Ig Nobel Prizes 2009
On 1 October 2009, at Harvard's Sanders Theatre, the nineteenth Ig Nobel ceremony is held. The official theme of the evening is risk. Fair enough: every morning I too switch on the office PC without knowing which update awaits me.
Among the winners: affectionate cows, beer bottles, tequila diamonds, a life-saving bra and a few institutions honoured with the Ig Nobel's customary irony.
- Winners
- Fumiaki Taguchi, Song Guofu and Zhang Guanglei (Kitasato University, Japan)
- Citation
- For demonstrating that kitchen refuse can be reduced more than 90% in mass by using bacteria extracted from the faeces of giant pandas.
- Reference
- Studies published in 2001 and 2003 in Japanese scientific journals.
- Winners
- Javier Morales, Miguel Apátiga and Victor M. Castaño (National Autonomous University of Mexico, Mexico)
- Citation
- For creating diamonds from liquid, specifically from tequila.
- Reference
- “Growth of Diamond Films from Tequila”, arXiv, 2008; also published in Reviews on Advanced Materials Science, 2009.
Making synthetic diamond film needs a source of carbon, hydrogen and oxygen in the right proportions. The researchers noticed that a cheap tequila had exactly the right mix. They vaporised it, heated it and obtained ultra-thin layers of diamond. Not jewellery, but useful material for industry.
The charm lies entirely in the paradox: out of a bottle comes the hardest thing in the world, when usually it's the other way round. All I've ever got out of the bottles at the company dinner is passwords forgotten the next day.
- Winners
- The directors, executives and auditors of four Icelandic banks: Kaupthing, Landsbanki, Glitnir and the Central Bank of Iceland (Iceland)
- Citation
- For demonstrating that tiny banks can be rapidly transformed into huge banks, and then back into tiny ones, and that the same can happen to an entire national economy.
The achievement honoured is the 2008 Icelandic financial crisis: within a few years the country's banking system had grown to many times the size of the national economy, then collapsed in a matter of days. The prize, in typical satirical Ig Nobel style, sums up the whole arc in a sentence fit for an economics textbook.
Anyone in IT knows this curve: a project that grows at lightning speed, everyone thrilled, then one day a piece goes missing and it's back to square one. The lesson applies everywhere. Before the big leap, make a backup.
- Winners
- An Garda Síochána, the Irish national police (Ireland)
- Citation
- For writing and presenting more than fifty traffic tickets to Ireland's most feared driver, one Prawo Jazdy, whose name in Polish means “driving licence”.
For years the Irish system logged dozens of offences in the name of Prawo Jazdy, an apparently ubiquitous motorist. Then someone discovered that those two words, printed on Polish licences, are not the holder's name: they mean, precisely, “driving licence”. A wrong-field error, as you'd say in a database.
A classic every developer knows: the form asks for a name, the user copies the label. We've had customers registered as “First Name Surname” for years. The Irish police, at least, found the error and had a laugh about it.
- Winners
- Gideon Gono, governor of the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (Zimbabwe)
- Citation
- For giving people a simple, everyday way to cope with a wide range of numbers, by printing bank notes with denominations ranging from one cent to one hundred trillion dollars.
- Reference
- Gideon Gono's book “Zimbabwe's Casino Economy: Extraordinary Measures for Extraordinary Challenges”, 2008.
During Zimbabwe's hyperinflation the central bank issued ever larger notes, up to one hundred trillion dollars: a one followed by fourteen zeros. The Mathematics prize ironically highlights the educational benefit: everyone learned to count zeros.
As a techie, the first thing I think of is the accounting software. A number field designed for “a few thousand” that suddenly has to hold fourteen zeros. Somewhere, a programmer had a very bad week. I'm fond of him, even without knowing him.
- Winners
- Donald L. Unger (Thousand Oaks, California, USA)
- Citation
- For investigating whether cracking your knuckles causes arthritis, by cracking the knuckles of his left hand, but never those of his right, at least twice a day for more than sixty years.
- Reference
- “Does Knuckle Cracking Lead to Arthritis of the Fingers?”, Arthritis and Rheumatism, 1998.
As a child he'd been told that cracking your knuckles gives you arthritis. Instead of believing it, he started an experiment: left hand yes, right hand no, for sixty years. In the end, no arthritis in either hand. The right hand as control group: touching dedication.
The most patient tester in history. I can't keep a ticket open for more than a week without losing the will. He maintained the protocol for six decades. If there were a prize for discipline, he'd have won it left-handed.
- Winners
- Stephan Bolliger, Steffen Ross, Lars Oesterhelweg, Michael Thali and Beat Kneubuehl (University of Bern, Switzerland)
- Citation
- For determining whether it is better to be smashed over the head with a full bottle of beer or with an empty one.
- Reference
- “Are Full or Empty Beer Bottles Sturdier and Does Their Fracture-Threshold Suffice to Break the Human Skull?”, Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine, 2009.
In assault cases, forensic doctors need to know how much harm an object can do. So these researchers dropped a weight on full and empty bottles, measuring the force needed to break them. Surprise: the empty one is sturdier, and both can cause serious damage. Scientific moral: better no bottle at all.
It's the most Swiss study imaginable: precise, measured, rigorous, applied to a pub brawl. The Peace prize is excellent advice. Bottles are for opening, not for winning arguments.
- Winners
- Katherine K. Whitcome (University of Cincinnati, USA), Daniel E. Lieberman (Harvard University, USA) and Liza J. Shapiro (University of Texas, USA)
- Citation
- For analytically determining why pregnant women don't tip over.
- Reference
- “Fetal Load and the Evolution of Lumbar Lordosis in Bipedal Hominins”, Nature, 2007.
As the bump grows, the centre of gravity shifts forward. And yet mothers-to-be don't topple over. The reason lies in the spine: in women the lower-back curve is spread over more vertebrae and has reinforced joints, so the back can arch without injury. An elegant evolutionary solution.
In practice, evolution planned a hardware upgrade for a temporary workload. Something no server vendor has ever done without asking you to renew the contract and sign in triplicate.
- Winners
- Elena N. Bodnar, Raphael C. Lee and Sandra Marijan (Chicago, Illinois, USA)
- Citation
- For inventing a brassiere that, in an emergency, can be quickly converted into a pair of protective face masks, one for the wearer and one for someone standing nearby.
- Reference
- US patent no. 7,255,627, “Garment Device Convertible to One or More Facemasks”, 2007.
The idea grew out of memories of the Chernobyl disaster and the realisation that, in an emergency, a mask within reach can make all the difference. The bra detaches, splits and becomes two masks. During the ceremony the inventor even demonstrated it live, with the Ig Nobel's customary nonchalance.
It's the principle of redundancy applied to clothing: one device, two functions, no cables. I still carry an emergency USB stick in my pocket. Nobody has ever asked me to turn it into anything.
- Winners
- Catherine Douglas and Peter Rowlinson (Newcastle University, UK)
- Citation
- For showing that cows who have names give more milk than cows that are nameless.
- Reference
- “Exploring Stock Managers' Perceptions of the Human-Animal Relationship on Dairy Farms and an Association with Milk Production”, Anthrozoös, 2009.
Farms where every cow has a name, and is treated as an individual, recorded higher milk yields. The name alone works no miracles, but it's a sign of a more attentive relationship with the animals. And the cows, it seems, appreciate it.
I've always called my servers by name. One is Gino, one is Ornella. Gino hasn't broken down in ten years. Ornella has, but only because I'd named her after a touchy aunt. Science now proves me right.
The panda eats bamboo all day, a plant that's extremely hard to digest. Its gut is home to specialised bacteria that do an exceptional job. The researchers recovered them and set them to work on kitchen scraps: result, mountains of waste reduced to almost nothing. An eco-friendly idea, with a very particular supplier.
It's data compression applied to rubbish. I dream of a similar bacterium for my inbox: you slip it in among the newsletters and overnight it shrinks everything by 90%. I'd call it Panda. It already sounds like an antivirus.