A CD on the dashboard against speed cameras: a reflected legend

Once upon a time people hung lucky charms, red horns and little mascots from the rear-view mirror. Then, at some point, CDs appeared. Not to listen to: to blind the speed camera. So says the legend, at least, which turned an installation disc into a technological talisman.
The two schools of thought
Believers are divided into two currents, almost like religious denominations of electronics.
- The flash school. The disc, shiny as it is, supposedly reflects the camera flash and ruins the photo.
- The beam school. The disc supposedly deflects the laser or radar beam, making the car invisible like a stealth aircraft.
Both share the same flaw: none of the faithful has ever seen the miracle in person. Everyone knows someone who knows someone it worked for.
Why it does not work
Speed-measuring devices calculate the movement of the car as a whole, and the photo is mainly there to read the number plate, which is outside the cabin. A disc hung behind the windscreen is like putting a "do not disturb" sticker on your monitor in the hope that it will block Windows updates: a kind thought, zero effect.
The police, asked several times, have ruled out that the trick works. And there are no serious studies saying otherwise. One practical detail should be added: devices designed specifically to interfere with speed detectors are not allowed under the highway code. So if the CD really worked, it would be one more problem, not one fewer.
How a digital talisman is born
The legend has a fascinating origin: it takes a technological object, shiny and a little mysterious, and attributes powers to it that it does not have. It is the same mechanism by which some users keep their phone next to the router "to get better signal" or blow into the USB port before plugging in a memory stick.
In some countries, moreover, a CD hung from the mirror is simply a cheap, sparkly decoration, with no anti-fine pretensions whatsoever. And that is perhaps the most honest use: an object that is no longer good for anything, recycled as an ornament. Like those old floppy disks that became coasters.
The real anti-fine device
There is a foolproof system for not being photographed by a speed camera, tested by millions of drivers: keeping to the speed limit. It costs nothing, needs no updates and works with any model of car.
My cousin, on the other hand, hung the complete set of a twelve-disc multimedia encyclopaedia in his rear window. The fine came anyway. But, he says, his car is now the best-read in the car park.
Loosely based on an old piece from the teneraerbetta.it archive