., Seattle, USA)
Citation
For discovering that listening to lift music stimulates the production of immunoglobulin A and may therefore help prevent the common cold.
Reference
Perceptual and Motor Skills, vol. 87, 1998, pp. 1163-1170

The authors measured an antibody in the saliva of volunteers exposed to various sounds and observed that Muzak-style background music seemed to increase it. Lift music as a vaccine: an idea nobody had dared to think.

This finally explains why waiting on the line for tech support lasts forty minutes: it isn't disorganisation, it's preventive therapy. The customer leaves the call with the problem unsolved, but with the immune system of an Olympic athlete. I call it holistic support.

METEOROLOGY1997 · #8
Winners
Bernard Vonnegut (State University of New York at Albany, USA)
Citation
For his revealing report entitled “Chicken Plucking as Measure of Tornado Wind Speed”.
Reference
“Chicken Plucking as Measure of Tornado Wind Speed”, Weatherwise, October 1975, p. 217

Vonnegut, a distinguished atmospheric physicist, wondered about the stories of chickens found plucked after a tornado had passed, and tried to estimate how much wind force would really be needed to tear out the feathers. A measuring method brilliant for its economy: the instrument is a chicken.

Where I live it works the same way: connection speed is measured by how much Grandad swears while checking the weather online. No calibration, no ISO certificate, but impressive precision. Vonnegut, at least, published his data.

PEACE1997 · #9
Winners
Harold Hillman (University of Surrey, United Kingdom)
Citation
For his peacefully thorough report on the possible pain experienced during execution by different methods.
Reference
“The Possible Pain Experienced During Execution by Different Methods”, Perception, vol. 22, 1993, pp. 745-753

Hillman, a physiologist, analysed with scientific method how much pain the various methods of execution might cause, starting from the widespread idea that some were “humane” and painless. A deadly serious topic, approached with the coolness of data.

The prize is a perfect example of how the Ig Nobels first make you smile at the title and then make you think about the content. Like when a security audit discovers that the procedure “secure by definition” was secure in name only. It's funny for three seconds, then everyone sits down and changes their passwords.

PHYSICS1997 · #10
Winners
John Bockris (Texas A&M University, USA)
Citation
For his wide-ranging achievements in cold fusion, in the transmutation of base elements into gold, and in the electrochemical incineration of domestic rubbish.

Bockris, an electrochemist with a long career, devoted himself to three of the most ambitious feats of fringe science: energy from room-temperature fusion, gold from common metals and rubbish that disappears thanks to electricity. A research programme worthy of an alchemist in a lab coat.

I have had a similar goal for years: turning a 2003 PC into a modern workstation by adding nothing but RAM. I believe in it deeply. The results are still awaiting independent replication, but the fan, I must say, makes a very determined noise.