Skip to content
CONTACT

Weinberg's Law

PROJECTS AND PEOPLE

If builders built buildings the way programmers write programs, the first woodpecker that came along would destroy civilisation.

— Gerald Weinberg, Uncertain attribution: appears in a 1975 collection (CoEvolution Quarterly) and as 'Weinberg's Second Law' in Arthur Bloch's Murphy's Law, 1977
VIDEO.EXE16:9

A real building has foundations, structural calculations, inspections. The average program has a library downloaded at three in the morning, maintained by a stranger, on which a bank, a hospital and the coffee machine all depend.

The law isn't just a dig: it reminds us that computing is a young discipline, with fewer regulations and fewer inspections than construction. Much of what we use holds up through goodwill and luck.

Once I saw a woodpecker on the roof of our warehouse, right above the server room. I stood between it and the aerial. We looked at each other for a long time. In the end it left. I think it understood it wasn't necessary: the server would break by itself, on Monday.