Exam legends: the barometer, the columns and Carnot's bicycle

Every university has a secret archive that is not in the library: the exam stories handed down from one year to the next. Nobody has seen them, everybody swears they are true, and every faculty claims they happened right there. It is the first peer-to-peer distribution system in history: no central server, just freshers passing files to each other.
The barometer and the skyscraper
The professor asks how to measure the height of a skyscraper with a barometer. The student suggests lowering it on a string and measuring the string. Not good enough. So he drops it and times the fall. Not good enough. Then the pendulum, then the shadows in the sun. Finally the definitive solution: give the barometer to the caretaker in exchange for the height of the building.
This story has been going round for decades, attributed to different faculties and scientists, and has never turned up in an exam record. But it has one merit: it is the manifesto of every sysadmin. There are always six technical solutions and only one that really works, namely asking someone who knows.
The portico columns
A professor asks how many columns there are in the university portico. The student does not know: failed, because "he does not attend". The next student, crafty, runs outside to count them. Correct answer. Failed as well: "instead of studying, he counts columns".
It is the classic exam with no exit path, like certain online returns procedures: whatever you click, you end up back on the home page. An infinite loop with the university stamp on it.
Philosophy in motion
Two gems from the same legendary faculty. In the first, the student has to refute Zeno's paradox of motion: he stands up and walks. "Good, keep refuting it," says the professor. As far as the door, then the corridor, then home, until the next exam session.
In the second, the professor shows a bunch of keys and asks the student to prove they are his. The student stammers, is dismissed, and heads for the exit with the keys in his pocket. "Where are you going with my keys?" There: proven. Passed. It is the only known case of proof of possession solved without a password and without two-factor authentication.
Creative physics
The professor asks for a drawing of the Carnot cycle. The student draws a circle. "Good, now draw another next to it. Now join them with a line. Perfect: take your bicycle and go." (In Italian, "ciclo" also means bike.) Another version tells of a bunch of keys thrown at the student with the question "what kind of motion is this?", and the student throwing them back: "the same as this".
In chemistry, meanwhile, a student confidently states that a certain stone dissolves in water. The professor invites him to come back when the city's most famous bridge has dissolved into the river. Textbook jokes, in the sense that they were probably already in a joke book.
The line that came back
An exasperated lecturer asks a student to draw a straight line and never stop. He carries on past the blackboard, along the wall, out of the door. A few minutes later he knocks at the other door of the lecture room, chalk in hand, and closes the line where he started it. The building was circular.
It is geometry, it is theatre, and it is also the exact description of a network cable that runs all round the office and comes back into the same switch. In IT, a loop does not get you a pass: it gets you a network meltdown.
The gift that costs a resit
A perfect private law exam. The delighted professor gives the student his own luxury watch. After much hesitation, she accepts. He then reminds her that donating a valuable item requires a formal deed: come back at the next session.
Technically it is a legal man-in-the-middle attack. Historically, nobody knows where it happened. Like all these legends, it is true at every university and documented at none.
Present!
Finally, the register full of improbable names, signed up as a joke by bored students: singers, TV presenters, medieval heroines. The professor loses patience on the very last one, and from the back of the room a little voice answers "present". Because every register, like every database, contains at least one record nobody has the courage to delete.
Loosely based on an old piece from the teneraerbetta.it archive