“My Way” in Philippine karaoke: how a curse is born

In the Philippines a rumour has been circulating for years: singing at karaoke a famous song made a hit by Frank Sinatra supposedly brings serious trouble. Behind that rumour there are real news events, with real victims, and that's why it deserves to be discussed with respect. The interesting question isn't whether the song is cursed, but how the idea that it is comes about.
What people say
Several news reports, international ones included, have over the years described violent incidents breaking out in Philippine karaoke bars while someone was singing “My Way” specifically. The matter became so well known that some bars, it's said, removed it from their song list, and many amateur singers prefer to avoid it. The number of cases is unclear and varies depending on who reports it.
How a curse is born
A curse, almost always, is a correlation missing its statistics. The most reasonable explanations put forward by those who have observed the phenomenon are very down to earth:
- Popularity. It's among the most sung songs of all. The more a song is played, the more likely it is to be in the background when something happens.
- The context. Crowded venues, the small hours, alcohol: ingredients that make an argument possible to any soundtrack.
- Selective memory. Once the rumour is born, every new incident linked to that song is noticed and connected; those with other songs go unnoticed.
There has also been talk of the nature of the song, a proud summing-up of one's own life that might sound arrogant to some, and of touchiness about performances judged to be bad. These are hypotheses, not certainties.
The mechanism, seen by a technician
Anyone who manages systems knows this trap well. A server freezes twice on a Thursday and the office legend of the cursed Thursday is born. Nobody looks at the three hundred quiet Thursdays, or the freezes that happened on Tuesdays. The story beats the event log, because the story gets remembered and the log doesn't.
With people the mechanism is identical, but the stakes are infinitely higher. A “curse” gives a name and a shape to something frightening and not understood, and it's understandable that it arises. The risk is that it shifts attention away from the real causes, which lie in people and situations, towards a convenient culprit that cannot defend itself: a song.
What remains
The song doesn't harm anyone. The tragedies remain tragedies, and deserve to be remembered as such, not as curiosities to tell over dinner. If there's one lesson to take home, it's the one that applies to all legends: when a coincidence seems too perfect, before looking for a curse it's worth counting how many times nothing happened.
Loosely based on an old piece from the teneraerbetta.it archive