Skip to content
CONTACT

Famous faces in reflections: pareidolia breeds hoaxes

A FAMOUS FACE ON THE BONNET

In the summer of 2009, a few days after the death of Michael Jackson, an English motorist told the papers he had seen the singer's face reflected on the bonnet of his car, in a photo taken to sell it. The story went round the world in a matter of hours. The face, looked at properly, was a cloud.

The brain and facial recognition

The phenomenon has a name: pareidolia. It's the brain's tendency to see familiar shapes, especially faces, in random images: clouds, damp patches on walls, plug sockets, slices of toast. It's facial-recognition software installed as standard, optimised never to miss a face, even at the cost of seeing a few too many.

From an evolutionary point of view it makes sense: better to mistake a bush for a person than the other way round. From a hoax point of view, it's a goldmine. The system has a huge number of false positives and no button for reporting them.

The recipe for viral news

The bonnet case has all the classic ingredients:

  • an event that is on everybody's mind at that moment;
  • an ambiguous image, with reflections and lights open to interpretation;
  • a well-meaning witness who shows the photo to friends;
  • a crowd that, once the name has been suggested, all sees the same thing.

That last point is crucial. Before the caption it's a cloud. After the caption it's impossible not to see a face in it. It's the same principle by which, once someone tells you the computer fan is making a funny noise, you hear it for the rest of your life.

A genre with a long history

Faces of celebrities or religious figures spotted on toast, tree trunks, damp stains and X-rays have featured in the oddball news for decades. None of these cases has ever shown anything more than the normal workings of human perception. To be fair, the people who report them often aren't trying to fool anyone: they're genuinely amazed, just as we all are when a plug socket looks at us with a surprised expression.

Respect before laughter

When the image concerns someone who has just died, the story also touches the grief of those who loved them. Laughing at pareidolia is perfectly fine; laughing at the person, not. The phenomenon is funny; mourning isn't.

The antivirus

If a face appears in a reflection, the test is simple: change the angle, change the light, wait five minutes. If the face disappears, it was the light. On the switched-off monitor of my old PC I see a tired, rather unconvinced face every morning. I've run all the tests. Sadly, that one is real.


Loosely based on an old piece from the teneraerbetta.it archive