
Every so often someone at the counter asks me, in a low voice: “Is Windows a virus?”. It's a serious question and deserves a scientific answer. So I carried out a comparative study, with rigorous method and a great deal of coffee.
The similarities
- It installs itself. A virus arrives without asking. Windows, every so often, arrives with an update you didn't ask for. First point in favour of the hypothesis.
- It takes up space. A virus fills the disk. Windows, after a few years, has a mysterious folder the size of a county. Second point.
- It asks to restart. Some viruses restart the computer. Windows asks politely, then less politely, then does it at three in the morning while you were exporting a video. Third point.
- It pushes you to buy new hardware. On this I say nothing. I have a laptop from 2015 that's looking at me.
At this point in the investigation the hypothesis seemed confirmed. I had even drafted the press release.
The differences
Then I dug deeper, and the data changed everything. A real virus has very precise characteristics.
- A virus never asks your permission. Windows always asks, even when you've already said yes.
- A virus doesn't have a progress bar that sits at 99% for forty minutes. A virus is in a hurry.
- A virus doesn't explain what it's doing. Windows tells you: “We're getting a few things ready”. Which things? Nobody knows. But it's getting them ready with love.
- A virus doesn't have a support line with hold music.
The verdict
So no, Windows is not a virus. A virus does one thing only and does it with determination. Windows does a great many things, many of them well, and some of them precisely while you're trying to do something else.
My official conclusion, after years of tech support, is this: Windows is not a virus. It's a flatmate. It helps you, keeps you company, and every now and then reorganises the kitchen without asking. And in the end you're fond of it anyway. Especially when it restarts on its own and, for once, fixes everything.
Loosely based on an old piece from the teneraerbetta.it archive