Skip to content
CONTACT

Ig Nobel Prizes 2000

Tenth edition, held at Harvard's Sanders Theatre with paper aeroplanes and real Nobel laureates on stage. 2000 is the year of two prizes science has never forgotten: the frog levitated with magnets by Andre Geim, who ten years later would win the real Nobel, and the study that gave us the Dunning-Kruger effect.

The millennium bug, meanwhile, had blown nothing up. Many technicians were almost disappointed. We had the sandwiches ready.

BIOLOGY2000 · #1
Winners
Richard Wassersug (Dalhousie University, Canada)
Citation
For his first-hand report on the taste of various kinds of dry-season tadpoles in Costa Rica.
Reference
“On the Comparative Palatability of Some Dry-Season Tadpoles from Costa Rica”, American Midland Naturalist, vol. 86, no. 1, July 1971, pp. 101-109

To understand why some tadpoles are avoided by predators, Wassersug got volunteers to taste, without swallowing, several species and rate their flavour. The result was a scientific ranking of unpleasantness. Ecology applied with the palate.

This is the true spirit of end-user acceptance testing: you don't read the documentation, you put the product in your mouth and see what happens. Many of my customers test software exactly like that. With results, I must say, just as bitter. But at least Wassersug published the data.

CHEMISTRY2000 · #2
Winners
Donatella Marazziti, Alessandra Rossi and Giovanni B. Cassano (University of Pisa, Italy) and Hagop S. Akiskal (University of California, San Diego, USA)
Citation
For their discovery that, biochemically, romantic love may be indistinguishable from having severe obsessive-compulsive disorder.
Reference
Marazziti, Akiskal, Rossi and Cassano, “Alteration of the Platelet Serotonin Transporter in Romantic Love”, Psychological Medicine, vol. 29, no. 3, May 1999, pp. 741-745

The Pisa researchers measured a serotonin-related marker in people who had recently fallen in love and found it similar to that of people with obsessive-compulsive disorder. Laboratory confirmation of what poets had been saying for centuries: a person in love does not think straight.

An Italian prize, and I'm proud of it. After all, anyone who has spent a night checking whether a message has been read knows the symptoms well: compulsive refreshing, waiting for the notification, blue-tick anxiety. I observe the same clinical picture in sysadmins during a long backup. That too, deep down, is love.

COMPUTER SCIENCE2000 · #3
Winners
Chris Niswander (Tucson, Arizona, USA)
Citation
For inventing PawSense, software that detects when a cat is walking across the computer keyboard.
Reference
PawSense software

Niswander wrote a program able to recognise the key combinations typical of a feline paw, block the input and, optionally, play a sound cats dislike. A real problem, elegantly solved by someone who had evidently lost more than one document.

At last a prize for real computing, the trench kind. I have lost more files to cats than to viruses, and no antivirus on the market covered the case. The cat, after all, is the most demanding user: never reads the manual, sits on the laptop's warm spot and demands immediate support.

ECONOMICS2000 · #4
Winners
Reverend Sun Myung Moon (Unification Church)
Citation
For bringing efficiency and steady growth to the mass-marriage industry, going, according to the figures quoted, from 36 couples in 1960 to 430 in 1968, 1,800 in 1975, 6,000 in 1982, 30,000 in 1992, 360,000 in 1995 and 36 million in 1997.

The committee lined up, with the precision of a company balance sheet, the figures for the collective wedding ceremonies celebrated by the reverend over the decades, as they were reported. The prize looks at one thing only: scalability.

As a technician, I must admit I'm impressed by the infrastructure problem. Handling 36 couples is a small server. Handling millions means load balancing, redundancy, queues. And there's me, going to pieces when I have to organise the office dinner for twelve people, with a single gluten intolerance.

LITERATURE2000 · #5
Winners
Jasmuheen, formerly Ellen Greve (Australia)
Citation
For her book “Living on Light”, which explains that although some people do eat food, they don't ever really need to.
Reference
Jasmuheen, “Living on Light”

In her book the author claims that human beings can feed on light instead of food. The committee rewarded the book by summing up its central thesis as precisely as possible and leaving every conclusion to the reader. For the scientific record, the human body remains stubbornly attached to calories, water and nutrients.

As a sysadmin, the idea of living on light strikes me: I live on monitor light, but I've noticed that without pizza at two in the morning the system goes into protection mode. Perhaps mine is an older model. The firmware, I fear, cannot be updated.

MEDICINE2000 · #6
Winners
Willibrord Weijmar Schultz, Pek van Andel and Eduard Mooyaart (Groningen, Netherlands) and Ida Sabelis (Amsterdam, Netherlands)
Citation
For their illuminating report “Magnetic Resonance Imaging of Male and Female Genitals During Coitus and Female Sexual Arousal”.
Reference
“Magnetic Resonance Imaging of Male and Female Genitals During Coitus and Female Sexual Arousal”, British Medical Journal, vol. 319, 1999, pp. 1596-1600

The Dutch team persuaded some volunteer couples to squeeze together into an MRI scanner, obtaining the first detailed anatomical images of intercourse. A genuine study, which corrected anatomical drawings handed down for centuries. Pek van Andel, incidentally, is a well-known scholar of serendipity.

The detail that strikes me, as a technician, is logistical: a narrow, noisy tube, with an operator saying “keep still”. That is the exact description of moving a server into a rack cabinet. Except nobody has ever published my photos in the British Medical Journal.

PEACE2000 · #7
Winners
The British Royal Navy (United Kingdom)
Citation
For ordering its sailors to stop using live ammunition during exercises and to shout “Bang!” instead.

In 2000 it was reported that, to keep costs down, during some exercises sailors would simulate firing by voice, shouting “Bang”. The committee saw in this choice a remarkable contribution to peace and, of course, to savings.

It is virtualisation applied to artillery, and I appreciate it as a professional. We in IT have been doing it for years: no physical server, just a convincing simulation. The principle is identical. If nobody looks too closely, a well-pronounced “Bang” is as good as a production environment.

PHYSICS2000 · #8
Winners
Andre Geim (University of Nijmegen, Netherlands) and Michael Berry (University of Bristol, United Kingdom)
Citation
For using magnets to levitate a frog.
Reference
M.V. Berry and A.K. Geim, “Of Flying Frogs and Levitrons”, European Journal of Physics, vol. 18, 1997, pp. 307-313

Geim exploited diamagnetism, a weak magnetic repulsion present even in water, by placing a live frog inside an extremely powerful magnetic field: the frog floated in mid-air, unharmed and presumably puzzled. Berry supplied the theory. Ten years later, in 2010, Geim won the Nobel Prize in Physics for graphene: he is the first person to hold both prizes.

It is the definitive proof that serious play takes you far. First you make a frog fly, then you revolutionise materials science. I am still stuck at phase one: I made a mouse levitate. The cable had got caught.

PSYCHOLOGY2000 · #9
Winners
David Dunning (Cornell University, USA) and Justin Kruger (University of Illinois, USA)
Citation
For their modest report “Unskilled and Unaware of It: How Difficulties in Recognizing One's Own Incompetence Lead to Inflated Self-Assessments”.
Reference
“Unskilled and Unaware of It: How Difficulties in Recognizing One's Own Incompetence Lead to Inflated Self-Assessments”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, vol. 77, no. 6, December 1999, pp. 1121-1134

The two psychologists showed that people who score worst on a test tend to vastly overestimate their own ability, because the very skills they lack are also needed to notice they lack them. Thus was born the famous Dunning-Kruger effect.

In my line of work it is daily bread. The customer who says “I had a go at it myself, it's sorted now” is patient zero. But the beauty of the study is that it applies to everyone, me included. Every time I think I have perfectly understood a network printer, the printer reminds me.

PUBLIC HEALTH2000 · #10
Winners
Jonathan Wyatt, Gordon McNaughton and William Tullett (Glasgow, Scotland, United Kingdom)
Citation
For their alarming report “The Collapse of Toilets in Glasgow”.
Reference
“The Collapse of Toilets in Glasgow”, Scottish Medical Journal, vol. 38, 1993, p. 185

The three doctors had treated patients injured by the sudden failure of old porcelain toilets, which collapsed under the weight of whoever was sitting on them. Their paper flagged a real risk, linked to the age of the fittings, and urged that it not be underestimated.

For a sysadmin it is a powerful parable about legacy infrastructure: it has worked for decades, nobody checks it, everyone leans on it every day with total trust. Then one morning it gives way, at the least convenient moment. My customer's server in the cellar is the same age as those toilets. I regard it with great respect.