Ig Nobel Prizes 2024
On 12 September 2024, after four years of online-only ceremonies, the Ig Nobels returned live in front of an audience, at MIT in Cambridge (Massachusetts), with a stream as well. The 34th edition honoured coins, trout, drunk worms and an old military project involving pigeons. Paper aeroplanes flew in the hall once more, and nobody had to mute their microphone.
- Winners
- B. F. Skinner, posthumous award (USA)
- Citation
- For experiments to see the feasibility of housing live pigeons inside missiles to guide the flight paths of the missiles.
- Reference
- “Pigeons in a Pelican”, American Psychologist, 1960.
- Winners
- Jacob White, Felipe Yamashita (Germany, Brazil, USA)
- Citation
- For finding evidence that some real plants imitate the shapes of neighboring artificial plastic plants.
- Reference
- “Boquila trifoliolata Mimics Leaves of an Artificial Plastic Host Plant”, Plant Signaling and Behavior, 2022.
Boquila trifoliolata is a Chilean climber known for imitating the leaves of the plants it climbs on. The researchers grew it next to a plastic plant and observed leaves that seemed to imitate the fake one. The mechanism is still debated.
It's plant plagiarism without an original source: the plant copies a copy. It reminds me of certain websites built from the template of another site, itself built from a template. After three rounds nobody knows who invented the button. But everybody has the same button.
- Winners
- Marjolaine Willems, Quentin Hennocq, Roman Hossein Khonsari and colleagues (France, Chile)
- Citation
- For studying whether the hair whorls on people's heads swirl in the same direction in the northern and southern hemispheres.
- Reference
- “Genetic Determinism and Hemispheric Influence in Hair Whorl Formation”, Journal of Stomatology, Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, 2024.
The hair whorl on the crown can turn clockwise or anticlockwise. The team compared children in France and Chile to see whether the direction changed from one hemisphere to the other, as is said, wrongly, of the water in sinks. Some differences emerged, but genetics matters more.
It's the kind of legend that in tech support we call an intermittent bug: everybody swears they've seen it, nobody can reproduce it. I admire people who go and check on the other side of the planet. For a bug like that, I'd at most open a ticket and wait for spring.
- Winners
- Lieven A. Schenk, Tahmine Fadai, Christian Büchel (Switzerland, Germany, Belgium)
- Citation
- For demonstrating that fake medicine that causes painful side effects can be more effective than fake medicine that does not cause painful side effects.
- Reference
- “How Side Effects Can Improve Treatment Efficacy: A Randomized Trial”, Brain, 2024.
The volunteers were given a nasal spray with no active ingredient, presented as a painkiller. One version contained a substance that stung a little, simulating a side effect. Those who felt the sting reported less pain in later tests: if it stings, it must be working.
It's the same principle as software that shows a fake progress bar during an instant operation. Users want to see that something is happening, otherwise they don't trust it. An optimisation nobody notices is a wasted optimisation. So is a placebo that doesn't sting.
- Winners
- James C. Liao (USA)
- Citation
- For demonstrating and explaining the swimming abilities of a dead trout.
- Reference
- “Neuromuscular Control of Trout Swimming in a Vortex Street”, Journal of Experimental Biology, 2004; “Passive Propulsion in Vortex Wakes”, Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 2006.
A dead trout, placed in the wake of vortices behind an obstacle in a water current, sways and moves upstream. It's no miracle: the flexible body responds passively to the vortices and extracts energy from them. Liao observed it and explained it with fluid dynamics.
This discovery finally explains certain colleagues. They stay put, completely motionless, and yet the project moves forward and they move forward with it. It isn't laziness. It's passive propulsion in other people's wake. From today I have a scientific reference to cite in annual appraisals.
- Winners
- Ryo Okabe, Toyofumi F. Chen-Yoshikawa, Takanori Takebe and colleagues (Japan, USA)
- Citation
- For discovering that many mammals are capable of breathing through their anus.
- Reference
- “Mammalian Enteral Ventilation Ameliorates Respiratory Failure”, Med, 2021.
Inspired by certain fish that absorb oxygen through their gut, the researchers delivered oxygen rectally to mice and pigs with respiratory failure, including with an oxygenated liquid. The animals' oxygen levels improved. The idea is to develop an emergency therapy for when the lungs aren't enough.
It's network redundancy applied to the body: if the main link goes down, you switch to the backup one. Nobody thought the second cable was there. Every good sysadmin knows it: the backup line is always where you least expect it.
- Winners
- František Bartoš, Eric-Jan Wagenmakers, Alexandra Sarafoglou, Henrik Godmann and colleagues (Netherlands, Switzerland, Belgium, France, Germany, Hungary, Czech Republic)
- Citation
- For showing, both theoretically and by 350,757 experiments, that when you flip a coin, it tends to land on the same side as it started.
- Reference
- “Fair Coins Tend to Land on the Same Side They Started: Evidence from 350,757 Flips”, arXiv, 2023.
A theory predicted that, because of the way a coin wobbles in flight, the starting side would have a small advantage. Almost fifty people tossed coins for hours, recording everything. Result: about 51 per cent of the time, the starting side wins.
Three hundred and fifty thousand tosses to shift one percentage point. That's the commitment I'd like to see in testing before a release. And now every decision taken by coin toss in the office has a documented security flaw. From today, whoever tosses the coin must declare its initial configuration.
- Winners
- Tess Heeremans, Antoine Deblais, Daniel Bonn, Sander Woutersen (Netherlands, France)
- Citation
- For using chromatography to separate drunk and sober worms.
- Reference
- “Chromatographic Separation of Active Polymer–Like Worm Mixtures by Contour Length and Activity”, Science Advances, 2022.
Chromatography separates the molecules of a mixture according to how they flow along a path. The chemists applied the same principle to live worms, which behave like active polymers: the livelier ones and those made sluggish by alcohol get through the obstacles differently and sort themselves out.
It's a most elegant sorting system, and I wonder why it doesn't yet exist for the exit of office Christmas parties. A corridor with a few well-placed obstacles, and the problem of who drives whom home would be solved by physics.
- Winners
- Saul Justin Newman (Australia, United Kingdom)
- Citation
- For detective work discovering that many of the people famous for having the longest lives lived in places that had lousy birth-and-death recordkeeping.
- Reference
- “Supercentenarian and Remarkable Age Records Exhibit Patterns Indicative of Clerical Errors and Pension Fraud”, bioRxiv, 2024.
Analysing data on supercentenarians, Newman noticed that record ages cluster in areas with poor civil registries, low life expectancy and sometimes pension incentives. The hypothesis: behind many records lie transcription errors or false data, rather than secrets of longevity.
Every sysadmin knows the golden rule: if a figure is too good to be true, check who entered it. I once saw an accounting system with a customer born in 1900 and still a very active buyer. It wasn't longevity. It was the default value of the date field.
- Winners
- Fordyce Ely, William E. Petersen (USA)
- Citation
- For exploding a paper bag next to a cat standing on the back of a cow, as part of a study of how and when cows release their milk.
- Reference
- “Factors Involved in the Ejection of Milk”, Journal of Dairy Science, 1941.
In the 1940s the two researchers were studying how fright affects milk production. To create controlled stress they put a cat on a cow's back and burst a paper bag. The fright reduced the milk released, a clue to the role of stress hormones.
It's the most nineteenth-century test procedure imaginable, and therefore the most honest. No simulations: a cat, a bag, a bang. Sometimes I think our load tests could do with that kind of straightforwardness.
During the Second World War the psychologist designed a guidance system in which trained pigeons pecked at an image of the target on a screen, correcting the missile's course. It worked in the lab, but was never adopted. The prize was collected by his daughter.
It's the oldest example of a guidance system with artificial intelligence, except the intelligence was a pigeon. The Peace prize is a masterpiece of irony: the most peaceful project in military history is the one that never launched. Like a lot of corporate software, come to think of it.