Skip to content
CONTACT

If everything is an opinion, the hoax always wins

IF IT'S ALL OPINION, HOAXES WIN

There's an idea that's very popular online: all points of view are equal, everyone has their own truth, and anyone who asks for evidence is a killjoy. It looks like open-mindedness. In reality it's a door left open, and urban legends walk in through it without even wiping their feet.

The server with no access control

Imagine a server where anyone can write anything, and where every file is worth exactly as much as every other. The technical manual weighs the same as the next-door neighbour's comment. After a week you can't find the manual any more. The comment, on the other hand, has been copied into hundreds of folders.

Relativism applied to facts works like this. Opinions are legitimate, and so are tastes. But the date of a battle, the distance between the Earth and the Moon or the number of kidneys in your body are not opinions. They're data. They can be verified.

Become anyone, believe anything

In the golden years of the internet there was a contagious enthusiasm: technology would let us become whoever we wanted. In part it was true, and it was wonderful. But an identity you change like a shirt risks bringing with it a worldview to be changed every morning too, picking whichever version of the facts is most convenient.

Into that wardrobe also slip those who rewrite history at will: if everything is a point of view, why not what's documented too? It's not a side effect of the internet. It's a genuine vulnerability, and it should be treated as such.

The three-point patch

  • Distinguish between a taste, an opinion and a fact. Only the third can be verified, and it should be.
  • Ask for the source, and then the source's source. The friend of the cousin doesn't have a valid certificate.
  • Don't mistake “lots of people say so” for proof: lots of people get spam too.

Respecting all people doesn't oblige you to agree with all claims. I, for example, deeply respect those who maintain that the Wi-Fi is stronger if you put the router on top of the fridge. But I'm not moving it. I've measured it.


Loosely based on an old piece from the teneraerbetta.it archive