Skip to content
CONTACT

Ig Nobel Prizes 2005

On 6 October 2005 at Harvard's Sanders Theatre ten prizes were handed out, including one to an experiment begun in 1927 and still not finished. The same evening: the alarm clock that runs away, penguins under pressure and swimming in syrup. I watched the pitch drop with the same anxiety with which I watch the progress bar of an update.

AGRICULTURAL HISTORY2005 · #1
Winners
James Watson (New Zealand)
Citation
For his scholarly study entitled “The Significance of Mr. Richard Buckley's Exploding Trousers”.
Reference
“The Significance of Mr. Richard Buckley's Exploding Trousers: Reflections on an Aspect of Technological Change in New Zealand Dairy Farming Between the World Wars”, Agricultural History, vol. 78, no. 3, 2004

In the Thirties, New Zealand farmers used sodium chlorate against an invasive weed. The product, soaked up by clothing and mixed with organic matter, made it flammable, and there were cases of trousers catching fire or exploding. Historian James Watson reconstructed the affair with academic rigour.

A textbook side effect: you solve a problem in the fields and create one in your trousers. Every system update ought to carry this story in its release notes.

PHYSICS2005 · #2
Winners
John Mainstone and the late Thomas Parnell (Australia)
Citation
For the pitch drop experiment, begun in 1927, in which a lump of pitch drips extremely slowly through a funnel, at a rate of roughly one drop every nine years.
Reference
“The Pitch Drop Experiment”, European Journal of Physics, 1984

At the University of Queensland, Thomas Parnell poured pitch into a funnel to show students that a material that looks solid, and shatters under a hammer, is actually an extremely viscous liquid. Then he waited. The drops fall years apart, and for decades nobody managed to see one fall live.

It is the most patient project in the history of science, and the most faithful to my customers' reality: they wait too. The difference is that the pitch, at least, gets there in the end.

MEDICINE2005 · #3
Winners
Gregg A. Miller (USA)
Citation
For inventing Neuticles, artificial testicles for dogs, available in three sizes and three degrees of firmness.
Reference
US Patent no. 5,868,140; book “Going, Going, NUTS!”, 2004

Gregg Miller, in Missouri, thought about neutered dogs and created silicone implants to be inserted during the operation, so the animal keeps its appearance. He turned it into a real business, with thousands of loyal customers, mostly owners worried about their friend's self-esteem.

It is the apotheosis of the user interface: the feature has been removed, but the icon stays in place so as not to disorient anyone. I know entire programs full of decorative buttons like that. Nobody presses them, but heaven help you if you remove them.

LITERATURE2005 · #4
Winners
The Internet entrepreneurs of Nigeria
Citation
For creating and then using e-mail to distribute a bold series of short stories, with a vast cast of characters, that ask readers for a small advance in order to unlock great wealth.

The prize is ironically dedicated to advance-fee email scams, the famous messages from the prince, the official or the banker who needs a small payment in order to transfer you a fortune. The citation treats them as a literary genre, with its fixed plot and recurring characters.

The serious message beneath the joke is a technician's one: no unknown inheritance ever arrives by email. If someone asks you to pay in order to receive money, the story always ends the same way. Like chain letters, but with a bank transfer.

PEACE2005 · #5
Winners
Claire Rind and Peter Simmons (United Kingdom)
Citation
For electrically monitoring the activity of a brain cell in a locust while that locust was watching selected highlights from the film “Star Wars”.
Reference
“Orthopteran DCMD Neuron: A Reevaluation of Responses to Moving Objects”, Journal of Neurophysiology, vol. 68, 1992

Locusts have a neuron specialised in detecting rapidly approaching objects, handy for avoiding collisions in flight inside a swarm. The two Newcastle neuroscientists studied it by showing the insects moving images, including space battle scenes, to understand how their natural collision avoidance works.

The result has also inspired research into crash-avoidance systems for cars. It is the only known case in which watching a science-fiction film during working hours has produced something useful. I remind my boss of it every time.

ECONOMICS2005 · #6
Winners
Gauri Nanda (USA)
Citation
For inventing an alarm clock that runs away and hides, repeatedly, thus ensuring that people do get out of bed, and thus theoretically adding many productive hours to the working day.

Gauri Nanda, at MIT, designed Clocky: an alarm clock on wheels that, when it goes off, rolls off the bedside table and escapes around the room. To switch it off you have to chase it, and by then you are awake. The product really did reach the shops.

It is the snooze button treated as a security vulnerability and closed with a patch on wheels. Brilliant and cruel. I'm waiting for the version for Windows notifications: the update starts, you click “later”, and the PC gets up and walks off into another room.

CHEMISTRY2005 · #7
Winners
Edward Cussler and Brian Gettelfinger (USA)
Citation
For conducting a careful experiment to settle the question of whether people can swim faster or slower in syrup than in water.
Reference
“Will Humans Swim Faster or Slower in Syrup?”, AIChE Journal, vol. 50, no. 11, 2004

An old question, going back as far as Newton and Huygens, divided physicists: in a denser liquid do you swim slower or faster? The two Minnesota chemical engineers filled a pool with water thickened by a food-grade gum and had volunteers swim in it. Result: practically the same speed.

The extra thrust makes up for the extra drag. It is like adding RAM to a PC that is slow because of the antivirus: you get more power, but also more effort. In the end the stopwatch doesn't budge.

BIOLOGY2005 · #8
Winners
Benjamin Smith, Craig Williams, Michael Tyler, Brian Williams and Yoji Hayasaka (Australia)
Citation
For painstakingly smelling and cataloguing the peculiar odours produced by 131 species of frogs when the frogs were feeling stressed.
Reference
“A Survey of Frog Odorous Secretions, Their Possible Functions and Phylogenetic Significance”, Applied Herpetology, vol. 2, 2004

Many frogs, when frightened, release secretions with distinctive smells. The researchers classified 131 of them, with descriptions ranging from peanut to curry, from cut grass to burnt tyre. An olfactory catalogue that helps explain the defensive role of those substances.

A heroic piece of filing, done with the nose instead of a computer. I do something similar with customers' PCs: from the smell I can tell whether the power supply has died or there's a sandwich that has been forgotten in the rucksack for three weeks.

NUTRITION2005 · #9
Winners
Yoshiro Nakamatsu (Japan)
Citation
For photographing and retroactively analysing every meal he has eaten during a period of 34 years, and counting.

Dr Nakamatsu, a Japanese inventor with an enormous number of patents to his name, photographed every dish he ate for over three decades, analysing the effects of diet on energy and health. He did it long before photographing food became a national online sport.

It is the first documented case of a system log applied to dinner. No data lost, no log rotation, permanent archive. My fridge, on the other hand, keeps track of nothing: every time I open it, it's a disaster recovery.

FLUID DYNAMICS2005 · #10
Winners
Victor Benno Meyer-Rochow (Germany and Finland) and Jozsef Gal (Hungary)
Citation
For using basic principles of physics to calculate the pressure that builds up inside a penguin as it expels its excrement.
Reference
“Pressures Produced When Penguins Pooh: Calculations on Avian Defaecation”, Polar Biology, vol. 27, 2003

Some penguins, to avoid soiling the nest, fire their droppings a good distance away. The two researchers measured the range, the consistency of the material and the angle, and used fluid physics to calculate the pressure required. The value turned out to be considerably higher than in humans.

Ballistics applied to everyday life, with real data and a memorable paper title. Every sysadmin should take inspiration: keep your workspace clean by sending problems far away. With accurate calculations. And preferably not at a colleague.