Ig Nobel Prizes 2018
The 28th First Annual Ig Nobel Prize Ceremony is held on 13 September 2018 at Harvard's Sanders Theatre, on the theme of the heart. It also sees the debut of a mini-opera in which children try to mend a broken heart by building one, breaking it and repairing it. A method I know well: it's how I learned to repair PCs.
- Winners
- Marc Mitchell and David Wartinger (USA)
- Citation
- For using roller coaster rides to try to hasten the passage of kidney stones.
- Reference
- “Validation of a Functional Pyelocalyceal Renal Model for the Evaluation of Renal Calculi Passage While Riding a Roller Coaster”, Journal of the American Osteopathic Association, 2016
- Winners
- Tomas Persson, Gabriela-Alina Sauciuc and Elainie Madsen (Sweden, Romania, Denmark, Netherlands and others)
- Citation
- For collecting evidence, in a zoo, that chimpanzees imitate humans about as often, and about as well, as humans imitate chimpanzees.
- Reference
- “Spontaneous Cross-Species Imitation in Interaction Between Chimpanzees and Zoo Visitors”, Primates, 2018
The researchers watched zoo visitors in front of the chimpanzee enclosure. The visitors made monkey noises and gestures. The chimpanzees, in turn, copied the visitors' gestures. Final score: roughly a draw.
It happens in the office too. The user imitates the technician and presses mysterious keys at random. The technician imitates the user and says “it worked yesterday”. After a few years nobody knows any more who is observing whom. I've started to suspect my boss is taking notes as well.
- Winners
- Paul Becher, Peter Witzgall, Marie Bengtsson and colleagues (Sweden, Colombia, Germany, France, Switzerland)
- Citation
- For demonstrating that wine experts can reliably identify, by smell, the presence of a single fly in a glass of wine.
- Reference
- “The Scent of the Fly”, bioRxiv, 2017
The female fruit fly gives off a pheromone. Just one, fallen into a glass of wine, is enough for an expert nose to notice and find the wine unpleasant. The males, on the other hand, go unnoticed. Serious research, with a practical spin-off for anyone who has drinks outdoors.
It's the oenological equivalent of an extra space in PHP code: just one, invisible, ruins everything. And there's always a colleague with a fine nose who finds it, sniffs it and then looks at you in silence.
- Winners
- Paula Romão, Adília Alarcão and the late César Viana (Portugal)
- Citation
- For measuring the degree to which human saliva is a good cleaning agent for dirty surfaces.
- Reference
- “Human Saliva as a Cleaning Agent for Dirty Surfaces”, Studies in Conservation, 1990
Restorers have always known it: for cleaning certain delicate surfaces of works of art, saliva works wonderfully thanks to its enzymes. These researchers measured it rigorously, comparing it with other solvents. The winners collected the prize by video message.
At last, scientific confirmation of the method grannies use to clean their grandchildren's faces. For the monitor, I'll stick with the microfibre cloth. Not for hygiene: it's just that pixels are touchy.
- Winners
- Akira Horiuchi (Japan)
- Citation
- For the medical report “Colonoscopy in the Sitting Position: Lessons Learned From Self-Colonoscopy”.
- Reference
- “Colonoscopy in the Sitting Position: Lessons Learned From Self-Colonoscopy by Using a Small-Caliber, Variable-Stiffness Colonoscope”, Gastrointestinal Endoscopy, 2006
Dr Horiuchi wanted to find out whether a colonoscopy done sitting down might be simpler. So he sat down and did it on himself, with a slim instrument. He reported that the discomfort was modest. Total dedication to the cause.
It's the purest form of technical support: the technician who tries the procedure on himself before imposing it on users. When I update the office PCs I do the same: I start with mine. But I admit that, as experiments go, my risk is a lot more comfortable.
- Winners
- Thea Blackler, Rafael Gomez, Vesna Popovic and M. Helen Thompson (Australia, El Salvador, United Kingdom)
- Citation
- For documenting that most people who use complicated products do not read the instruction manual.
- Reference
- “Life Is Too Short to RTFM: How Users Relate to Documentation and Excess Features in Consumer Products”, Interacting With Computers, 2014
The study's title uses an acronym every IT person knows, a not-very-polite invitation to read the manual. The researchers confirmed that almost nobody does: you try, you get it wrong, you ask the person next to you. And many features remain unused forever.
As an author of manuals, I feel personally addressed. I have written beautiful guides. I keep them like relics. Every now and then I open one to check it's still there. It is. Untouched. Like the first time. The only one who reads it is the printer, when I print it.
- Winners
- James Cole (Zimbabwe, Tanzania, United Kingdom)
- Citation
- For calculating that the caloric intake from a human-cannibalism diet is significantly lower than the caloric intake from most other traditional meat diets.
- Reference
- “Assessing the Calorific Significance of Episodes of Human Cannibalism in the Paleolithic”, Scientific Reports, 2017
Archaeologist James Cole wanted to understand why some of our ancestors practised cannibalism. He calculated the calories in a human body and compared them with those of a mammoth or a deer. Result: as a meal, humans are poor value. So the reasons must have been other ones too, social or ritual.
It's a perfect cost-benefit analysis. The client is skinny, hard work to catch and complains. It reminds me of certain quotes for a Joomla site. Not worth it. You do it for sentimental reasons.
- Winners
- Francisco Alonso, Cristina Esteban, Constanza Calatayud and colleagues (Spain, Colombia)
- Citation
- For measuring the frequency, motivation, and effects of shouting and cursing while driving an automobile.
- Reference
- “Shouting and Cursing While Driving: Frequency, Reasons, Perceived Risk and Punishment”, Journal of Sociology and Anthropology, 2017
With questionnaires given to hundreds of drivers, the Spanish researchers quantified a universal phenomenon: people shout in the car, often, and we all know it's pointless. The study examines its causes, perceived risks and possible penalties.
The Peace prize is well deserved. I only swear at the satnav, which can't hear me. It answers “recalculating route” with the calm of a monk. It's the only device that has ever won an argument with me. And it doesn't even have Wi-Fi.
- Winners
- John Barry, Bruce Blank and Michel Boileau (USA)
- Citation
- For using postage stamps to test whether the male sexual organ is functioning properly.
- Reference
- “Nocturnal Penile Tumescence Monitoring With Stamps”, Urology, 1980
During sleep, healthy men have spontaneous erections. To check for them without expensive equipment, doctors used a ring of postage stamps: if in the morning the strip had torn along the perforation, everything was working. Low-cost diagnosis, postage paid.
It's textbook systems engineering: a cheap, disposable sensor with a built-in data logger. From an IT point of view it's perfect: a log that writes itself overnight. The only problem is persuading the user to accept the installation.
- Winners
- Lindie Hanyu Liang, Douglas Brown, Huiwen Lian, Samuel Hanig, D. Lance Ferris and Lisa Keeping (Canada, China, Singapore, USA)
- Citation
- For investigating whether it is effective for employees to use Voodoo dolls to retaliate against abusive bosses.
- Reference
- “Righting a Wrong: Retaliation on a Voodoo Doll Symbolizing an Abusive Supervisor Restores Justice”, The Leadership Quarterly, 2018
In the study, participants recalling an unfair boss could stick pins into a virtual voodoo doll representing him. Afterwards they felt better, with the sense that a little justice had been restored. No bosses were harmed.
In IT we've had the same therapy for years: it's called a stress ball, or the Enter key pressed with violence. The keyboard plays the doll. In my company there are keyboards whose Enter key is now as shiny as a votive offering. They have restored a great many souls.
A patient had passed a kidney stone after a roller coaster ride. Dr Wartinger, instead of smiling, 3D-printed a model kidney, put real stones inside it and carried it in a rucksack for dozens of rides at a theme park. Back seats: better results.
This is science with a crash helmet. It's also my philosophy for stuck hard drives: one well-aimed tap and sometimes they start again. Don't tell anyone. Especially not the drives.