Skip to content
CONTACT

Immortal hoaxes: the ones that survive every debunking

THE HOAXES THAT NEVER DIE

News goes off like yoghurt. Hoaxes, on the other hand, are like those programs that reinstall themselves at every reboot: you delete them, you empty the recycle bin, and the next day they are back, with a bigger icon. Here is a selection of the most stubborn.

Why debunking is not enough

Spreading a false story takes a minute. Debunking it takes a week, a source, an expert and a lot of patience. And often it is not enough: people who study the psychology of communication have repeatedly observed that a correction can reinforce, in those who already believed, the very idea it was meant to dismantle. Like pressing "delete" and getting a backup copy.

Perfect example: the famous line about slandering boldly because "something will always stick", attributed to a great French philosopher. Shame it does not appear anywhere in his writings. It is a hoax about hoaxes, and that is why everyone remembers it. Pure recursion.

Crocodiles in the sewers

Beneath the streets of a great American metropolis there supposedly live colonies of alligators, descended from babies bought as souvenirs and then flushed down the toilet. In the dark they apparently turned white, blind and hungry.

A few isolated sightings of animals in improbable places really did make the papers, and from there the legend built an entire underground civilisation. The colonies, however, have never been found. Sewers are cold, dirty and inhospitable for a tropical reptile. I say so with the authority of someone who has run cables through certain basements: down there only technicians and spiders survive.

Nails and hair after death

An ancient and very widespread belief: after death, hair and nails keep growing. It is false. What happens is that the skin dries out and retracts, so nails and hair look longer.

It is an optical illusion mistaken for data. In IT we know it well: the disk has not got bigger, the files have been compressed. The system is the same; only the way you look at it changes.

Waking up in a bath of ice

A young man spends an evening in town, accepts a drink from a stranger and wakes up in a bath full of ice, with a scar and a note: call an ambulance, you are missing a kidney.

This story has travelled by fax, email and social media with the punctuality of an automatic update. No verified case matching the tale has ever emerged: a transplant requires hospitals, teams, compatibility, not a bathtub and a bucket of ice. But fear works better than medicine, and it has inspired quite a few TV series too.

The licked hand

The campfire story par excellence: a girl alone at home, noises in the night, and every time she wakes up she reaches under the bed, where her dog licks her hand to reassure her. The next morning she discovers the dog had been gone for hours, and someone else had been keeping her company.

There is nothing to debunk: it is a horror story pretending to be news. Its strength lies entirely in the ending, like certain films you only watch for the last minute. The technical advice still stands: before trusting a signal, check who is sending it.

When the newspapers fall for it

The beauty of hoaxes is that they spare nobody, not even those who are supposed to act as the antivirus. A few famous cases:

  • The presidential emails. A British paper published, as a joke, fake emails from the American president to world leaders, including a list of tech gifts for the North Korean dictator. An Asian newspaper took it seriously and ran it. Satire without the "satire" label is like a file with no extension: everyone opens it with whatever program they like.
  • The restaurant that was not there. An American writer entered an invented Milanese restaurant for a wine award, with a wine list deliberately chosen from the worst bottles, to show how serious the criteria were. The imaginary restaurant won.
  • The invented music slang. In the early Nineties a major American newspaper published a dictionary of grunge fans' slang. The words had been made up on the spot by the person interviewed, and the paper printed them in all seriousness.
  • The child who did not exist. A moving report about a child drug addict, published by an important American newspaper, even won a prestigious prize. When readers asked where the boy was so they could help him, it emerged that the child had been invented. The prize was returned.

We are the antivirus

Moral: no filter is perfect, not even a newsroom's. The only antivirus that is always up to date is a simple question: who says so, and how do they know? It costs nothing, does not slow your computer down and never asks you to renew the licence.


Loosely based on an old piece from the teneraerbetta.it archive