Skip to content
CONTACT

Gilb's Laws of Unreliability

USERS AND SUPPORT

Computers are unreliable, but humans are even more unreliable; and any system that depends on human reliability is unreliable.

— Tom Gilb, Laws circulated in 1970s collections (e.g. Arthur Bloch); numbering and wording vary between sources (attribution partly uncertain)
VIDEO.EXE16:9

Computers make mistakes, yes. But they always make them the same way, and sooner or later you work it out. Humans make mistakes creatively: today the password on a sticky note, tomorrow the sticky note on the screen, the day after the screen photographed and shared in the family group chat.

The lesson is an engineer's: don't design systems that only work if everyone is paying attention. People are tired, distracted, in a hurry. Automatic checks, confirmations and backups exist for them.

One company had a foolproof backup procedure: every evening an employee swapped the disk. It worked for years. Then the employee retired. The disk is still there, inserted since 2015, as faithful as a dog waiting at the station.