Ig Nobel Prizes 1993
Third edition, again in MIT's Kresge Auditorium, and this year the prizes rise to eleven, one more than usual. The winners include kidnapping aliens, pigs out for a ride in a lorry and a scientific paper signed by nearly a thousand people.
Eleven prizes instead of ten: an off-by-one error nobody wanted to fix. As a developer I understand. When a loop returns one element too many and that element is funny, you call it a feature.
- Winners
- John E. Mack, Harvard Medical School, and David M. Jacobs, Temple University (United States)
- Citation
- For concluding that people who believe they were kidnapped by aliens from outer space probably were, and that the purpose of the abductions was to produce children.
- Reference
- David M. Jacobs, Secret Life, 1992
- Winners
- Ron Popeil (United States)
- Citation
- To the incessant inventor and perpetual pitchman of late-night television, for redefining the industrial revolution with devices such as the Veg-O-Matic, the Pocket Fisherman, Mr. Microphone and the Inside-the-Egg Scrambler.
Popeil was the king of American infomercials: kitchen gadgets and improbable objects presented with live demonstrations and the promise that no, that's not all. The egg scrambler that scrambles the egg without breaking the shell is his most philosophical work.
In him I see the spiritual father of every corporate software presentation. First the problem you didn't know you had, then the solution that does everything, finally the unexpected bonus. All that's missing is the freephone number on screen. Plenty of business software vendors studied under him, even if they won't admit it.
- Winners
- Paul Williams Jr., Oregon State Health Division (United States), and Kenneth W. Newell, Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine (United Kingdom)
- Citation
- For their pioneering study “Salmonella Excretion in Joy-Riding Pigs”, on the effects of lorry transport on the animals.
- Reference
- Salmonella Excretion in Joy-Riding Pigs, American Journal of Public Health, 1970
The study was serious: checking whether the stress of being transported by lorry increased salmonella shedding in pigs, with consequences for food safety. The title, however, spoke of pigs on a joy ride, and that is where the prize became inevitable.
The lesson is universal: travel stresses everyone. I know it well: every time I move a server from one office to another, it comes back with some new error in the logs. It is no coincidence. It is joy-riding pig syndrome, and from today I shall write it in my call-out reports.
- Winners
- Ravi Batra, Southern Methodist University (United States)
- Citation
- To the economist and author of the bestsellers “The Great Depression of 1990” and “Surviving the Great Depression of 1990”, for selling enough copies to single-handedly prevent worldwide economic collapse.
- Reference
- The Great Depression of 1990; Surviving the Great Depression of 1990
Batra predicted a great economic crisis for 1990 and wrote two books to describe it and teach people how to survive it. The crisis of the century never came, but the books sold extremely well. Hence the citation: his publishing success alone saved the economy.
It is the paradox of the alarm: if nobody buys it you are wrong, if lots of people buy it you become the economic activity that disproves the prophecy. Same with the millennium bug: everybody worried, everybody buying updates, and at midnight the printer carried on working badly exactly as before.
- Winners
- Pepsi-Cola Products Philippines (Philippines)
- Citation
- For sponsoring a contest to create a millionaire and then announcing the wrong winning number, thereby uniting 800,000 riotous winners for the first time.
In 1992 a bottle-cap prize contest announced number 349 as the winner. Unfortunately that number had been printed on hundreds of thousands of caps, not just one. Protests and a long tail of lawsuits followed.
Every IT person shivers reading this story: it is the error of the value that was supposed to be unique and wasn't. A database field with no unique constraint, and suddenly you have 800,000 customers with the same prize code. The peace in the title is of course ironic: lots of people united, but all at the complaints desk.
- Winners
- Jay Schiffman (United States) and the Michigan state legislature (United States)
- Citation
- To Jay Schiffman, inventor of AutoVision, an image-projection device that makes it possible to drive and watch television at the same time, and to the Michigan legislature for making it legal.
- Reference
- US Patent 5,061,996
AutoVision projected the images from a television into the driver's field of view, so you no longer had to choose between the road and the news. And according to the citation, in Michigan someone had even seen to making it legal.
It is the ancestor of modern multitasking, the kind everyone claims to be good at and nobody really is. Even I, when I answer the phone while configuring a router, always end up giving the Wi-Fi password to the wrong customer. Imagine doing it on the motorway with a penguin documentary in front of your eyes.
- Winners
- James Campbell and Gaines Campbell (United States)
- Citation
- To the dedicated deliverers of fragrance, for inventing scent strips, the method by which perfume is applied to magazine pages.
These are the paper flaps in magazines that, when opened, release the advertised perfume. A clever invention: advertising that doesn't just get seen, but follows you by the nose.
The trouble is that there is one magazine and twelve fragrances, so in the end leafing through it becomes like visiting a perfume shop where something has exploded. IT people know the phenomenon: it is the web page with twenty pop-up windows opening at once. Each one alone would be bearable. All together, you switch the computer off.
- Winners
- Eric Topol, R. Califf, F. Van de Werf, P. W. Armstrong and 972 other co-authors (16 countries)
- Citation
- For publishing a medical research paper with one hundred times as many authors as pages.
- Reference
- New England Journal of Medicine, 1993
The study was a huge clinical trial of heart attack drugs, carried out in many hospitals across 16 countries. Every centre involved deserved to appear among the authors, and so it reached almost a thousand names for a paper of a few pages.
It is the same phenomenon as company emails with two hundred people in copy to announce that the coffee machine on the second floor is broken. The message is short, the recipient list is a novel. The difference is that here everyone's work was real. In the emails, much less so.
- Winners
- Robert W. Faid (United States)
- Citation
- To the far-seeing visionary of statistics, for calculating the exact odds, 710,609,175,188,282,000 to 1, that Mikhail Gorbachev is the Antichrist.
- Reference
- Gorbachev! Has the Real Antichrist Come?, 1988
Faid wrote a book in which, combining clues and interpretations, he calculated to eighteen digits the probability that the Soviet leader was the figure foretold by the prophecies. The prize passes no judgement on faith: it celebrates precision.
Because the wonderful detail is exactly that: not roughly, not very likely, but an exact number down to the unit. It is the manager who asks for a project estimate and is told 1,247 hours and 18 minutes. The more digits you add, the surer you sound. It is statistics applied to courage rather than to data.
- Winners
- Corentin Louis Kervran (France)
- Citation
- To the ardent admirer of alchemy, for concluding that the calcium in chickens' eggshells is produced by a process of cold fusion.
- Reference
- Corentin Louis Kervran, Biological Transmutations
Kervran claimed that living organisms turned one chemical element into another, for instance that hens produced the calcium for their shells from other elements. In practice, a miniature nuclear power station inside every henhouse.
The idea is irresistible: the hen as a low-power reactor, fuelled by feed and able to change atoms with no energy bills. If it were true, I would already have put one in the server room in place of the UPS. Sadly physics says no, and hens carry on simply laying eggs.
- Winners
- James F. Nolan, Thomas J. Stillwell and John P. Sands Jr. (United States)
- Citation
- For their painstaking research report “Acute Management of the Zipper-Entrapped Penis”.
- Reference
- Acute Management of the Zipper-Entrapped Penis, Journal of Emergency Medicine, 1990
Three doctors wrote an A&E guide to a painful accident that is far more common than you would think: getting caught in your trouser zip. Complete with the recommended technique to free the patient as quickly and painlessly as possible.
It is documentation in the noblest sense of the word: nobody reads it until they desperately need it, and at that moment it becomes the most important text in the world. Like the server manual, which lies untouched for years and then, one night, saves somebody's career.
Two academics collected hundreds of accounts from people describing alien abductions and, instead of looking for psychological explanations, took the stories as factual reports. Complete with a theory of motive: interplanetary breeding programmes.
The method is reminiscent of telephone-only tech support. The user says the computer switches itself on at night and makes strange noises: you note everything, open a file, hypothesise an alien intelligence. Then you go on site and discover automatic updates. At the 1994 ceremony, incidentally, some students turned up as the aliens in question.