Skip to content
CONTACT

Segal's Law

DATA AND BACKUPS

A man with a watch knows what time it is. A man with two watches is never sure.

— Anonymous, Saying that appeared in the San Diego Union in 1930; later misattributed to Lee Segall and made famous as 'Segal's Law' in Arthur Bloch's books (uncertain attribution)
VIDEO.EXE16:9

With a single watch you have no doubts: you're wrong with complete serenity. With two watches showing different times, the crisis begins. Which one is right? With three, you set up a committee.

In computing it's the drama of multiple sources. The price list lives in the management system, in the salesman's Excel sheet and in the PDF sent to the client. They're three different numbers, and all of them are called 'the up-to-date one'. That's why people who design serious systems talk about a single source of truth: one place everyone reads from, and the others copy.

It applies to servers too: if the clocks of the computers on a network aren't synchronised, the logs tell impossible stories, with answers arriving before the questions. I've solved it at the office. I removed every clock but one. It stopped in 2016, but nobody argues any more.